(Circulation. 1995;92:518-525.)
© 1995 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Department of Medical Physiology, Microcirculation Research Institute, Texas A&M University Health Science Center, College Station.
Correspondence to Dr Lih Kuo, Department of Medical Physiology, Microcirculation Research Institute, Texas A&M University Health Science Center, College Station, TX 77843-1114.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results Experiments were performed in four different
sizes of porcine subepicardial coronary arterial microvessels: small
arterioles (40±1-µm ID with resting tone); intermediate arterioles
(60±1 µm); large arterioles (106±4 µm); and small
arteries
(179±9 µm). Vessels were isolated and cannulated to allow luminal
pressure and flow to be independently controlled. All vessels developed
active tone (to
65% to 75% of maximum diameter) at their control
luminal pressures and showed graded dilations to stepwise increases in
shear stress (0 to 10 dynes/cm2). For arterioles, the
magnitude of the dilations increased as vessel size increased. The
highest shear stress produced 21±3%, 32±2%, and 52±5%
increases
in diameter in small, intermediate, and large arterioles, respectively.
Small arteries dilated only 22±6%. The
endothelium-dependent vasodilator substance P (SP)
produced dose-dependent dilation of all vessels with a threshold at
10-16 mol/L. Arterioles were maximally dilated at
10-9 mol/L SP. However, this dose produced only 80%
dilation in small arteries. The ED50 for SP was shifted to
the right by two orders of magnitude in small arteries compared with
the arterioles. Adenosine preferentially dilated small arterioles, and
the dose-response curves shifted to the right for larger vessels. The
thresholds for adenosine-induced dilation were
10-12, 10-11, and
10-9 mol/L for small, intermediate, and large arterioles,
respectively. The endothelium-independent vasodilator
nitroprusside produced identical dose-dependent dilations in all vessel
segments.
Conclusions The results indicate that the pig coronary circulation exhibits a heterogeneity in physiological and pharmacological responses along the microvascular network. Small arterioles are more sensitive to adenosine, but large arterioles are more responsive to shear-stress stimulation. We speculate that site-specific preferential responses may play a crucial role in coordinating overall vascular function in the coronary microvascular network.
Key Words: endothelium-derived factors vessels microcirculation substance P adenosine
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Although flow-induced vasodilation has been found in both the macrocirculation and the microcirculation, a significant difference in the magnitude of the response appears to exist. Studies of canine conduit arteries indicate that the magnitude of flow-induced vasodilation is a 9% increase in diameter in the femoral artery (diameter, 5.0 mm) and a 15% increase in diameter in the smaller, downstream saphenous artery (diameter, 2.6 mm) in response to a 10-fold increase in flow.2 Recent studies in the mesenteric microcirculation indicate that flow-induced dilation is much more pronounced in resistance vessels: 68-µm arterioles dilated approximately 70% to a sevenfold increase in flow velocity.4 Similarly, in the coronary circulation, we recently found a 30% dilation of arterioles with resting diameters of 65 µm during flow augmentation,7 in comparison to only a 3% to 10% dilation found in large coronary arteries.8 15 18 These observations suggest that the microcirculation is a major site for flow-induced responses and that a longitudinal gradient for flow-induced responsiveness may exist within the coronary microcirculation. However, the size of coronary microvessels that dominate in these responses is not clear. In addition, a longitudinal response gradient to agonists, ie, dilation or constriction that varies inversely with vessel size, has been shown in arteriolar networks of several different tissues other than the heart.19 Whether the coronary microvascular network also exhibits this pharmacological response gradient has not been unequivocally demonstrated. Since flow-induced dilation17 20 and the local release of adenosine21 have been suggested to play an important role in maximizing blood flow to tissue during periods of increased metabolic demand and the majority of coronary resistance (>90%) resides in microvessels <300 µm in diameter, it is important to quantitatively evaluate the regulatory properties of coronary microvessels.
The purpose of the present study was to systematically examine the relative responsiveness of coronary arterial microvessels to physiological (ie, flow) as well as to pharmacological (substance P, adenosine, and nitroprusside) stimuli. To achieve these goals, the changes in vascular diameter in response to different levels of flow and agonist concentration were studied in four different sizes (25 to 45, 50 to 70, 80 to 130, and 140 to 280 µm) of subepicardial coronary microvessels in vitro. The microvessels were isolated and cannulated to allow flow and intraluminal pressure to be independently controlled. Thus, the magnitudes of flow-induced vasodilation and pharmacological responses were evaluated at a constant intraluminal pressure and without the confounding influence of the myogenic response.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Isolation and Cannulation of Microvessels
The techniques for
identification and isolation of coronary
microvessels were described previously.22 In brief, a
mixture of india ink and gelatin in physiological salt solution (PSS)
containing (in mmol/L) NaCl 145.0, KCl 4.7, CaCl2 2.0,
MgSO4 1.17, NaH2PO4 1.2, glucose
5.0, pyruvate 2.0, EDTA 0.02, and MOPS buffer 3.0 was perfused under
low pressure (20 to 40 cm H2O) into the left anterior
descending artery (0.5 mL) and the circumflex artery (0.5 mL) to enable
visualization of the coronary microvessels. At 4°C, four consecutive
branches of coronary arterial microvessels were selected and dissected
for in vitro studies. The left anterior descending and circumflex
arteries were considered first-order arteries. The small arteries (140-
to 300-µm ID) branching from left anterior descending and circumflex
arteries were designated second- or third-order vessels. Their
downstream large arterioles (90 to 130 µm) were designated third- or
fourth-order vessels. Intermediate (50 to 80 µm) and small (25 to 45
µm) arterioles further downstream corresponded to the fifth and six
generations of microvessels, respectively. These vessels were selected
and dissected from the surrounding cardiac tissue and transferred for
further dissection to a dish (4°C) containing filtered PSS-albumin
(BSA, 1 g/100 mL PSS; US Biochemical Corp) solution at pH 7.4. After
careful removal of any remaining cardiac tissue, each microvessel was
transferred for cannulation to a Lucite vessel chamber containing
PSS-albumin solution equilibrated with room air at ambient temperature.
One end of the microvessel was cannulated with a glass micropipette
filled with filtered PSS-albumin solution, and the outside of the
microvessel was securely tied to the pipette with 11-0 ophthalmic
suture (Alcon). The ink-gelatin column inside the vessel was flushed
out at low perfusion pressure (<20 cm H2O). The other end
of the vessel was cannulated with a second micropipette and secured
with suture. In this study, four sets of micropipettes with different
tip diameters were used for cannulating different sizes of vessels. For
example, micropipettes with 20-, 30-, and 40-µm tip ID were used for
cannulation of small, intermediate, and large arterioles, respectively.
Small arteries were cannulated with micropipettes with 60-µm tip
diameter. Electrical resistances (measured by LCR Bridge Circuit, model
LCR-740, Leader Electronics) of each micropipette pair were matched
(±0.5%).
Instrumentation
After a vessel was cannulated, the
preparation was transferred
to the stage of an inverted microscope (model IM35, Carl Zeiss) coupled
to a Dage-MTI camera (model 67M, Newvicon), video micrometer
(Microcirculation Research Institute, Texas A&M University), and video
recorder (Panasonic). IDs of the vessel were measured
manually throughout the experiment by videomicroscopic
techniques.22 To study flow-induced responses without
interference from possible myogenic responses, a dual-reservoir system
was used to maintain a constant intraluminal pressure over a wide range
of flows.7 In brief, the micropipettes were connected to
independent reservoir systems, and intraluminal pressures were measured
through side arms of the two reservoir lines by low-volume-displacement
strain-gauge transducers (Statham P23 Db, Gould). The isolated vessels
were pressurized without flow by setting both reservoirs at the same
hydrostatic level. The recorded intraluminal pressure of the vessel was
equivalent to the actual hydrostatic pressure of the reservoirs if
there were no leaks. Preparations with leaks were excluded from further
study. Flow was initiated by simultaneously moving the reservoirs in
equal but opposite directions, thus generating a pressure gradient
(
P, inflow pressure minus outflow pressure). Because the resistances
of both cannulation pipettes were equivalent, movement of the
reservoirs in this manner did not alter luminal
pressure.22 Thus, flow-induced responses could be studied
by perfusing the vessel at different flow rates, ie, at various
pressure gradients, without changing intraluminal pressure.
Calculation of Shear Stress
Shear stress (
) at each
level of
P was calculated as
follows:
=4
Q/
r3, where
is viscosity
(0.8 cp for PSS-albumin solution at 37°C), Q is the volumetric flow
with respect to
P, and r is steady-state vessel radius before flow.
The relationship between
P and flow rate was calibrated in each pair
of micropipettes according to techniques described
previously.7 Specifically, flow rates for micropipettes of
20-µm ID were determined in arterioles between 30 and 45 µm
(maximally dilated with 10-4 mol/L nitroprusside, 41±3
µm, n=3) at
P=2, 4, 10, 20, 40, and 60 cm
H2O. Similar
flow calibrations in paired micropipettes (30-, 40-, and 60-µm ID)
were made in different sizes of vessels (65 to 250 µm, n=6) at the
same pressure gradients. In this system, flow was determined primarily
by the caliber of the tip of the micropipette and increased linearly
with increases in
P.7 In each pair of
resistance-matched micropipettes, the increase in flow was independent
of size of vessel within the range of
P studied. In paired 20-, 30-,
40-, and 60-µm micropipettes, the ranges of mean volumetric flows for
P between 0 and 60 cm H2O were 0 to 8.9, 0 to 34.8, 0 to
112.5, and 0 to 211.2 nL/s, respectively.
Experimental Protocols
To study flow-induced responses, each
cannulated vessel was
bathed in PSS-albumin solution, and the temperature was maintained at
36°C to 37°C by an external heat exchanger. The vessel was set to
its in situ length22 and allowed to develop active tone at
50, 60, or 70 cm H2O intraluminal pressure without flow for
small, intermediate, and large arterioles, respectively. Small arteries
were pressurized to 80 cm H2O. These internal pressures
were selected on the basis of in vivo micropressure
measurements.23 After the vessel developed active tone,
the relation between flow and vessel diameter was examined. Diameter
was measured at each level of flow corresponding to a
P of 4, 10,
20, 40, and 60 cm H2O, and shear stress was calculated as
described above.
To study the response gradient for pharmacological agonists, the cannulated microvessels were set to their corresponding intraluminal pressures and allowed to develop active tone without flow at 36°C to 37°C. After a steady diameter was established, the dose-dependent vasomotor responses to substance P, sodium nitroprusside, and adenosine were evaluated by construction of cumulative dose-response curves at a constant luminal pressure (no flow). At the end of each experiment, each vessel was relaxed with nitroprusside (10-4 mol/L) in PSS-albumin solution to obtain the maximum diameter at its corresponding intraluminal pressure.
Drugs were obtained from Sigma Chemical Co except as specifically stated. All drugs were dissolved in PSS-albumin solution and administered to the bath surrounding the vessel.
Data Analysis
To analyze the level of vascular tone in
different sizes of
microvessels, all diameters were normalized to the maximum diameter in
the presence of nitroprusside (10-4 mol/L). To analyze
vascular responses to shear stress, vessel diameters were normalized to
their resting levels and increases in diameter were expressed as
percent vasodilation. To analyze pharmacological responses, all
diameter changes were normalized to the maximum dilation in the
presence of nitroprusside (10-4 mol/L). Normalized
diameters were averaged at each flow step or each dose of drug. All
data are reported as mean±SEM. In this study, only vessels with
relatively stable resting tone (±5%) between interventions were
analyzed. Statistical comparisons of vasodilation at different levels
of shear stress or at different doses of a specific drug among four
sizes of vessels were made with two-way ANOVA and tested with Fisher's
least-significant-difference multiple-range tests. The dose-response
curves of each vessel were linearized by the Hill transformation, and
the ED50s were determined by the y intercept and
slope according to the equation:
ED50=10-(y intercept/slope).
Because ED50 is a logarithmic value, analysis was
performed on the -(y intercept/slope). The
statistical comparison of ED50s among different sizes of
vessels were made by one-way ANOVA and tested with Fisher's
least-significant-difference multiple-range tests. Significance was
accepted at P
.05.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Segmental Gradient for Flow-Induced Responses
Flow-induced
vasodilation in four different sizes of microvessels
was studied under constant luminal pressure. A graded vasodilation was
observed in these vessels when
P, and thus flow, was increased in a
stepwise manner. The corresponding shear stresses that initiated
vascular dilation in different vascular segments are shown in Fig
1
. The magnitude of the vasodilatory response increased
as the size of the arterioles increased. Maximum vasodilations were
observed at all vessel segments when shear stress was >4
dynes/cm2. The highest shear stress produced 21±3%,
32±2%, and 52±5% increases in diameter in small, intermediate,
and
large arterioles, respectively (P<.05). In small arteries,
only 22±6% dilation was observed in response to the highest shear
stress (Fig 1
).
|
To estimate the degree of regulation of
shear stress in different
vascular segments, secondary changes in shear stress resulting from
vessel dilation are shown in Fig 2
. Shear stress was
calculated at steady-state diameters after each flow step. This value
was defined as "regulated shear stress" because it was determined
by the degree of dilation of the vessel in response to the increased
flow. This regulated shear stress was plotted against the
"theoretical shear stress," which was calculated from the flow
rate generated in a rigid tube with same ID as the vessel at zero flow.
The line of identity shows how wall shear stress would relate directly
to flow in a rigid tube. It should be noted that perfect regulation of
shear stress would be reflected by a slope of zero. As shown in Fig
2
,
shear stress was partially regulated in all vascular segments, ie,
slopes were less than the line of identity but greater than zero.
However, large arterioles showed the best regulation of shear stress
among these groups of vessels as indicated by the smallest slope
(P<.05). In contrast, the small and intermediate-size
arterioles as well as the small arteries exhibited similar degrees of
shear-stress regulation (Fig 2
).
|
Segmental Gradient for Pharmacological Responses
We tested
whether other endothelium-dependent
mechanisms exhibited segmental response gradients. The
endothelium-dependent vasodilator substance
P17 produced dose-dependent dilation in all vessels with a
threshold at 10-16 mol/L (Fig 3
). The
ED50 for substance P was shifted to the right by two orders
of magnitude in small arteries (2.4x10-12 mol/L; CI,
8.2x10-12 to 7.2x10-13 mol/L)
compared with
the small arterioles (1.8x10-14 mol/L; CI,
6.3x10-14 to 4.9x10-15 mol/L).
There
was no statistical difference in ED50s among three
different sizes of arterioles. Arterioles (40 to 100 µm) were
maximally dilated at 10-9 mol/L. However, this dose
produced only 80% dilation in small arteries (Fig 3
).
|
Vasodilatory responses to adenosine are shown in Fig 4
.
The sensitivity and magnitude of vasodilation in response to adenosine
decreased as the size of the vessels increased. Small arterioles
exhibited the lowest threshold (10-12 mol/L) for dilation
(P<.05) and were maximally dilated at 10-5
mol/L. In comparison with the small arterioles, intermediate arterioles
were maximally dilated at 10-5 mol/L, but the
ED50 and threshold shifted to the right by one and two
order(s) of magnitude, respectively (Fig 4
). Large arterioles
and small
arteries exhibited identical dose-response relations with the
same threshold (10-9 mol/L), ED50
(3.0x10-7 mol/L versus 2.5x10-7
mol/L,
respectively), and maximum dilation (10-4 mol/L) (Fig
4
).
|
The dose-dependent responses to the
endothelium-independent vasodilator nitroprusside are
shown in Fig 5
. Nitroprusside produced identical
dose-dependent dilations in all groups of vessels with thresholds at
10-10 mol/L, ED50 at
9.2x10-8
mol/L, and maximum dilations at 10-4 mol/L. There were no
statistical differences in threshold, ED50, and
maximum dilation of the different vessel segments in response to
nitroprusside.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methodological Considerations
There are two key advantages of
the isolated arteriole preparation
over in vivo microcirculatory techniques. These are important for
quantitative evaluation of functional heterogeneity in
the microvascular network. First, in the in vitro preparation, luminal
pressure and flow can be independently and precisely controlled with
the double-reservoir system previously developed in our
laboratory.7 Second, due to the nature of isolated vessel
preparations, confounding effects of neurohumoral and metabolic
interferences are eliminated. In contrast, most in vivo studies cannot
precisely and quantitatively evaluate segmental reactivity of coronary
microvessels because local changes in pressure and flow are always
associated with application of physiological and pharmacological
stimuli. We previously demonstrated that coronary microvessels are
sensitive to local pressure (myogenic responses) and flow (flow-induced
responses) changes.7 24 These two factors also
interact
with each other to influence vascular tone.17 It is
conceivable that this would be a particular problem in the study of
vascular heterogeneity due to the confounding
influences generated by local changes in hemodynamics and tissue
metabolites. In the present study, the experiments were conducted
under constant luminal pressure during flow variations.7
Therefore, the differential responsiveness to flow and agonist
stimulation among vessel segments most likely reflects inherent
differences in vascular reactivity.
Isolated arteriolar segments are
potentially susceptible to trauma as a
result of dissection and cannulation procedures. The amount of trauma
may potentially increase as vessel size decreases because smaller
vessels have thinner walls and fewer vascular smooth muscle cell layers
and are also more difficult to cannulate. This might artifactually
generate an apparent response gradient. Thus, great care was taken to
minimize possible damage to the vessels during isolation and
cannulation. Lack of damage is supported by the fact that the smallest
arterioles (1) developed a level of active tone comparable to that of
larger arterioles (Table
), (2) dilated equally in comparison
with
larger arterioles to substance P (Fig 3
), and (3) exhibited the
greatest sensitivity to adenosine (Fig 4
). Taken together,
these
findings indicate that the endothelial and vascular smooth muscle cell
function in small arterioles was preserved.
An increase in shear stress
has been shown to be responsible for the
dilation during flow augmentation.5 In addition to the
increase in flow rate, the increase in fluid viscosity (under constant
flow) also initiates vascular dilation because of the increase in shear
stress.5 In our studies, the fluid viscosity was
relatively low (0.8 cp) in comparison with those in vivo
studies.5 11 Under the conditions of our experiments,
pig
coronary arterioles began to dilate at a pressure gradient of only 4 cm
H2O. If we used solutions with a higher viscosity, the
dilation would probably have occurred at an even lower
P. This would
have made precise diameter-flow relations difficult to determine
because small pressure differences (<1 cm H2O) would have
been difficult to precisely control. Because of this technical problem,
we were not able to study the flow-dependent vascular responses under
higher-viscosity conditions. To the best of our knowledge, normal
ranges of shear stress in coronary microvessels are not known. However,
the average value of shear stress in the dog left circumflex coronary
artery is approximately 25 dynes/cm225 and in
the left main coronary bifurcation of humans is between 2.3 and 19.7
dynes/cm2.26 Our results indicate that
coronary microvessels actively respond to this range of shear stress (0
to 10 dynes/cm2, Fig 1
). Interestingly, the same
range of shear stress correlates well with the opening of endothelial
potassium channels,27 with increases in endothelial cell
calcium,28 and with nitric oxide production by cultured
porcine endothelial cells.29 It is worth noting that a
mean red cell velocity between 2 and 3 mm/s was found in dog
subepicardial coronary arterioles between 10 and 30 µm in
diameter.30 31 Thus, flow velocities between 0 and 35
mm/s
in 40- to 180-µm vessels for the present study can be considered
to extend over a large portion of the physiological range. In contrast
with our results, isolated rat cremaster muscle arterioles (80 µm in
diameter) were maximally dilated at a relatively high shear stress (50
dynes/cm2).11 These disparate findings may be
related to factors such as differences in animal species (pigs versus
rats), vascular bed (cremaster muscle versus coronary), and/or
differences in the mechanism of flow-induced dilation (eg, release of a
prostaglandin11 versus nitric
oxide17 ).
Segmental Gradient for Flow-Induced Responses
The present
study, using an in vitro approach, is the first to
systematically and quantitatively evaluate flow-induced responsiveness
in vessels from a single vascular network (the coronary
microcirculation). When our results are compared with data from large
coronary arteries8 15 18 and coronary
venules,14 a clear segmental gradient for flow-induced
responses in the coronary circulation became apparent. Large coronary
arterioles (
100 µm in diameter) appeared to dominate these
responses, and the magnitude of the dilations progressively decreased
in larger and smaller vessels. In a separate study, we showed that
coronary venules (100 µm in diameter) also exhibited flow-induced
dilation of a magnitude (
15% increase in diameter) comparable to
those observed in small arterioles and arteries.14 In
contrast, the magnitude of flow-induced dilations of large conduit
arteries (eg, left anterior descending and circumflex arteries) was
minimal (
3% to 10% increase in diameter). These observations
appear to fit together even though those studies were performed in
different species under varied experimental conditions using dissimilar
techniques.8 15 32
It has been
suggested that vasodilation in response to an increase in
flow is a physiological mechanism that will maintain wall shear stress
relatively constant.33 Our results support this idea,
because increases in wall shear stress were limited during flow
augmentation (Fig 2
). The effectiveness of maintaining a
constant shear
stress was greatest in large arterioles. This is consistent with the
fact that the largest magnitude of dilation was observed in these
vessels (Fig 1
). We therefore propose that the inherent
properties of
segmental flow-induced responsiveness in the coronary microcirculation
may play an important role in the regulation of myocardial blood flow
under physiological conditions.
Segmental Gradient for Endothelium-Dependent Receptor-Mediated
Vasodilation
Recent experiments indicate that heterogeneity
exists among different sizes of vessels in the amount of
endothelium-derived relaxing factor (EDRF) released
under basal conditions and in response to various
stimuli.19 34 35 It has been shown in
denuded canine
coronary arteries that relaxation caused by basal release of EDRF (from
a femoral artery) is greater in distal than in proximal
arteries.35 In addition, a gradual increase in
acetylcholine-induced endothelium-dependent
vasodilation with decreasing initial arterial diameter was found in
rabbit ear.19 Recent studies in pig coronary circulation
also indicate that basal release of EDRF appears to be more pronounced
in small arteries (300-µm ID) than in large conduit
arteries.34 These findings suggest that a
heterogeneous, agonist-induced,
endothelium-dependent response may exist in the
coronary circulation. Our data support this point of view because
substance Pinduced vascular dilation mediated by the endothelial
release of nitric oxide was greater in arterioles (40 to 100 µm) than
in small arteries (175±18 µm) (Fig 3
). However, the
pattern of
vascular responsiveness to substance P was different from flow-induced
dilation in arteriolar segments (Figs 1
and 3
).
Therefore, the
differential synthesis and release of nitric oxide in response to flow
seems unlikely to be the major mechanism responsible for segmental
responsiveness.
Interestingly, recent studies in the coronary
circulation of conscious
dogs indicated that cGMP-mediated vasodilation mechanisms vary
according to vessel size.36 This suggests that a
differential sensitivity of guanylyl cyclasemediated vasodilation may
also exist in the coronary microcirculation. However, the vasodilation
induced by sodium nitroprusside, a nitrovasodilator that exerts its
relaxant effect through direct activation of soluble guanylate
cyclase, appeared to be identical in all microvascular segments (Fig
5
). Thus, it is unlikely that a difference in the sensitivity
of
soluble guanylyl cyclase can explain the gradient for flow-induced
responsiveness.
Another possible explanation for differences in the pattern of responsiveness to flow and other endothelium-dependent stimuli may be that fundamental regulatory differences exist between flow- and agonist-induced nitric oxide biosynthesis. This is supported by a recent study in cultured endothelial cells showing that shear stress and pharmacological agonists stimulate different metabolic pathways for nitric oxide synthesis.37 Conversely, the differences in the distribution of pharmacological receptors and shear-stress mechanoreceptors along the microvascular network could explain the inherent differences in endothelium-dependent responses.
Segmental Gradient for Adenosine- Induced Vasodilation
In
vivo studies in dogs indicate that adenosine preferentially
dilates coronary microvessels smaller than 150 µm and that the
magnitude of dilation increases with decreasing vessel
size.38 39 This vasodilatory pattern, ie, greater
dilation
in the smaller coronary arterioles, is similar to the microvascular
dilation during graded ischemia,40 increased
metabolic activity,38 and decreased
perfusion39 of the heart. This suggests that adenosine may
play a role in the regulation of microvascular activity during
increased metabolic demand and in coronary autoregulation. However, a
major deficiency of the in vivo studies described above is that the
investigators could not exclude local arteriolar pressure and flow
changes during the experimental interventions. It is conceivable that
the preferential increase in downstream arteriolar diameter may be due
to a passive distension of the vascular wall during upstream arteriolar
dilation to adenosine. In addition, the interaction of other local
regulatory mechanisms, such as myogenic and flow-dependent responses,
may also alter the metabolic vasodilatory responses in the coronary
microcirculation. Moreover, the above-mentioned
studies38 39 did not extend to the analysis of
dose-response relations in different-size coronary microvessels. In the
present study, without interference of myogenic and flow-induced
responses, we demonstrated a segmental gradient for
adenosine-induced vasodilation in the coronary microcirculation
(ie, the vasodilatory responsiveness varies inversely with vessel
size). In a porcine model,41 adenosine relaxes
preconstricted left anterior descending and circumflex coronary
arteries at a threshold of 10-6 mol/L, which is about six
orders of magnitude greater than our present finding in small
arterioles (10-12 mol/L) (Fig 4
). This may
support the
idea that endogenous release of adenosine from cardiac
tissue during metabolic activation may significantly influence flow
perfusion by dilation of small coronary arterioles.
In the present study, we did not examine the endothelial dependence of adenosine-induced dilation. Isolated vascular ring studies have shown that the relaxation induced by adenosine is partially dependent on the presence of an intact endothelium.42 43 In contrast, an endothelium-independent response has also been reported.44 45 Furthermore, adenosine may cause vasodilation through activation of ATP-sensitive potassium channels in addition to activation of vascular smooth muscle adenylyl cyclase.46 Although the mechanisms of adenosine-induced vasodilation in coronary microvessels are not clear, our study confirms the apparent longitudinal gradient for adenosine responses in the coronary microvascular network found in previous in vivo studies; most importantly, our study provides quantitative dose-response information for four consecutive coronary vascular segments. Furthermore, we have shown that the response gradient to adenosine was different from that for shear stress and substance P. The difference in the response pattern between shear stress and agonists may be essential for integrating and coordinating blood flow regulation in response to physiological stimuli.
Physiological Considerations
Segmental distribution of local
regulatory mechanisms may be a
general feature of most microvascular systems. Recent in vivo studies
in cat skeletal muscle indicate that slight activation of metabolic
demands causes inhibition of intrinsic tone and decreases vascular
resistance selectively in the small arteriolar segment.47
The dilation of proximal arterial resistance vessels occurs only at
increasing workloads47 and may be initiated by
endothelium-dependent flow-induced dilation
mechanisms.48 These results suggest a segmental response
pattern to metabolic and flow-induced dilation. In addition, in the
rabbit ear microcirculation, shear stressinduced dilation of larger
feeding arterioles has been shown to play an important role in
coordinating the behavior of vascular resistance and optimizing
perfusion characteristics over a wide range of flow
rates.12
We previously proposed an integrative hypothesis for metabolic, myogenic, and flow-induced control of coronary blood flow during an increase in metabolic demand by the myocardium.7 In that model, different elements of the microvasculature would be governed predominantly by different regulatory mechanisms. First, an increase in metabolic demand by the myocardium would preferentially dilate small arterioles through the release of a metabolic vasodilator, presumably adenosine. This dilation would then result in a decreased pressure in upstream intermediate sizes of arterioles, which would in turn elicit myogenic dilation of these vessels. The dilation would decrease arteriolar resistance and hence increase flow. The increased flow would recruit larger upstream vessels to dilate because of endothelium-dependent flow-induced responses. The additive interaction of myogenic and flow-mediated responses would increase tissue perfusion and optimize oxygen delivery. This integrative flow control mechanism is supported by our finding that small coronary arterioles indeed were more sensitive to adenosine than larger arterioles and that flow-induced dilation operated predominantly in upstream larger arterioles. Furthermore, we also found a greater myogenic responsiveness in intermediate sizes of coronary arterioles (54±4 µm)17 than in upstream larger arterioles (70 to 100 µm)22 24 in the same species. Segmental heterogeneity would help to coordinate the overall vascular response of the microvasculature during physiological stress.
The segmental gradient for flow-induced responsiveness may also be beneficial in maintaining a constant flow in the microvascular network via interactions with other local regulatory mechanisms. For example, an increase in local flow could preferentially dilate large feeding arterioles (flow-sensitive segments) and also preferentially constrict downstream small arterioles (metabolite-sensitive segments) as a result of washout of local metabolic vasodilators. These vascular changes would facilitate the increase in pressure in intermediate-size arterioles, which exhibit a greater myogenic responsiveness (pressure-sensitive segments). It is worth noting that the myogenic constriction effectively counteracts flow-induced dilation in these vessel segments.17 Therefore, the constriction of arterioles downstream from feeding vessels would increase local resistance and thus limit the increase in flow. Thus, the preferential dilation of feeding arterioles in response to flow (shear stress) could participate in the regulation of resistance and blood flow in the microcirculation.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received November 10, 1994; revision received January 9, 1995; accepted January 22, 1995.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. M. Canty Jr and V. S. Iyer Hydrogen Peroxide and Metabolic Coronary Flow Regulation J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., September 25, 2007; 50(13): 1279 - 1281. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. G. Soucy, S. Ryoo, A. Benjo, H. K. Lim, G. Gupta, J. S. Sohi, J. Elser, M. A. Aon, D. Nyhan, A. A. Shoukas, et al. Impaired shear stress-induced nitric oxide production through decreased NOS phosphorylation contributes to age-related vascular stiffness J Appl Physiol, December 1, 2006; 101(6): 1751 - 1759. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Koshida, P. Rocic, S. Saito, T. Kiyooka, C. Zhang, and W. M. Chilian Role of Focal Adhesion Kinase in Flow-Induced Dilation of Coronary Arterioles Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., December 1, 2005; 25(12): 2548 - 2553. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Pistea, E. N. T. P. Bakker, J. A. E. Spaan, and E. VanBavel Flow inhibits inward remodeling in cannulated porcine small coronary arteries Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, December 1, 2005; 289(6): H2632 - H2640. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. P. Johnson and K. L. Gould Clinical Evaluation of a New Concept: Resting Myocardial Perfusion Heterogeneity Quantified by Markovian Analysis of PET Identifies Coronary Microvascular Dysfunction and Early Atherosclerosis in 1,034 Subjects J. Nucl. Med., September 1, 2005; 46(9): 1427 - 1437. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. Takahashi, T. Komaru, S. Takeda, K. Sato, H. Kanatsuka, and K. Shirato Nitric oxide inhibition unmasks ischemic myocardium-derived vasoconstrictor signals activating endothelin type A receptor of coronary microvessels Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, July 1, 2005; 289(1): H85 - H91. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. W. G. E. VanTeeffelen, A. A. Constantinescu, H. Vink, and J. A. E. Spaan Hypercholesterolemia impairs reactive hyperemic vasodilation of 2A but not 3A arterioles in mouse cremaster muscle Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, July 1, 2005; 289(1): H447 - H454. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Davis, K. L. Thornburg, and G. D. Giraud The effects of anaemia as a programming agent in the fetal heart J. Physiol., May 15, 2005; 565(1): 35 - 41. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. D. Shipley and J. M. Muller-Delp Aging decreases vasoconstrictor responses of coronary resistance arterioles through endothelium-dependent mechanisms Cardiovasc Res, May 1, 2005; 66(2): 374 - 383. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. C. Schafer, T. Wallerath, E. I. Closs, C. Schmidt, P. M. Schwarz, U. Forstermann, and H.-A. Lehr Dexamethasone suppresses eNOS and CAT-1 and induces oxidative stress in mouse resistance arterioles Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, January 1, 2005; 288(1): H436 - H444. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |