| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
(Circulation. 1997;95:2271-2276.)
© 1997 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Departments of Nephrology and Hypertension (G.L., P.J.B., H.A.K.) and Clinical Neurophysiology (P.L.O., G.H.W., A.C. van H.), University Hospital Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Correspondence to H.A. Koomans, MD, Department of Nephrology and Hypertension, University Hospital Utrecht, Room F03.226, PO Box 85500, 3508 GA Utrecht, Netherlands.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results Fourteen healthy subjects underwent CPT, lower-body negative pressure (LBNP; -45 mm Hg for 60 minutes), or the combination thereof. CPT alone caused vasoconstriction and increased muscle sympathetic nerve activity, followed by uneventful relaxation. When applied during reduced cardiac output, tachycardia, and vasoconstriction induced by prior LBNP for 6 minutes, CPT again caused vasoconstriction, now followed by acute hypotension in 10 subjects, and was associated with vasorelaxation, relative bradycardia, and fall in muscle sympathetic nerve activity. Eight subjects also experienced acute LBNP-induced hypotension in the absence of CPT, but not until 17±6 minutes of LBNP. We also performed CPT before and in the final phase of hemodialysis in 8 patients. Before dialysis, the patients tolerated CPT uneventfully, but during hemodialysis, CPT provoked acute hypotension in 5 cases, showing similar withdrawal of vasoconstriction.
Conclusions This is the first study showing that brief cold stress, tolerated well in normal circulatory conditions, can provoke sudden sympathoinhibition and hypotension when applied during decreased cardiac output induced by LBNP or hemodialysis. We suggest that during conditions of a decreased cardiac output, subtle sympathetic relaxation such as follows cold stress triggers self-enhancing relaxation that cannot be controlled.
Key Words: syncope cardiac output reflex physiology sympathoinhibition
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
20% of treatment sessions.1 Its pathogenesis is still
uncertain. However, it is clear that progressive hypovolemia due to
gradual volume withdrawal plays a central role.1 2 The
physiological response to hypovolemia is
sympathetic excitation and vasoconstriction.3 However, in
healthy subjects, progressive hypovolemia can evoke sudden withdrawal
of sympathetic activity, causing vasodilation, bradycardia, and
profound hypotension.3 Such a paradoxical reflex
withdrawal has been shown during progressive
hemorrhage4 and during lower-body negative
pressure (LBNP),5 6 7 which is used to simulate progressive
hypovolemia in humans. The same paradoxical reaction may be involved in
dialysis hypotension, because Converse et al8 recently
described sudden withdrawal of reflex vasoconstriction in seven
patients experiencing dialysis hypotension. Sudden paradoxical sympathoinhibition occurring during hypovolemia is known as the Bezold-Jarisch reflex. The background theory is that progressive emptying of the left ventricle causes forceful contraction and activation of cardiac mechanoreceptors.3 9 This inhibits cardiovascular centers through vagal afferents, overruling the stimulation caused by arterial baroreceptor deactivation. However, this concept is hardly complete; whereas the alleged trigger for this event, progressive ventricular emptying, is a gradual process, sympathoinhibition is an abrupt and unpredictable phenomenon. Clinically, it seems that once a vasodilatory reflex starts, it is self-enhancing and does not turn off unless ventricular filling is restored. Indeed, immediate recovery after saline infusion or head-down tilt is well known.1 2
The hypothesis of the present study is that brief, subtle release of the tight sympathetic vasoconstriction during hypovolemia cannot be adequately controlled and triggers a full-blown vasodilatory syncope. We based this hypothesis on the idea that the slightest additional decrease in ventricular filling, caused by subtle fall in afterload, starts an uncontrolled vasodilatory response, whereas normally such relaxation will pass uneventfully. Such a finding would greatly improve our understanding of sudden sympathoinhibitory hypotension, but this possibility has never been tested. In the present study, we induced brief cold stress, causing sympathetic relaxation after brief excitation, in healthy volunteers in whom cardiac output was reduced by LBNP. Strikingly, many of them responded with vasodilatory presyncope. Microneurography, performed in a subset of subjects, demonstrated an exaggerated fall in sympathetic activity after cold stress was stopped. Brief cold stress could also induce sudden hypotension in patients during hemodialysis. It thus appears that sudden dialysis hypotension may arise by brief superimposed fluctuation of sympathetic activity.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Experimental Design in Healthy Subjects
Each subject underwent LBNP twice. To this end, they were
positioned supine in an airtight acrylic plastic box to the level of
the iliac crests. After the subject had rested for 30 minutes in the
LBNP box, -45 mm Hg LBNP was applied for 60 minutes or a shorter
period if presyncopal signs occurred. The other LBNP experiment was
performed in a similar way, except a cold pressor test (CPT) was
performed after 6 minutes of LBNP. Furthermore, a CPT was performed
separately from LBNP. The order of these studies was randomized, with a
60-minute recovery period after each LBNP experiment. Presyncope
was defined as a systolic pressure decrease of >30 mm Hg
in <20 seconds. The CPT consisted of immersion of the left hand up to
the wrist into ice slush for 60 seconds.
Arterial pressure and heart rate were recorded
continuously on the right upper extremity by use of finger photo
plethysmography (Finapres). Cardiac index was measured by thoracic
impedance cardiography (Bomed). Forearm blood flow was measured by
venous occlusion plethysmography using a mercury-insilicone elastomer
strain gauge. Forearm vascular resistance was calculated by dividing
mean arterial pressure by forearm blood flow and was
expressed as resistance units. In a subset of subjects (n=8), muscle
sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) was recorded throughout the
experiments. A unipolar tungsten microelectrode was inserted into a
fascicle of the peroneal nerve posterior to the fibular head by use of
the technique of Vallbo et al.10 The neural signal was
filtered (bandwidth, 500 to 2000 Hz), rectified, and integrated (time
constant, 0.1 second). Sympathetic bursts were identified by their
characteristic morphology and relationship to R waves on the ECG. The
correct position of the electrode was confirmed by the characteristic
response to a Valsalva maneuver (Fig 1
).
|
Experimental Design in Hemodialysis Patients
Eight hemodialysis patients underwent a CPT before a regular
4-hour hemodialysis session. A second CPT was performed 30 minutes
before the end of dialysis and, if no hypotension occurred, a third CPT
followed at 10 minutes before the end of dialysis. During hemodialysis,
fluid was removed by constant ultrafiltration to achieve dry weight,
which was estimated individually by use of standard clinical methods.
Dialysis was performed with polysulfone artificial kidneys using
bicarbonate as dialysate buffer. Arterial pressure, cardiac
index, and peripheral vascular resistance were recorded
as outlined above for 3-minute periods at 0, 1, 2, and 3 hours of
dialysis and continuously during the final 30 minutes of dialysis.
Data Analysis
Beat-to-beat recordings of blood pressure and heart rate
were averaged per minute. Forearm vascular resistance was calculated
per 10 seconds and averaged per minute. Cardiac index was measured once
per minute. Data during presyncope were synchronized to the lowest
value of systolic blood pressure. Data are presented as
mean±SD. Data were analyzed with repeated measures ANOVA and
Bonferroni multiple comparison post hoc tests. A value of
P<.05 was considered significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
Healthy Volunteers: LBNP Combined With CPT
In the absence of LBNP, the CPT evoked the classic pressor and
tachycardic responses, with uneventful normalization to baseline values
within two minutes after the test (Fig 2D
). MSNA increased from 16±3
to 30±4 bursts/min during CPT (P<.0001) and returned to
17±6 bursts/min in 2 minutes after the CPT was stopped.
When applied in the seventh minute of LBNP, the CPT again caused a
pressor response and a further increase in heart rate. However, in 10
subjects, discontinuation of the test was followed by acute hypotension
after 100±40 seconds that was associated with vasorelaxation and
relative bradycardia (Fig 2B
), and LBNP had to be stopped. In the other
4 subjects, LBNP was continued uneventfully (Fig 2C
). Notably,
hypotension after CPT occurred in all subjects who also experienced
hypotension during LBNP alone, but CPT advanced its occurrence to 9±1
minutes (P<.001). Similar to the hypotension occurring
"spontaneously" during LBNP, this hypotensive phase was
associated with unchanged cardiac index, relative bradycardia, and fall
in peripheral vascular resistance (Table
). MSNA,
recorded in 5 subjects experiencing hypotension, increased
significantly during LBNP, showed a further nonsignificant increase
during the superimposed CPT, and then dropped during the hypotensive
phase. A representative recording is given in
Fig 4
.
|
Hemodialysis Patients
Before dialysis, all eight patients tolerated the CPT uneventfully
(data not shown). However, when performed in the final half hour of
dialysis, CPT evoked acute hypotension in five patients (30 minutes
from the end of dialysis in one patient and 10 minutes from the end of
dialysis in four patients). By this time, 3.2±0.5 L (92±2% of the
estimated volume excess) had been withdrawn. Sequential changes in
these five patients show a fall in cardiac index accompanied by a
gradual decrease in blood pressure and an increase in heart rate and
vascular resistance (Fig 5
). Cold stress caused an
increase in blood pressure, heart rate, and vascular resistance. After
the cold stimulus was stopped, symptomatic hypotension and
vasodilation followed within minutes, necessitating a temporary break
in dialysis. The hemodynamic data were very similar to
those obtained in the healthy subjects during LBNP and cold stress
(Table
).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
LBNP and hemodialysis caused cardiac output reduction and vasoconstriction, which are well-known effects.3 5 6 7 8 11 12 Increased MSNA, a direct sign of sympathetic excitation, has been shown previously during LBNP5 6 7 8 and in a few patients during hemodialysis.8 During prolonged LBNP, 8 of the present 14 healthy subjects showed sudden sympathoinhibition, vasodilation, bradycardia, and hypotension. This Bezold-Jarisch reflex, elsewhere coined vasovagal collapse, cardiac depressor reflex,13 or ventricular syncope,9 is also known from the literature,3 but until now, only a few cases have been reported in which sympathetic withdrawal was actually proven with MSNA.6 7 8
The hypothesis of the present study was that the sympathetic relaxation that automatically follows a bout of sympathetic excitation would trigger sympathoinhibition if it occurred in conditions of reduced cardiac output. To study this, we used brief cold stress. Cold stress increases sympathetic activity through a central neural mechanism.14 15 This is independent of the baroreflex, and cold stress is used to test the efferent limb of the sympathetic arc.16 The usual response to cold stress is sympathetic excitation and vasoconstriction during the stimulus, followed by gradual relaxation over 1 to 2 minutes after it.14 Normally, the relaxation phase passes uneventfully, probably because in resting conditions, the dependence of the circulation on sympathetic drive is limited. Apparently, and in agreement with the hypothesis, it is different during hemodialysis or LBNP, when cardiac output is decreased and maintenance of arterial pressure depends strongly on tight sympathetic vasoconstriction.5 6 7 8 11 12 In such conditions, it may become difficult to control relaxation, which then can proceed to overt sympathoinhibition.
To explain the present findings, we propose that the vasorelaxation that follows the cold stress decreases cardiac afterload and that the resultant ventricular emptying may trigger a Bezold-Jarisch reflex if basal cardiac output and ventricular volume are critically low. Typically, the vasodepressor reflex occurred only if cardiac output was first decreased, either by LBNP or, in the patients, by progressive volume removal during hemodialysis. Brief sympathetic excitation followed by relaxation may thus offset the delicate balance between low ventricular volume and high peripheral resistance that exists during hypovolemia. Another option is that the Bezold-Jarisch reflex was brought about by cold stressinduced adrenaline release.17 Adrenaline may cause excessive stimulation of cardiac vagal afferents that are preactivated by hypovolemia.9 13 High plasma adrenaline levels have been associated with sympathoinhibitory syncope,6 and it has been shown that the ß-agonist isoproterenol can induce sympathoinhibition when infused during head-up tilt.18 We cannot exclude this possibility, but the fact that we never observed presyncope during the cold stress but only in the relaxation phase after it argues against this. In addition, the adrenaline release during cold stress, even when prolonged, is very modest.17
Underlying the hypothesis of our study was the question why sympathoinhibitory hypotension that occurs in progressive hypovolemia is so abrupt and unpredictable, whereas the alleged stimulus for this reflex, progressive left ventricular emptying, is a gradual process. Although we cannot answer this question directly, our data suggest a likely explanation. It is assumed that hypovolemia, arriving at a certain severe stage, starts to activate cardiac mechanoreceptors and vagal afferents. This opposes the disinhibition of the brain cardiovascular centers established previously by deactivation of cardiac and arterial stretch receptors.3 9 13 We surmise that although this start may be gradual, the first slight decrease in sympathetic tone that occurs at this stage can trigger a full sympathoinhibitory reflex, in accordance with the findings described herein after brief cold stress. Thus, the takeover by the vagal inhibitory afferents cannot be gradual, as it tends to be self-enhancing.
The interactive effects of LBNP and acute cold stress or isometric exercise on sympathetic drive received attention in previous studies. Briefly, additive rather than potentiating effects on sympathetic activity were found,19 20 21 22 indicating independence of sympathetic excitation by the baroreflex and somatic pressor reflex mechanisms. Notably, in none of the studies was sudden hypotension reported, but LBNP was either moderate and nonhypotensive19 21 22 or not continued beyond the additional sympathetic stimulus.20 The orthostatic intolerance that occurs after exhaustive exercise is probably a different phenomenon, as it may still be present after a half hour of recovery.23 Also different is the phenomenon that sustained mild isometric exercise or cold environment may improve tolerance to LBNP24 25 or hemodialysis,12 probably by enhancing sympathetic drive and vasoconstriction. In none of these studies was the effect of stopping exercise or cold stress mentioned.
The present data help to clarify dialysis hypotension, a major and disabling problem of hemodialysis.1 2 Recently, this problem has grown because of the increased use of high-flux dialysis, which shortens dialysis time but increases the risk of a critical decrease in blood volume, and the increased admission of older patients to dialysis. Classically, dialysis hypotension has been ascribed to a progressive decrease in cardiac output, insufficiently compensated for by increased peripheral resistance. For the latter, many factors have been implicated, such as autonomic dysfunction related to uremia,26 electrolyte changes or use of acetate as dialysate buffer,26 27 increased body temperature,26 incompatibility of dialysis membranes,26 and, recently, the release of vasodilating substances such as nitric oxide28 and adenosine.29 The present study does not refute these ideas. However, they offer no explanation for the abrupt sympathoinhibitory manifestations of dialysis hypotension, which are the rule rather than the exception.11 Our data indicate that during the progressive hypovolemia that occurs during hemodialysis, subtle fluctuations in vasomotor tone, possibly but not necessarily related to any of the above factors, can trigger acute sympathoinhibition.
Clearly, detailed studies of the initiation of a sympathetic withdrawal reflex will be needed to explore this concept further. In this regard, cold stress is a useful tool, but parallel tests have to be examined too. In theory, fluctuations in vasomotor tone during hemodialysis may be caused by any kind of intermittent stress or the release of small amounts of vasodilators. It remains to be determined whether fluctuations in vasomotor tone can trigger a sympathetic withdrawal reflex in hypovolemic conditions in general rather than exclusively during hemodialysis or LBNP. Furthermore, a similar mechanism should be considered in vasodepressor syncope of exercise, aortic stenosis, infusion of nitro compounds, and myocardial infarction.9 Finally, we do not know whether patients with decreased ventricular function will be more sensitive to this phenomenon. Thus, we expect that the present observations will give further impetus to the exploration of this frightening and stressful phenomenon of paradoxical sympathoinhibition.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received October 31, 1996; accepted December 2, 1996.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2.
Koomans HA, Blankestijn PJ. Blood volume
preservation in dialysis: tools and strategies. Nephrol
Dial Transplant. 1995;10:1791-1793.
3.
Schadt JC, Ludbrook J.
Hemodynamic and neurohumoral responses to acute
hypovolemia in conscious mammals. Am J Physiol. 1991;260:H305-H318.
4. Sander-Jensen K, Secher NH, Bie P, Warberg J, Schwartz TW. Vagal slowing of the heart rate during haemorrhage: observations from 20 consecutive hypotensive patients. Br Med J. 1986;292:364-366.
5.
Sander-Jensen K, Mehlsen J, Stadeager C, Christensen
NJ, Fahrenkrug J, Schwartz TW, Warberg J, Bie P. Increase in
vagal activity during hypotensive lower-body negative pressure in
humans. Am J Physiol. 1988;255:R149-R156.
6.
Rowell LB, Seals DR. Sympathetic activity
during graded central hypovolemia in hypoxemic humans.
Am J Physiol. 1990;259:H1197-H1206.
7. Sanders JS, Ferguson DW. Profound sympathoinhibition complicating hypovolemia in humans. Ann Intern Med. 1989;111:439-441.
8. Converse RL, Jacobsen TN, Jost CMT, Toto RD, Grayburn PA, Obregon TM, Fouad-Tarazi F, Victor RG. Paradoxical withdrawal of reflex vasoconstriction as a cause of hemodialysis-induced hypotension. J Clin Invest. 1992;90:1657-1665.
9. Abboud FM. Ventricular syncope: is the heart a sensory organ? N Engl J Med. 1989;320:390-392.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
10.
Vallbo AB, Hagbarth KE, Torebjork HE, Wallin BG.
Somatosensory, proprioceptive, and sympathetic activity in human
peripheral nerves. Physiol Rev. 1979;59:919-957.
11. Santoro A, Mancini E, Spongano M, Rossi M, Paoloini F, Zuchelli P. A haemodynamic study of hypotension during haemodialysis using electrical bioimpedance cardiography. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 1990;5:147-153.
12. Yu AW, Ing TS, Zabaneh RI, Daugirdas JT. Effect of dialysate temperature on central hemodynamics and urea kinetics. Kidney Int. 1995;48:237-243.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
13. Rowell LB. Human Cardiovascular Control. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 1993:116-161.
14.
Victor RG, Leimbach WN, Seals DR, Wallin BG, Mark
AL. Effects of cold pressor test on muscle nerve activity in
humans. Hypertension. 1987;9:429-436.
15.
Schobel HP, Schmieder RE, Hartmann S, Schächinger
H, Luft FC. Effects of bromocriptine on
cardiovascular regulation in healthy humans.
Hypertension. 1995;25:1075-1082.
16. Johnson RH, Spalding JMK. Disorders of the Autonomic Nervous System. Oxford, UK: Blackwell Press; 1974:33-58.
17. Stratton JR, Halter JB, Hallstrom AP, Caldwell JH, Ritchie JL. Comparative plasma catecholamine and hemodynamic response to handgrip, cold pressor test and supine bicycle exercise testing in normal subjects. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1983;2:93-104.[Abstract]
18. Almquist A, Goldenberg IF, Milstein S, Chen M-Y, Chen X, Hansen R, Gornick CC, Benditt DG. Provocation of bradycardia and hypotension by isoproterenol and upright posture in patients with unexplained syncope. N Engl J Med. 1989;320:346-351.[Abstract]
19. Walker JL, Abboud FM, Mark AL, Thames MD. Interaction of cardiopulmonary and somatic reflexes in humans. J Clin Invest. 1980;65:1491-1497.
20.
Ebert TJ, Stowe DF, Barney JA, Kalbfleisch JH, Smith
JJ. Summated circulatory responses of thermal and baroreflexes
in humans. J Appl Physiol. 1982;52:184-189.
21. Sanders JS, Ferguson DW. Cardiopulmonary baroreflexes fail to modulate sympathetic responses during isometric exercise in humans: direct evidence from microneurographic studies. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1988;12:1241-1251.[Abstract]
22.
Scherrer U, Vissing SF, Victor RG. Effects of
lower-body negative pressure on sympathetic nerve responses to static
exercise in humans: microneurographic evidence against cardiac
baroreflex modulation of the exercise pressor reflex.
Circulation. 1988;78:49-59.
23. Bjurstedt H, Rosenhamer G, Balldin U, Katkov V. Orthostatic reactions during recovery from exhaustive exercise of short duration. Acta Physiol Scand. 1983;119:25-31.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
24. Raven PB, Pape G, Taylor WF, Gaffney FA, Blomquist CG. Hemodynamic changes during whole body surface cooling and lower body negative pressure. Aviat Space Environ Med. 1981;52:387-391.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
25. Smith ML, Hudson DL, Raven PB. Effect of muscle tension on the cardiovascular responses to lower body negative pressure in man. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1987;19:436-442.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
26. Daugirdas JT. Dialysis hypotension: a hemodynamic analysis. Kidney Int. 1991;39:233-246.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
27. Palmer BF. The effect of dialysate composition on systemic hemodynamics. Semin Dial. 1992;5:54-60.
28. Beasley D, Brenner BM. Role of nitric oxide in hemodialysis hypotension. Kidney Int. 1992;42:S96-S100.
29. Shinzato T, Miwa M, Nakai S, Morita H, Odani H, Inoue I, Maeda K. Role of adenosine in dialysis-induced hypotension. J Am Soc Nephrol. 1994;4:1987-1994.[Abstract]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. H. J. Thijssen, P. de Groot, M. Kooijman, P. Smits, and M. T. E. Hopman Sympathetic nervous system contributes to the age-related impairment of flow-mediated dilation of the superficial femoral artery Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, December 1, 2006; 291(6): H3122 - H3129. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. P. van Orshoven, P. L. Oey, L. J. van Schelven, J. M. M. Roelofs, P. A. F. Jansen, and L. M. A. Akkermans Effect of gastric distension on cardiovascular parameters: gastrovascular reflex is attenuated in the elderly J. Physiol., March 1, 2004; 555(2): 573 - 583. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. L. Hijmering, E. S. G. Stroes, J. Olijhoek, B. A. Hutten, P. J. Blankestijn, and T. J. Rabelink Sympathetic activation markedly reduces endothelium-dependent, flow-mediated vasodilation J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., February 20, 2002; 39(4): 683 - 688. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. G. W. BARNAS, W. H. BOER, and H. A. KOOMANS Hemodynamic Patterns and Spectral Analysis of Heart Rate Variability during Dialysis Hypotension J. Am. Soc. Nephrol., December 1, 1999; 10(12): 2577 - 2584. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
G. Ligtenberg, P. J. Blankestijn, P. L. Oey, I. H.H. Klein, L.-T. Dijkhorst-Oei, F. Boomsma, G. H. Wieneke, A. C. van Huffelen, and H. A. Koomans Reduction of Sympathetic Hyperactivity by Enalapril in Patients with Chronic Renal Failure N. Engl. J. Med., April 29, 1999; 340(17): 1321 - 1328. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Circulation Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 1997 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |