| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
(Circulation. 1996;93:238-245.)
© 1996 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Division of Nuclear Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
Correspondence to Juergen vom Dahl, MD, Medizinische Klinik I der RWTH Aachen, Klinikum Aachen, Pauwelsstr 30, 52057 Aachen, FRG.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results Twenty-seven patients with angiographically proven coronary artery disease and 5 subjects with a low likelihood for coronary artery disease underwent dynamic PET imaging under resting conditions using Rb-82 and FDG. Both image sequences served as input data for a semiautomated regional analysis program. This program generated polar maps representing Rb-82 tissue half-life and FDG utilization assessed by Patlak's approach. Myocardial tissue viability was visually determined from static Rb-82 and FDG images. Regions were categorized as normal, ischemically compromised, and scar tissue. Their coordinates were subsequently copied to the functional polar maps for further analyses. In normal subjects, Rb-82 tissue half-life was homogeneous throughout the left ventricle (90±11 seconds). In coronary patients, differences between Rb-82 tissue half-lives in normal and scar tissue were highly significant (95±10 and 57±15 seconds, respectively; P<.0001). FDG uptake in these two tissue groups was 78±12% and 40±13%, respectively (P<.0001). Ischemically compromised tissue with reduced perfusion but maintained FDG uptake displayed an Rb-82 half-life of 75±9 seconds, indicating active cellular tracer retention, which was significantly different from scar tissue. Overall agreement of tissue categorization as either viable or scar was 86% between Rb-82 kinetics and FDG utilization. In a subgroup of 11 patients with all three tissue types within one image set, Rb-82 tissue half-life discriminated between normal, ischemic, and scar tissue (97±9, 75±9, and 60±15 seconds, respectively; P<.01).
Conclusions This study demonstrated a significant relationship between cell membrane integrity as assessed by dynamic Rb-82 PET imaging and myocardial glucose utilization as a marker for tissue viability. In regions with reduced perfusion, Rb-82 kinetics was different in compromised but metabolically active and irreversibly injured myocardium. The predictive value of this approach must be evaluated in follow-up studies.
Key Words: tomography potassium perfusion myocardium
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
PET imaging with Rb-82 has proven to be highly accurate in the detection and functional assessment of coronary artery stenoses and infarct size imaging.19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 Experimental and first clinical data indicate the usefulness of Rb-82 in combination with PET to assess myocardial viability. Animal models with coronary occlusion and reperfusion demonstrated rapid Rb-82 clearance from irreversibly injured tissue, whereas the tracer was retained in reversibly damaged and viable tissue.28 29 Based on these experimental data, Gould et al30 subsequently proposed Rb-82 imaging early and late after tracer injection as a new approach for definition of tissue viability in patients with previous myocardial infarction. Recently, the clinical long-term follow-up of patients studied by this approach has been reported and was shown to be of diagnostic value to identify patients with poor prognosis and those who might benefit from coronary revascularization.31
The purpose of this study was to develop a method for quantitative assessment of myocardial Rb-82 kinetics and to compare the results with regional FDG and Rb-82 tracer uptake measurements as independent markers of tissue viability.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
For comparison, 5 subjects (3 men, 2 women; age, 50±20 years) with a low likelihood of hemodynamically relevant coronary artery disease by history, ECG criteria, echocardiography, and negative stress thallium-201 scintigraphy were studied to evaluate the homogeneity of Rb-82 clearance parameters in normal myocardium.
Positron Emission Tomography
Patient Preparation
Patients had a light breakfast in the morning and received
either 50 g dextrose orally or, in the presence of diabetes mellitus,
small doses of insulin to titrate plasma glucose levels at
approximately 120 mg/100 mL before the imaging
procedure.32
After positioning of the patient in the scanner gantry, a 20-minute transmission scan for attenuation correction was performed using a retractable germanium-68 ring source. Consistency in patient positioning was achieved by marking the chest with washable ink and aligning the marks with a low-power laser light beam from the tomograph. Patients were not moved out of the scanner during the study.
Data Acquisition
All studies were performed
under resting conditions using a
two-ring, multislice, whole-body PET scanner (ECAT 931,
CTI/Siemens), allowing simultaneous imaging of 15
transaxial slices, with a slice thickness of 6.75 mm encompassing the
entire heart. All studies were obtained using the following
reconstruction parameters: matrix size, 128x128 pixels
with a pixel size of 2.35 mm and Hanning reconstruction filter with a
cutoff frequency of 0.30.
Rb-82 delivered from a strontium-82/Rb-82 generator (Squibb) was injected using an automated infusion system (Harvard model 975, Harvard Apparatus) capable of accurate delivery of Rb-82, with a maximum volume of 100 mL per infusion. A dose of 60 mCi Rb-82 was diluted and infused over 30 seconds. Dynamic data acquisition was initiated at the beginning of the infusion and continued for 8 minutes, with a total of 15 frames (12x10 seconds and 3x120 seconds).
After Rb-82 decay, 10 mCi FDG was injected as a slow intravenous bolus over 30 seconds, and dynamic PET images were obtained for 60 minutes (12x5 minutes).
Data
Processing and Analysis
Three-dimensional reorientation. A
reorientation
algorithm provided by the scanner software system was used to generate
12 short-axis cardiac planes for each time point obtained from
dynamic Rb-82 or FDG protocols.33 The short-axis
cardiac images served as input data for a semiautomated regional
analysis program developed at our institution, which generates
quantitative polar maps of regional myocardial Rb-82 clearance rates
and of myocardial FDG utilization.
Topographic definition of myocardial regions for quantitative analysis. An automated region definition program that had been developed for N-13 ammonia studies at our institution was used for the calculation of regional time-activity curves.34 Epicardial and endocardial borders were visually defined by the operator for each short-axis plane in the time frame with the highest ratio of myocardial to background tracer activity. For the Rb-82 study, this was usually frame 13 (2 to 4 minutes). In this frame, tracer activity had already cleared from the blood pool, but significant decay of myocardial Rb-82 had not yet occurred. In the case of FDG study with progressive myocardial tracer accumulation over time, the final frame (55 to 60 minutes) was chosen.
Activity maxima within the two concentric borders were defined along 36 circumferential radii, beginning at the posterior intersection of the left and right ventricular walls. Thirty-six regions of 3x3 pixels in each of the 8 short-axis planes were created along these radii, centered at the point of maximal activity of each radius. Subsequently, the locations of these regions were copied to all time frames. Time-activity curves were finally determined for 36 circumferential regions in each short-axis cardiac plane for further analysis.
Blood pool definition. For both tracers, definition
of the
region representing the blood pool activity was confined to
the two most basal planes to minimize resolution distortion. For Rb-82
kinetics, the blood pool region covering
9 pixels was defined in the
left ventricular chamber using the frame showing peak Rb-82
activity.35 For the FDG studies, the blood pool region
covering
9 pixels was placed in the right ventricular
chamber, with sufficient distance to the ventricular septum
to minimize myocardial tracer contribution at late imaging time
frames.
Calculation of Rb-82 tracer kinetics. A
monoexponential, least squares curve fit was applied to
nondecay-corrected regional time-activity curves.
Dependent on the individual shape of the tissue curve, the start time
point for the curve fit was chosen interactively by the operator so
that the rapid component of the blood clearance function was completed
and only the slow component remained (Fig 1
). This time
point was defined in most patients approximately 90 seconds after the
start of tracer infusion. All following data points until completion of
the study were included into the fitting procedure. Regional
time-activity curves were fitted to the
formula
|
![]() |
where CRb(t) represents the total tissue activity predicted by the model at time t and Ca(t) represents the actual blood pool activity at time t. The two estimated parameters were A and kt. Parameter A [1] represents Rb-82 uptake at the start time point of curve fit, and parameter kt [min-1] characterizes the combined physical tracer decay and tissue clearance rate of Rb-82. The constant TBV represents the total blood volume and spillover fraction within the defined region. Based on previous studies, TBV was preset to a value of 0.3 (30%).34
Upon completion of the fitting procedure, the resulting values for parameters A and kt were presented in a polar map display. To prevent interstudy variation, the polar map representing parameter A was normalized to the individual maximum and expressed as a percentage.
Analysis of FDG time-activity curves. Blood pool and myocardial FDG time-activity curves were used to calculate regional values for the Patlak analysis as described previously from our laboratory.32 36
The analysis
describes the correlation between the ratio
Ct/Cb and the expression
Cb(0-t)/Cb, where Ct is the
decay-corrected myocardial activity and Cb is the
decay-corrected blood pool activity at any given time t.
Cb(0-t) represents the integral of blood pool
activity from time zero to time t and serves as an index of the
arterial FDG input function. Since FDG6-phosphate
accumulates in tissue as a function of uptake and
phosphorylation of FDG, this relationship becomes
linear after equilibration of free tissue FDG. The linear part of this
plot was determined with the use of a derivative approach.
Regional Patlak slopes derived from all 36 time-activity curves were displayed in polar map format. Results of each region were presented as a percentage of individual maximum. This relative expression was chosen to avoid additional scatter in the data caused by intraindividual and interindividual variation of absolute metabolic values.14
Regional analysis of data. Based on the time-activity curves and analysis scheme, the software package generated three coordinate polar maps for each individual study: (1) percentage of maximal Rb-82 uptake (RbUpt%): average noncorrected Rb-82 tissue activity between 2 and 4 minutes after start of Rb-82 infusion, expressed as a percentage of the individual maximum; (2) Rb-82 tissue half-life (RbT1/2) derived from the washout rate constant kt converted into tracer half-lives (RbT1/2=[ln|0.5|/kt]x60): a time of 76 seconds represents physical tracer decay; higher values indicate cellular tracer accumulation and lower values express accelerated clearance from tissue; and (3) percentage of maximal FDG Patlak slope (FDGSlo%): regional Patlak slopes were normalized to the individual maximum within each polar map and expressed as a percentage.
Visual definition of regional tissue viability. Myocardial viability was defined by visual analysis of conventional static Rb-82 and FDG PET images (short axis and horizontal and vertical long axis). These static images were created from the dynamic studies by summing up frames acquired from several consecutive time frames. In the case of Rb-82 studies, frames 9 through 15 (80 seconds to 8 minutes) were combined. For creation of static FDG images, summation was carried out from frames 7 through 12 (30 to 60 minutes). From these images, tissue regions representing three different tissue types were categorized visually as previously described from our laboratory15 : normal, regions with normal or highest Rb-82 uptake; ischemically compromised, regions with reduced Rb-82 uptake but maintained or elevated F-18 uptake (mild match and mismatch); and scar, regions with concordant reduced Rb-82 and FDG uptake (match).
Based on the well-validated match or mismatch pattern, this approach was used to optimally separate into discrete regions the various tissue types that each heart contained in varying extent and mixture.
This visual analysis allowed localization of the regions of interest on the polar maps for further quantitative analysis. One region in each individual patient was defined to represent normal tissue. Additionally, in 21 patients one region was defined in each as representing ischemically compromised tissue with maintained viability. In another 17 patients one region in each was categorized as scar tissue with markedly reduced perfusion and concordant reduction of FDG utilization. Thus, each individual patient could have a maximum of three regions with different tissue categories.
A region definition procedure similar to that described for the dynamic protocol was applied to the static images and polar maps representing Rb-82 distribution and FDG activity. On these static polar maps, the regions of interest for the individual tissue categories were placed according to the previous visual localization. The coordinates of the so-defined regions were subsequently copied to the polar maps of the dynamic studies representing RbUpt%, RbT1/2, and FDGSlo%, as described above.
Analysis of Regional Homogeneity of Rb-82
Kinetics
In the control population, the left ventricular
myocardial wall was divided into four quadrants (anterior, lateral,
inferior, and septal). These quadrants were divided into
basal and mid ventricular parts. The apex was defined as a
separate region. Overall, nine myocardial regions were defined in each
subject to study the regional homogeneity of tracer uptake and
clearance. Analysis of regional Rb-82 kinetics was performed as
described for patient studies.
Statistical Analysis
Values are given as mean±SD. For
statistical analysis,
the software package StatView 4.02 (Abacus Concepts Inc) was used.
Comparison between two groups was performed with the use of Student's
t test for either unpaired or paired data sets. Linear
regression analysis was applied to study relationships between
different parameters. A value of P<.05 was
considered statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Rb-82 Kinetics and FDG Uptake in Different Tissue
Types
The results of quantitative analyses of regional Rb-82
uptake, Rb-82 half-life, and FDG utilization are given in Table
2
. Rb-82 uptake as well as Rb-82 half-life was
significantly different between normal and scar tissue
(P<.0001).
|
In regions defined as ischemically compromised, Rb-82 uptake was significantly different from normal and scar tissue. Rb-82 tissue half-life was 75±9 seconds in these regions, which approximates physical tracer decay and indicates active cellular tracer retention. In contrast, Rb-82 half-life was significantly shorter in scar tissue, with 57±15 seconds (P<.0001) indicating accelerated tracer clearance from myocardium. FDG uptake in ischemically compromised tissue was 68±15% and significantly higher compared with scar tissue (40±13%, P<.0001).
Fig 2
illustrates the individual Rb-82 tissue
half-lives in all 27 patients. In regions defined as normal, 26 of
27 regions (96%) had RbT1/2
76 seconds
(physical tracer decay). In ischemically compromised regions, 9
of 17 regions (53%) displayed RbT1/2>76
seconds. In contrast, 16 of 17 (94%) of the regions defined as scar
tissue demonstrated accelerated Rb-82 washout
(RbT1/2<76 seconds).
|
Ten regions displayed a
perfusion/metabolism mismatch with
FDG utilization >70%. Rb-82 uptake was 47±10%, and FDG utilization
was 81±7%. Myocardial Rb-82 half-life averaged 78±9 seconds
(range, 68 to 88), with 7 of 10 regions displaying
RbT1/2
76 seconds.
Eleven patients displayed
all three different tissue categories
(normal, ischemically compromised, and scar) within one image
set. The comparison of different tissue types in these 11 patients is
presented in Table 3
. As for all patients,
differences for Rb-82 uptake and Rb-82 tissue half-life between
normal and scar tissue were highly significant (P<.0001).
Again, in regions with reduced Rb-82 uptake,
RbT1/2 differentiated between
ischemically compromised and necrotic tissue. However, Rb-82
uptake in these two groups also was different. FDG utilization in
regions defined as either normal or compromised was not significantly
different and confirmed the previous visual definition for
ischemically jeopardized regions.
|
Relationship Between Rb-82 Uptake and Rb-82 Tissue
Half-life
There was a significant linear relationship between Rb-82
uptake
and Rb-82 tissue half-life (r=.81, P<.0001).
Fig 3
illustrates the correlation between those two
parameters in all regions with reduced perfusion. Inclusion
of normal regions did not change the relationship (r=.86,
P<.0001).
|
Comparison of Rb-82 Uptake and Rb-82 Tissue Half-life as
Indicators of Absent or Maintained Tissue Viability
The following two
criteria were chosen to compare the
diagnostic value of Rb-82 uptake and of Rb-82 tissue
half-life for evaluation of myocardial viability. The thresholds
for preserved viability were RbUpt%
50% of individual
maximum30 and RbT1/2
normal
mean-2 SD.
These two criteria were applied to regions that had
been classified by
FDG utilization as either viable (>50%) or nonviable (
50%).
Agreement between the different approaches is presented in
Table 4
. For all regions, maintained viability as
defined by FDG uptake was identified correctly in 76% by Rb-82 uptake
and in 92% by Rb-82 tissue half-life. Consistent
categorization of scar tissue was achieved in 100% and 71%,
respectively. Overall agreement for viability categorization by FDG
uptake was 86% with Rb-82 kinetics and 81% with Rb-82 uptake.
|
Rb-82 uptake identified 48% of regions with preserved FDG utilization when only regions with reduced perfusion were analyzed. In contrast, agreement between Rb-82 tissue half-life and FDG utilization was 86% for identification of maintained viability.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Rb-82 kinetics correlated with regional FDG uptake measurements in regions with reduced perfusion. This finding suggests a relationship between cell membrane function as assessed by Rb-82 tissue kinetics and preservation of intracellular glucose metabolism as independent indicators of maintained myocardial viability in the presence of reduced blood flow.
Using FDG uptake as the "gold standard" for tissue viability, Rb-82 agreed with this parameter in 86% for definition of scar tissue and viable myocardium.
This study was not designed to define the predictive accuracy of dynamic Rb-82 PET imaging for functional outcome after coronary revascularization but to evaluate the feasibility to assess tissue tracer kinetics compared with the established FDG method. Future studies in patients with severe left ventricular dysfunction must elucidate the predictive value of this approach for functional outcome.
Physiological Considerations
Similar to other potassium
analogues such as thallium-201, Rb-82
is rapidly extracted by the myocardium. Its uptake reflects
the equilibration within the potassium pool with little activity
clearance in the presence of intact cell membranes. Based on these
physiological characteristics, Rb-82 is currently
used as a flow tracer for the detection of regionally impaired
coronary flow reserve in patients with suspected or known
coronary artery
disease.19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
Since the intracellular retention of potassium and of Rb-82 requires active maintenance of ionic gradients across cell membranes, Rb-82 tissue kinetics allows study of the integrity of membrane function. The accelerated leakage of potassium from myocardium in the presence of coronary occlusion has been experimentally documented and correlated with early impaired cellular membrane function as well as with tissue necrosis in a canine model.37 Experimental studies by Goldstein28 29 evaluated Rb-82 as a marker of potassium fluxes. These investigations recorded regional tracer kinetics of Rb-82 using ß-detectors placed on the epicardial surface of the heart in acutely ischemic animals after coronary occlusion and reperfusion. Rb-82 tissue activity increased over time in viable myocardium reflecting intracellular retention, while the tracer cleared rapidly from tissue defined as necrotic by histochemical staining methods.
Based on these observations, Gould et al30 proposed the clinical use of Rb-82 as an indicator of cell membrane integrity and myocardial viability. They used static data acquisition early and late after tracer injection to estimate the regional Rb-82 uptake. Infarct size based on these Rb-82 uptake and retention images correlated closely with infarct size and location on FDG images. The results suggested that loss of cell membrane integrity as indicated by accelerated Rb-82 clearance parallels loss of intracellular glucose metabolism.
These observations, obtained by comparison of two static images, are supported and further elucidated by our findings from dynamic PET imaging. In our study, the tissue half-life of Rb-82 exceeded the physical tracer half-life of 76 seconds as evidence for active tissue tracer retention in 96% of regions previously defined as normal. Regions with evidence of irreversible injury by FDG criteria displayed accelerated tracer clearance with tissue half-life times <76 seconds in 94% of regions.
However, few of our study patients were studied in the early subacute phase of myocardial infarction, which would most closely reflect the above-cited experimental condition. The Rb-82 kinetics in patients with chronic coronary artery disease and infarctions may reflect primarily the retention capacity of the tracer within a given region. Since blood flow to infarcted tissue may recover, as demonstrated in animal experiments using microspheres, the clearance rate of Rb-82 in these segments may correspond to the number of viable cells that can retain the tracer. Therefore, the Rb-82 kinetics may be best described by the distribution volume of the tracer in tissue as a marker for the available potassium space. However, the calculation of the distribution volume requires tracer kinetic modeling defining tracer delivery (K1) and clearance (K2). The PET camera system in this study did not allow for the fit of the entire dynamic study because of dead-time considerations, limiting the analysis to the estimates of tracer clearance rates only. The hypothesis that Rb-82 clearance rates may reflect the number of viable cells in one segment is supported by the good agreement with FDG data in regions with reduced perfusion.
An additional technical aspect is the fact that tissue clearance parameters are less affected by partial volume effects, which may be especially important in areas with infarcted myocardium. This may even offer advantages for the Rb kinetic analyses over the assessment of tissue FDG uptake.
The observed
overlap of individual clearance rates, as illustrated in
Fig 2
, is most likely a result of our approach to choose large
regions
for analysis. It cannot be excluded that ischemically
compromised regions predominantly presented "hibernating"
myocardium but that islets of necrotic tissue were also
included in those regions and influenced the resulting signal (mild
match). This explanation is supported by the finding that myocardial
FDG utilization of all these regions was slightly but not significantly
lower compared with normal regions. Because of the limited spatial
resolution of the PET system used in this study, it was impossible to
distinguish if intermediate values predominantly reflected truly
accelerated washout (compared with normal regions) of not irreversibly
damaged myocardium or if this pattern predominantly
reflected a transmural mixture of different tissue types in the
presence of a nontransmural infarction. However, despite this technical
limitation, the data provide evidence that Rb kinetics in
myocardium with reduced perfusion but maintained FDG
utilization differs from those observed in irreversibly damaged
myocardium and that this approach may be helpful in the
diagnostic workup of patients with ischemic heart
disease and reduced ventricular function. Future studies
with advanced scanner systems and higher spatial resolution might
provide further insights into the Rb-82 kinetics of hibernating
myocardium.
Clinical Considerations
The presented approach might be of
particular interest for
those nuclear facilities without on-site cyclotron, since Rb-82 can
be eluted from a convenient generator system. It allows the combined
assessment of perfusion by early tracer uptake measurement and
assessment of viability by either serial imaging as proposed by Gould
et al or dynamic data acquisition as performed in our study with
washout analysis after only a single tracer injection. The
polar maps, which could be created easily, allowed quantitation of
defect sizes or regions with potentially salvageable
myocardium. This might be of particular interest in
patients with regional wall motion abnormalities to identify those in
whom revascularization might result in significant
functional improvement. Furthermore, the short half-life of Rb-82
allows repetitive studies in combination with exercise or
pharmacological stress testing.24 25 38
Besides the logistic aspects of the Rb-82 generator, the combined assessment of myocardial perfusion and viability with a single tracer infusion offers clinical advantages with respect to patient throughput and possibly costs.39 Currently, the combined assessment of myocardial perfusion and metabolism is the most widely used PET imaging technique for assessment of myocardial viability.6 However, these study protocols need two tracer injections, with higher radiation exposure to the patient and longer imaging times. Furthermore, metabolic conditions such as the patient's nutritional state or diabetes mellitus, which may limit the interpretation of FDG images, do not influence Rb-82 image quality. This may be of particular consequence for laboratories with high patient throughput, since individualized patient preparation is required for FDG imaging. Finally, the effect of regional heterogeneities of myocardial glucose utilization, limiting the diagnostic accuracy of FDG imaging, may be avoided.36 40 However, other metabolic conditions might influence myocardial Rb uptake and need further studies in patients with coronary artery disease.41
All patients in this study had reduced left ventricular function (ejection fraction ranged from 25% to 47%), and the majority had a history of previous myocardial infarction. Since PET viability imaging is clinically most useful in patients with markedly reduced ventricular function, a subanalysis was performed in 17 patients with left ventricular ejection fractions <40%. Eight of these 17 patients had all three tissue types within their individual PET data set. The results were comparable to the entire patient population, with an Rb-82 tissue half-life of 97±11 seconds in normal regions, 77±12 seconds in compromised regions, and 59±14 seconds in scar tissue regions. Similarly, Rb uptake values and FDG utilization did not differ substantially from the results observed in all patients.
Limitations
This evaluation of Rb-82 kinetics must be
validated in a
prospective study in patients undergoing coronary
revascularization with assessment of functional
outcome at follow-up. Recently, the study by Yoshida and
Gould,31 with analysis of the clinical
follow-up in the patient population described 2 years earlier by
Gould et al,30 indicated the clinical usefulness of Rb-82
in combination with PET imaging for assessment of myocardial viability
and of patient prognosis.
The lack of follow-up data on regional or global left ventricular function somewhat limits the clinical conclusions that can be drawn from our results. Confirmation of improved wall motion in ischemic regions after coronary revascularization would certainly serve as the "gold standard" for assessment of myocardial viability. However, analysis of FDG uptake has been validated by follow-up studies in several laboratories as an accurate indicator of myocardial tissue viability.7 8 9 10 11 13 14 15 Therefore, we used the direct comparison between Rb-82 kinetics and FDG imaging to validate this dynamic imaging approach.
Normalization of regional FDG uptake to the individual region with maximal FDG utilization may provide results other than normalization to the region with highest or "normal" perfusion, as proposed by other groups.14 42 However, since normalized FDG utilization values did not differ significantly between normal and ischemically compromised regions, we do not expect that this would substantially change the results of the Rb-82 kinetic calculations obtained in this study.
Technical Considerations
Because of the count rate
limitations of the system, it was not
possible to include the first part of the dynamic data set into the
fitting procedure. The maximal sensitivity of this PET scanner was
approximately 12 000 prompts per second. At this count rate, the error
caused by dead-time losses is less than 5%. The typical peak count
rate of the Rb-82 study was approximately 15 000 prompts per second
after 20 to 30 seconds of Rb-82 infusion in the basal planes of the
left ventricle. The count rate fell rapidly after approximately 45
seconds as a result of the decreasing amount of activity infused by the
generator and the short physical half-life of Rb-82 (Fig 1
).
The
typical count rate at 60 seconds was 5000 to 7000 prompts per second.
Because of the high initial count rate, it was necessary to delay the
start of the fitting routine until the blood activity had cleared from
the myocardium. Consequently, it was not possible to
measure the initial tracer delivery to tissue. Hence, an analytic
approach with the use of a compartmental model such as the one proposed
by Herrero et al43 44 could not be used, since this
approach requires knowledge of blood and tissue time-activity
curves during the initial part of the study.
The physical decay of Rb-82 is very fast compared with the duration of the imaging procedure. At the end of the 8-minute protocol, less than 3% of the administered activity is still present. As a result, large correction factors (factors of 10 to 100) are necessary to correct for physical decay. Such correction magnifies the noise contribution as a function of time. To reduce this influence, Rb-82 time-activity curves were not decay corrected. The calculated rate constant kt therefore represented both physical decay and tissue clearance rate and was subsequently converted into tracer tissue half-life.
Selection of different tissue types from visual analysis of flow-metabolism patterns for further quantitative analysis procedures was performed to provide pure tissue typesnormal, viable but ischemic, and scarwith prognostic impact of functional outcome that have been validated in several clinical studies with functional follow-up evaluation.7 8 9 11 13 15 This approach was believed to represent the best way of comparing the different types of quantitative data (Rb-82 uptake and kinetics and FDG utilization) from the same region of interest selected to minimize mixtures of different tissue types.
The standardized presentation of Rb-82 and FDG data in a polar map display allowed direct comparison of both tracers using the same regions of interest. The software package written in our institution allowed interactive definition of regions in polar map coordinates, their storage and easy manipulation, and overlay between different studies. The advantage of this procedure lies in the convenient display of several polar maps side by side and the fact that regions defined in one of these polar maps can be automatically copied to all other polar maps.
Conclusions
This study demonstrated a significant
relationship between cell
membrane integrity as assessed by dynamic Rb-82 PET imaging and
myocardial viability defined by FDG utilization. Myocardial tracer
distribution and tissue half-life of Rb-82 in normal
myocardium were homogeneous. In patients with
coronary artery disease, Rb-82 kinetics was significantly
different and in good agreement with FDG data in compromised but
metabolically active and irreversibly injured
myocardium. Further investigation with prospective
evaluation of wall motion recovery after coronary
revascularization is required to determine the
prognostic impact of this approach in a clinical setting.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received August 9, 1994; revision received August 1, 1995; accepted August 29, 1995.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. A. Stankewicz, C. S. Mansour, R. L. Eisner, K. B. Churchwell, B. R. Williams, S. R. Sigman, J. Streeter, and R. E. Patterson Myocardial Viability Assessment by PET: 82Rb Defect Washout Does Not Predict the Results of Metabolic-Perfusion Mismatch J. Nucl. Med., October 1, 2005; 46(10): 1602 - 1609. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Schwaiger, S. Ziegler, and S. G. Nekolla PET/CT: Challenge for Nuclear Cardiology J. Nucl. Med., October 1, 2005; 46(10): 1664 - 1678. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. El Fakhri, A. Sitek, B. Guerin, M. F. Kijewski, M. F. Di Carli, and S. C. Moore Quantitative Dynamic Cardiac 82Rb PET Using Generalized Factor and Compartment Analyses J. Nucl. Med., August 1, 2005; 46(8): 1264 - 1271. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S.R. Underwood, J. J Bax, J. v. Dahl, M. Y Henein, A. C van Rossum, E. R Schwarz, J.-L. Vanoverschelde, E. E.v. d. Wall, and W. Wijns Imaging techniques for the assessment of myocardial hibernation: Report of a Study Group of the European Society of Cardiology Eur. Heart J., May 2, 2004; 25(10): 815 - 836. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||