(Circulation. 1995;92:2984-2994.)
© 1995 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Department of Laboratory Medicine (W.L.C.) and the Division of Cardiology, Department of Medicine (W.C.L., J.R.S.), University of Washington and Seattle VA Medical Center.
Correspondence to Wayne L. Chandler, MD, Department of Laboratory Medicine, SB-10, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results Experimental measurements of cardiac output,
heart rate, tissue plasminogen activator (TPA),
urokinase plasminogen activator (UPA),
plasminogen activator inhibitor
(PAI-1), C1-inhibitor, and TPA/C1-inhibitor
complex during the infusions and exercise were used to develop a
comprehensive fluid-phase model of the circulatory regulation of
fibrinolysis.
- and ß-adrenergic agonists
increased TPA and UPA in plasma by different mechanisms:
Phenylephrine decreased hepatic blood flow and thus
clearance while isoproterenol stimulated increased secretion of TPA and
UPA. Exercise to exhaustion increased TPA and UPA through a combination
of increased secretion and decreased clearance. The time course of UPA
and TPA release were similar, but the magnitude of their secretion
responses differed. In vivo, C1-inhibitor bound to TPA at a
rate of 553 mol-1 · s-1.
C1-inhibitor contributed equally with PAI-1 to TPA
inhibition when active PAI-1 levels were low (20 to 50 pmol/L) but was
less important when active PAI-1 levels were high.
Conclusions We conclude that secretion, inhibition, clearance, and regional blood flow effects must all be taken into account when evaluating changes in plasminogen activator levels.
Key Words: plasminogen activators exercise
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Fibrinolysis is closely linked to the overall
regulation of the cardiovascular system. Factors that
increase fibrinolytic activity including adrenergic agonists,
vasopressin, bradykinin and histamine also have more general
cardiovascular effects, producing changes in cardiac
output, regional blood flow, vascular tone, and
permeability.10 11 Older studies using nonspecific
global
fibrinolytic assays found that both
- and ß-adrenergic
agonists increased fibrinolytic activity in plasma, but the mechanism
for each agent and the plasminogen activators
involved were
unknown.12 13 14 15
Fibrinolysis
is initiated by TPA and UPA.16 17 18 UPA
circulates as
scu-PA. Only limited data are available on the source, secretion, and
clearance of scu-PA,19 20 21 yet
chronically increasing the
level of scu-PA in plasma has been advocated as a possible treatment
for thrombotic heart disease.22 Active TPA in plasma is
primarily inhibited by PAI-1 and C1-inhibitor, yet the in
vivo kinetics and relative role of the two inhibitors are
unclear.23 24 25 While it is well known
that exercise
increases both TPA and scu-PA levels in plasma, the mechanisms behind
these increases are still controversial. Both decreased
plasminogen activator clearance and increased
secretion have been
proposed.19 26 27 28
The level of plasminogen activators in plasma
can be affected by changes in secretion, clearance, inhibition, and
regional blood
flow.19 27 29 30 31
All of these factors
operate simultaneously to regulate fibrinolytic activity in
blood. The purpose of this study was to develop a comprehensive model
of the fluid-phase circulatory regulation of the major fibrinolytic
activators and inhibitors. This model
incorporates experimental measurements of cardiac output, heart rate,
and the plasma levels of active TPA, active PAI-1, total TPA,
activatible scu-PA, total C1-inhibitor, TPA/PAI-1 complex,
and TPA/C1-inhibitor complex during
- and
ß-adrenergic agonist infusions and graded exercise to exhaustion;
experimental conditions known to both increase fibrinolytic activity
and alter cardiovascular dynamics. The experimental
data were used to develop a computer simulation of the circulatory
regulation of fibrinolysis resulting in an integrated
model of how secretion, inhibition, clearance, and regional blood flow
interact to regulate TPA and scu-PA levels in plasma. This is the first
study to (1) model and evaluate the systemic regulation of scu-PA
secretion and clearance, (2) determine the specificity and mechanisms
of adrenergic agonistinduced increases in fibrinolytic activity,
(3) quantitate the role of C1-inhibitor in relation to
PAI-1 as an inhibitor of active TPA, and (4) incorporate
all of these findings into a model of fibrinolytic regulation during
exercise.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Materials
Human glu-plasminogen, single-chain UPA,
two-chain high-molecular-weight UPA (80 000 IU/mg),
one-chain melanoma-derived TPA (512 000 IU/mg), monoclonal
anti-human urokinase (No. 394), and polyclonal anti-human TPA
(No. 387) were obtained from American Diagnostica Inc.
Human fibrinogen, cyanogen bromide (CNBr), and Triton X-100 were
obtained from Sigma Chemical Co. CNBr-cleaved human fibrinogen
fragments were prepared as previously described.32
Chromogenic substrate
D-valyl-phenyl-alanyl-lysyl-p-nitro-analide
(S-2390) was obtained from Pharmacia Hepar Inc. Enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kits for the measurement of TPA/PAI-1
complex and total TPA antigen were obtained from American
Bioproducts. Peroxidase-conjugated sheep anti-human
C1-inhibitor F(ab')2 fragments and
C1-inhibitor nephelometric kits were obtained from The
Binding Site. All other materials not described below were reagent or
analytical grade.
Exercise and Infusion Protocol
Samples were taken in the
supine position after (1) 35 minutes
of rest, (2) infusion of 7 and 35 ng/kg per minute of isoproterenol for
18 minutes each, (3) 60 minutes of rest, (4) infusion of 0.5, 1.0, and
1.5 mg/kg per minute of phenylephrine for 18 minutes each,
(5) 60 minutes of rest, and (6) after each 3-minute supine bicycle
exercise stage beginning at 33-W output and increasing by 33-W steps
until exhaustion.
Hemodynamic Measurements
Cardiac outputs were determined with
the use of radionuclide
angiography.33 Heart rates and cardiac outputs were
measured during the final 2 minutes of each infusion or bicycle
exercise stage.
Blood Sampling and Sample Preparation
Blood was obtained from
a forearm vein. Blood samples were
anticoagulated by the addition of 4.5 mL whole blood to 0.5 mL of 130
mmol/L sodium citrate. To stabilize TPA activity, 0.5 mL of citrate
anticoagulated whole blood was mixed with 0.25 mL of 0.5 mol/L sodium
acetate, pH 4.2, within 1 minute after the sample was
drawn.32 All samples were centrifuged for 10
minutes at 2500g at room temperature. Citrate and acidified
plasma then were removed and frozen at -80°C until
analyzed.
TPA and Activatible scu-PA Activity
TPA and activatable
scu-PA activity were measured in acidified
plasma using an amidolytic method as previously
described.32 34 scu-PA was converted to active
two-chain UPA by plasmin formed in the assay. TPA and UPA activity
were separated using neutralizing concentrations (25 µg/mL) of
anti-UPA and anti-TPA added to the
plasminogen-substrate reagent. TPA and UPA activity
results were converted into molar concentrations of active TPA and
activatible scu-PA using specific molar activities of
4.48x1013 IU/mol (TPA units) and 6.4x1012
IU/mol (UPA units), respectively.35 36
TPA Antigen Assays
Total TPA antigen was determined in
citrated plasma using an
ELISA, as previously described.37
TPA/C1-inhibitor complex antigen was measured in citrated
plasma by a modification of the ELISA method of Huisman et
al25 using microtiter plates coated with monoclonal
anti-human TPA F(ab')2 fragments and sheep polyclonal
anti-human C1-inhibitor F(ab')2 fragments
conjugated to peroxidase.
Active PAI-1
Active PAI-1 was measured at the end of each
rest phase in
citrated plasma with the use of an immunofunctional
method.38 Active PAI-1 levels were determined by adding
active one-chain TPA (final concentration, 50 IU/mL) to an aliquot
of plasma followed by incubation for 20 minutes at 37°C. This
converted active PAI-1 in the sample into TPA/PAI-1 complex. The
concentration of TPA/PAI-1 complex was measured in the plasma before
and after the addition of excess TPA.39 The concentration
of active PAI-1 in the citrate plasma was equal to the difference in
TPA/PAI-1 complex before versus after TPA addition.
As active TPA and active PAI-1 continued to react after the blood was drawn into citrate anticoagulant, the measured in vitro active PAI-1 level underestimated the in vivo active PAI-1 level by an amount approximately equal to the original TPA activity. To estimate the original active PAI-1 level in vivo, we added the measured active PAI-1 level in citrated plasma to the active TPA level measured in acidified plasma as previously described.35
Other Assays
C1-inhibitor antigen was measured in serum using
an
immunonephelometric method. Spun hematocrits were determined at each
sample point. All protein measurements were corrected for
hemoconcentration based on changes in hematocrit.40
Model Circulatory System
The effects of secretion, clearance,
and inhibition reactions on
the concentration of fibrinolytic factors were modeled throughout a
simplified human circulatory system (Fig 1
). The model
circulation consisted of a cardiopulmonary segment that
split into forearm, splanchnic, and systemic segments. The systemic
segment consisted of all the noncardiopulmonary,
nonforearm, nonsplanchnic circulatory beds, that is, cerebral, renal,
lower extremity, and so forth.
|
The fibrinolytic system of the model contained active TPA, active PAI-1, active C1-inhibitor, TPA/PAI-1 complex, TPA/C1-inhibitor complex, and scu-PA. The concentrations of these proteins were regulated by three processes: (1) secretion of scu-PA, TPA, and PAI-1, (2) inhibition of TPA by PAI-1 and C1-inhibitor forming TPA/PAI-1 or t-PA/C1-I complex, and (3) hepatic clearance of all factors. Under physiological conditions, scu-PA is not inhibited by PAI-1.41 Total TPA was assumed to be equal to active TPA plus TPA/PAI-1 complex plus TPA/C1-I complex. C1-inhibitor levels did not change significantly during the experiment and were held constant at the resting level for each subject.
Blood Volumes
Resting total blood volume was estimated for
each subject based
on their height and weight.42 Blood volumes for different
segments of the vascular system were calculated as a percentage of the
total blood volume using the values in Table
1
.43 44 Because fibrinolytic factors
are in
the plasma fraction and not in blood cells, the model simulated
secretion, inhibition, and clearance of fibrinolytic factors in the
plasma only. Resting plasma volume was estimated from total blood
volume and resting hematocrit.42
|
Blood Flow Rates
Cardiac outputs and heart rates in the
simulation were set to
the measured level for each subject at each stage of the experiment. At
rest, the splanchnic circulation in the simulation received 25% of
total resting blood flow, both forearms together received 3.6%, and
the systemic circulation (all remaining areas) received the remaining
71.4%.44 45 During isoproterenol infusions, forearm
and
splanchnic blood flows in the model increased in proportion to cardiac
output.11 46 47 48 During
phenylephrine infusions
forearm blood flow decreased in proportion to cardiac
output11 while splanchnic blood flow decreased
proportional to the phenylephrine infusion rate:
![]() | (1) |
where SBF is splanchnic blood flow and PE is the phenylephrine infusion rate in µg/kg per minute.47 49 During exercise, splanchnic blood flow in the model remained unchanged at the resting value up to a heart rate of 100 beats per minute, after which splanchnic flow decreased linearly with heart rate:
![]() | (2) |
where HR is heart rate.27 29 45 Forearm blood flow in the model did not change for the first 6 minutes of exercise, doubled from 6 to 12 minutes, and tripled from 12 to 18 minutes, remaining constant at triple baseline levels from 18 minutes on.50
Secretion
TPA is primarily secreted from vascular
endothelial cells.51 The majority of the
endothelium are in the small vessels and
capillaries.43 The rate of TPA secretion varies with
different vascular beds. Keber et al44 have shown that the
forearm vascular bed secretes TPA approximately 60% faster than the
average rate for the entire body. TPA secretion in the simulation was
simplified by assuming (1) TPA was secreted only by vascular
endothelial cells, (2) essentially all of the vascular
endothelium was located in four capillary beds: the
pulmonary, splanchnic, forearm, and systemic capillary beds,
and (3) TPA secretion was the same in all capillary beds except the
forearm bed, which secreted TPA 60% faster than the average rate.
The source of scu-PA in blood is unknown. While endothelial cells secrete scu-PA in culture,52 53 studies in humans show no evidence of scu-PA secretion during venous occlusion.54 55 scu-PA secretion in the simulation was simplified by assuming (1) scu-PA was secreted in the capillary beds, but from an unknown source, and (2) all capillary beds secrete scu-PA at the same rate.
Brommer et al56 have shown by direct catheterization of the hepatic artery and hepatic vein that the liver is a net producer of active PAI-1. This is supported by other studies, which show that in healthy subjects, PAI-1 is secreted primarily by the liver and not endothelium and that human hepatocytes express the gene for PAI-1 in vivo.35 40 44 54 55 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 During the acute-phase response, PAI-1 may be secreted by both liver and endothelium.60 64 65 66 Since all subjects in this study were healthy, we started with an initial assumption that all PAI-1 was secreted by the liver. As a final study, we compared the effect of liver versus endothelial PAI-1 secretion on the predicted levels of TPA and PAI-1 in the model.
To minimize the effect of circadian variations, the infusion and
exercise protocols were started in the late morning and continued into
the early afternoon. A baseline sample was obtained just before
starting each segment of the study, and the length of each segment was
limited to 1 hour or less:
-agonist infusion average, 36
minutes; ß-agonist infusion average, 54 minutes; exercise
average, 18 minutes.31 67 68 For the
purposes of the
simulation, it was assumed that PAI-1 secretion remained constant at
the resting level obtained just before each experimental segment.
Inhibition
A second-order rate constant of
3.7x107
mol-1 · s-1 was used for the reaction
between one-chain TPA and PAI-1.69 70 Initially, a
second-order rate constant of 3.3
mol-1 · s-1 was used for the reaction
between one-chain TPA and
C1-inhibitor.71
Clearance
de Boer et al29 have shown that the
rate of TPA
clearance is directly proportional to liver blood flow. Plasma
clearance is equal to
![]() | (3) |
where E is the hepatic extraction fraction and Q is the hepatic plasma flow rate. Brommer et al56 measured the level of active and total TPA in the hepatic vein and hepatic artery, directly determining the hepatic extraction fractions. They found that active TPA was cleared at a faster rate than total TPA. As the majority of TPA in resting samples is in the form of TPA/PAI-1 or TPA/C1-inhibitor complexes, Brommer et al suggested that complexed TPA must have a hepatic extraction fraction similar to that for total TPA (39%).23 24 35 39 Huisman and coworkers25 reported similar half-lives for total TPA antigen and TPA/C1-inhibitor complex during TPA infusion.
At rest, the hepatic extraction fraction for active TPA is more difficult to determine because of the low level of circulating active TPA. Brommer et al used DDAVP to increase the plasma levels of active TPA; under these conditions they measured an average hepatic extraction fraction of 71% for active TPA. scu-PA is also rapidly cleared, with a half-life of 4 to 5 minutes, equivalent to a hepatic extraction fraction of approximately 55% in our model.19 20 21 Because liver is a net producer of active PAI-1, the hepatic extraction fraction must be low. Most active PAI-1 is cleared through reactions with active TPA.31 Unless otherwise noted, hepatic extraction fractions of 71% for active TPA, 39% for TPA/PAI-1 and TPA/C1-inhibitor complex, 55% for scu-PA, and 0% for active PAI-1 were used in the simulation.20 21 23 24 29 31 72 While these extraction fractions were the most likely based on current studies, additional simulations were run with active TPA clearance equal to and less than complexed TPA clearance to determine which clearance model fit the measured data best.
Reaction Kinetics
In large arteries and veins, the ratio of
endothelial surface area to blood volume is low. It was
assumed that no secretion of scu-PA, TPA, or PAI-1 occurred in large
vessels. Because scu-PA does not react with PAI-1, the concentration of
scu-PA in the model did not change in large vessels.41 The
only changes in concentration were due to the reaction between TPA and
either PAI-1 or C1-I:
![]() | (4) |
where k1 and k2 are the second-order rate constants for the reactions.
In the capillary beds of the lung, splanchnic, forearm, and systemic circulation, changes in concentration occur as the result of both TPA and scu-PA secretion and the inhibition reaction between TPA and either PAI-1 or C1-I. Using TPA as an example again:
![]() | (5) |
where STPA is the TPA secretion rate in pmol/L per second. In this article, scu-PA, TPA, and PAI-1 secretion rates are given as the rate averaged over the entire plasma volume. In the simulation, local secretion rates were used.
In the liver sinusoids, changes in concentration occur as the result of the secretion of active PAI-1, the reaction between TPA and either PAI-1 or C1-I, and the clearance of the appropriate fraction of each factor as the plasma flows into the hepatic veins.
Computer Simulation
Concentrations of fibrinolytic proteins
in the forearm veins of
the simulation were compared with measured levels of these factors in
samples from the forearm of the subject. The simulation predicted
splanchnic, forearm, and systemic blood flows based on prior studies of
adrenergic agonist effects and exercise as described above. The
computer model iteratively adjusted secretion rates for scu-PA, TPA,
and PAI-1 to minimize the weighted squared error between simulated and
measured levels of plasma scu-PA, active TPA, active PAI-1, and total
TPA at each sample point in the experiment. The error for each factor
was weighted using the between-run precision for that assay.
Because scu-PA levels were a function of secretion and clearance only,
they could be fit exactly. For active TPA, active PAI-1, and total TPA,
the summed error for these three measurements was minimized. When a
best-fit was achieved, the output from the model was an estimate of
the secretion rates for scu-PA, TPA, and PAI-1 at each sample point in
the experiment. The total sum of weighted errors for all active TPA,
active PAI-1, and total TPA values for all steps in the simulation was
also determined for each subject as an overall measure of how well the
simulation fit the measured values.
TPA/C1-inhibitor levels were fit separately. The simulation was first run using the in vitro TPA versus C1-inhibitor second-order rate constant from the study by Ranby et al (3.3 mol-1 · s-1).71 Next, the TPA/C1-inhibitor rate constant was adjusted to produce the best fit between measured and simulated TPA/C1-inhibitor levels.
The simulation was run on a Macintosh Quadra 700 with SYMANTEC THINK PASCAL 4.0. A disk containing the program, a copy of the source code, and instructions for running the program are available from the authors at no charge. While the program is designed to run on the system described above, it can be adapted by a knowledgeable programmer to work on any system running standard PASCAL.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
During the 60-minute rest periods after each adrenergic infusion, most cardiovascular and fibrinolytic parameters returned to the baseline status measured before the first infusion. Cardiac outputs, scu-PA levels, active PAI-1 levels, TPA/C1-I levels, and hematocrits were not significantly different than baseline levels at the end of each rest period. The kinetic model predicted that hepatic blood flow, forearm blood flow, TPA secretion, PAI-1 secretion, and scu-PA secretion also returned to baseline levels between experiments. Compared with baseline, heart rates were on average slightly higher during the rest periods after each infusion than at baseline. Active TPA levels were slightly higher, and total TPA levels slightly lower before exercise than at baseline.
Fibrinolytic Response to ß-Adrenergic Agonists
Infusion
of 7 and 35 ng/kg per minute of isoproterenol resulted in
significant increases in cardiac output, heart rate, active TPA, total
TPA, and scu-PA (Table 2
and Fig 2
). Compared
with
baseline, the maximum infusion rate of isoproterenol increased the
average cardiac output by 93% and the average heart rate by 73%. The
percentage of TPA in the active form increased from an average of 15%
active at baseline to 40% active at the maximum isoproterenol infusion
rate. In addition to increasing plasma TPA levels, isoproterenol also
increased the average plasma scu-PA level by 44%. The kinetic model
predicted an increase in hepatic blood flow proportional to the
increased cardiac output. Increased hepatic blood flow in turn cleared
TPA and scu-PA faster. As TPA and scu-PA clearances were predicted to
be increased by isoproterenol, the kinetic model indicated that the
rise in TPA and scu-PA was due to increased secretion of these
proteins. The maximum dose of isoproterenol was predicted to increase
average TPA secretion threefold to fourfold while increasing average
scu-PA secretion twofold to threefold.
|
Fibrinolytic Response to
-Adrenergic Agonists
Infusion
of 0.5 to 1.5 µg/kg per minute of
phenylephrine resulted in significant decreases in cardiac
output and heart rate while increasing plasma TPA and scu-PA levels.
Compared with baseline, the maximum phenylephrine dose
decreased average cardiac output 29% and heart rate 28%. Compared
with baseline, the maximum infusion rate of phenylephrine
increased average active TPA by 8 pmol/L but produced no significant
change in average total TPA levels. On average, 19% of TPA was active
before starting phenylephrine versus 32% at the maximum
infusion rate. Phenylephrine infusion also increased scu-PA
levels by 4 pmol/L. The kinetic model predicted a 32% reduction in
hepatic blood flow and thus a similar decrease in TPA and scu-PA
clearance. The increase in both TPA and scu-PA during
phenylephrine infusion could be accounted for by reduced
clearance of these factors alone. There was no predicted change in
average TPA or scu-PA secretion.
Fibrinolytic Response to Graded Exercise
On average, the
subjects exercised for 18 minutes, reaching a
maximum exercise level of 200 W (range, 100 to 300 W). Graded exercise
resulted in increased heart rate, cardiac output, and plasma TPA and
scu-PA. Compared with baseline, graded exercise produced a rapid
increase in cardiac output and heart rate that gradually leveled off at
the point of exhaustion. In contrast to the rapid changes in cardiac
output and heart rate, graded exercise had little effect on
fibrinolytic parameters until the last 6 minutes before
exhaustion when an exponential increase in TPA and scu-PA occurred.
Total TPA levels increased twofold, active TPA levels increased
fivefold to sixfold, while scu-PA levels increased threefold. The
percentage of TPA in the active form increased from an average 24%
before starting exercise to 58% at the point of exhaustion. The
kinetic model predicted that graded exercise produced a progressive
decline in hepatic blood flow and thus, TPA and scu-PA clearance.
Average TPA secretion increased fourfold to fivefold, and scu-PA
secretion increased sixfold to sevenfold at the point of
exhaustion.
Effect of TPA Inhibitors
At baseline, active PAI-1 levels
ranged from a low of 16 pmol/L to
a high of 221 pmol/L. Active TPA levels were strongly influenced by the
concentration of active PAI-1 (Fig 3
). There was an
inverse relation between the percent of TPA in the active form and the
concentration of active PAI-1. In the subject with the highest active
PAI-1 (221 pmol/L), less than 1% of his TPA was active at baseline,
rising to a peak of 19% active at maximum exercise. Another subject
with low active PAI-1 (19 pmol/L) had 36% active TPA at baseline,
increasing to nearly 100% active TPA at maximum exercise.
|
Compared with
PAI-1, C1-inhibitor produced a lower
intensity but more constant inhibition of TPA. C1-inhibitor
levels showed less variation among subjects (mean, 3.1±0.4 µmol/L)
and essentially no change other than hemoconcentration during the
experiments. At baseline, the average TPA/C1-inhibitor
level was 13 pmol/L. On average, 16% of total TPA was inhibited by
C1-inhibitor (Table 2
). The only significant increase in
TPA/C1-inhibitor levels occurred at the end of exercise
when active TPA levels were highest.
Table 3
shows the
results of the two protocols used to
simulate the different reaction rates between TPA and
C1-inhibitor. In the first protocol a second-order rate
constant of 3.3 mol-1 · s-1 was used
for
the reaction between TPA and C1-inhibitor. This rate
constant was based on the in vitro reaction rate study of Ranby et
al.71 Using this rate constant, the kinetic model
predicted an average baseline TPA/C1-inhibitor level of
0.08 pmol/L, approximately 100-fold less than the measured level. This
indicated that the in vivo rate constant was faster than the measured
in vitro rate. In the second protocol, the TPA/C1-inhibitor
rate constant was adjusted for each subject to produce the best fit
between measured and simulated levels of TPA/C1-inhibitor.
The kinetic model predicted an average rate constant of 553±100 (SEM)
mol-1 · s-1 (range, 205 to 1139
mol-1 · s-1).
|
The use of higher rate constants for the TPA/C1-inhibitor reaction also significantly improved the fit for active TPA, active PAI-1, and total TPA. The average total error for these three factors for the entire simulation was 316±86 (SEM), using a TPA/C1-inhibitor rate constant of 3.3 mol-1 · s-1, which fell to an average summed error of 188±60 when the rate constant was optimized for each subject (paired t test, P=.006). Thus, higher TPA/C1-inhibitor rate constants improved the overall fit of the kinetic model in addition to improving the fit between measured and simulated TPA/C1-inhibitor levels.
Blood Volume, Clearance Fraction, and Regional Secretion
Effects
While cardiac output in the model was measured for each
subject at
each data point, total and regional blood volumes and regional blood
flows were estimated (Table 1
).42 Fig
4
shows the effect on predicted TPA secretion rates of increasing and
decreasing total blood volumes in the model by 5% and 10%. Increasing
blood volume while holding cardiac output constant at the measured
value resulted in a proportional decrease in the predicted TPA
secretion; decreasing blood volume had the opposite effect. Changes in
blood volume had no effect on the relative change in TPA secretion due
to isoproterenol infusion (or other experimental conditions). Thus,
while changing the absolute secretion rate predictions, variations in
blood volume did not effect the major predictions of the model.
|
Hepatic extraction fractions have been measured for total TPA and TPA activity but not for TPA/PAI-1 complex and TPA/C1-inhibitor complex. To determine the effect of different TPA extraction fractions on the model, three different simulations were run: The first, used in the simulations described above, used extraction fractions of 71% for active TPA and 39% for complexed TPA based on the measured hepatic extraction of TPA activity and total TPA antigen by Brommer et al.56 Second, both extraction fractions were set equal to 55%, and third the initial values were reversed: 39% for active TPA and 71% for complexed TPA. The best overall fit between measured and predicted levels of TPA and PAI-1 occurred when complexed TPA was cleared slower than active TPA, resulting in an average total simulation error of 188±60 (SEM). Equal clearance rates for active and complexed TPA produced a higher error of 277±92, with the worst fit occurring when complexed TPA was cleared faster than active TPA (error, 354±124). In summary, the model predicted that higher active PAI-1 levels result in more TPA complexed to PAI-1 in turn resulting in slower clearance of total TPA.
Both liver and endothelium have been
proposed as sites
for PAI-1 synthesis. Table 4
shows the effect of 100%
liver versus 100% endothelial PAI-1 secretion on
predicted regional TPA and PAI-1 levels in the model vascular system.
The site of PAI-1 secretion had little effect on predicted total TPA
levels in the model. With liver secretion of PAI-1, the model predicted
higher active PAI-1 levels in the hepatic vein versus the hepatic
artery and a slightly negative arterial-venous gradient
in the forearm due to the reaction between active TPA and active PAI-1.
With endothelial PAI-1 secretion, a different pattern
was seen, little or no change in active PAI-1 across the liver, with a
slight increase in active PAI-1 in the forearm veins versus
arteries.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Adrenergic Effects on the Fibrinolytic System
Prior studies
reported that both
- and ß-adrenergic
agonists increased fibrinolytic activity in plasma, but the mechanisms
for each agonist and the specific plasminogen
activators involved were
unknown.12 13 14 15 Our
results indicate that ß-agonists increase fibrinolytic activity
by stimulating secretion of both TPA and scu-PA.
-Agonists, on the
other hand, increase TPA and scu-PA in plasma by decreasing hepatic
blood flow and thus clearance of these
proteins.11 29 47
The ability to model both cardiovascular as well as
fibrinolytic changes allowed us to separate these two mechanisms.
At baseline, TPA secretion was threefold to fourfold higher than scu-PA secretion (70 versus 20 fmol/L per second). Increased secretion of both TPA and scu-PA during isoproterenol infusion were dose dependent, rapid in onset, and sustained for at least 15 to 20 minutes. The time course of TPA and scu-PA secretion in response to isoproterenol infusion and exercise were similar, but the magnitude of their secretion responses differed: TPA secretion increased fourfold to fivefold with both, while scu-PA secretion increased sevenfold with exercise but only threefold with isoproterenol infusion. Prior studies indicated that TPA secretion during exercise was linearly related to the plasma epinephrine concentration.27 28 scu-PA secretion may involve different mechanisms or may show different sensitivities to epinephrine versus isoproterenol.
Regional Differences in Secretion
Recent studies suggest that
major differences in regional TPA and
PAI-1 secretion may exist. Keber et al59 reported reduced
TPA secretion from the leg versus the forearm. In contrast, Gough et
al73 found higher levels of plasminogen
activator activity in the inferior vena cava
versus forearm veins, suggesting higher TPA secretion in the abdomen
versus the forearm. Our model predicted TPA gradients across the
forearm and average TPA secretion rates similar to those reported at
rest and after stimulation of TPA
release.44 59 62 63 The
only regional variation in secretion we included was higher than
average TPA secretion in the forearm, based on the work of Keber et al,
as that was the site of blood sampling in our study. Because all the
subjects in this study were healthy, we initially assumed PAI-1 was
secreted by the
liver.35 40 44 54 55 57 58 59 60 61 62 63
Endothelial secretion of PAI-1 was also
possible.60 64 65 66 The
liver PAI-1 secretion model agreed
well with the finding by Brommer et al of higher PAI-1 levels in the
hepatic vein versus the hepatic artery and with other reports showing
no arterial-venous gradient in total PAI-1 across the
forearm and no increase in total PAI-1 during venous
occlusion.44 56 59 62 63
The liver secretion model was
also supported by Gough et al,73 who reported higher TPA
antigen and total plasminogen activator
activity, lower PAI activity, but no change in PAI-1 antigen in the
inferior vena cava versus the abdominal aorta, suggesting
TPA secretion from lower body capillary beds, leading to consumption of
PAI activity but no secretion of PAI-1. Additional studies are needed
on the regional release of TPA and PAI-1 both in healthy subjects and
during the acute phase response.
Inhibition by PAI-1 and C1-Inhibitor
The second process that
regulates plasminogen
activator levels is inhibition by PAI-1,
C1-inhibitor, and to a lesser extent, other serine protease
inhibitors. Booth et al23 and Bennett et
al24 have reported finding increases in plasma free TPA,
TPA/PAI-1 complex, TPA/C1-inhibitor complex, and free UPA
after venous occlusion, exercise, electrical shock, and obstetric
complications but no UPA inhibitor complexes. Because
scu-PA is not inhibited by PAI-1 (or C1-inhibitor), changes
in the plasma levels of scu-PA are a function of secretion and
clearance only. For TPA, the importance of PAI-1 versus
C1-inhibitor was dependent on the concentration of active
PAI-1. When active PAI-1 levels were low, in the range of 20 to 50
pmol/L, on average 22% of TPA circulated in an active form, with the
remainder inhibited equally by PAI-1 and C1-inhibitor. When
active PAI-1 levels were higher (100 to 200 pmol/L), PAI-1 became the
principal inhibitor of TPA. As little as 5% of the TPA
circulated in an active form, and only 5% of the TPA was inhibited by
C1-inhibitor; the remaining 90% of TPA was inhibited by
PAI-1. The percent TPA in the active form was inversely proportional to
the active PAI-1 concentration in blood (Fig 3
). This applied
both at
rest and at the point of maximum TPA secretion. In subjects with low
active PAI-1 levels, the majority of their TPA was in the active form
at the maximum isoproterenol infusion and maximum exercise points. In
one subject with an active PAI-1 level of 221 pmol/L, only 19% of TPA
remained active at the maximum TPA secretion point. It is important to
note that there is a wide variation in the level of active PAI-1 among
different subjects. Healthy individuals may have as little as 20 to 50
pmol/L active PAI-1 in plasma versus 500 to 1500 pmol/L active PAI-1 in
some patients with persistently elevated levels and over 1500 pmol/L
transiently during an acute phase response.74 The level of
PAI-1 in plasma is important in determining the final active TPA level
in plasma in response to various secretion stimuli.
The rate of TPA inhibition by C1-inhibitor was predicted to be slow, 3 to 5 mol-1 · s-1, based on in vitro kinetic measurements.25 71 Kinetic modeling using the measured levels of TPA, C1-inhibitor, and TPA/C1-inhibitor complex predicted a second-order rate constant in vivo of 553 mol-1 · s-1, almost 200 times faster than measured in vitro. This suggests that the mechanism of TPA inhibition by C1-inhibitor in vivo may be more complex than simple fluid phase binding, possibly involving catalysis by cell surfaces or receptors. Compared with PAI-1, C1-inhibitor was present in much higher concentration in plasma (about 3 µmol/L) and showed less interindividual variation but reacted much slower with TPA (4x107 versus 5x102 mol-1 · s-1) and was of greatest importance when PAI-1 activity was low.
Hepatic Clearance of TPA and scu-PA
The third process
regulating plasminogen
activator levels in plasma was hepatic clearance, which was
as important as secretion or inhibition in regulating TPA and scu-PA
levels. The rise in TPA and scu-PA during
-agonist infusion was
entirely accounted for by decreased clearance due to reduced hepatic
blood flow. Clearance was also changed during ß-agonist infusion
but in the opposite direction. Isoproterenol infusion increased cardiac
output, heart rate, hepatic blood flow, and thus,
clearance.11 47 The model predicted that TPA and
scu-PA
secretion rose threefold to fourfold during isoproterenol infusion,
overcoming increased clearance. If clearance had not been included in
the model, predicted TPA and scu-PA secretion rates would have been
lower.
Three TPA clearance models were studied, with active TPA cleared faster, equal to, and slower than complexed TPA. The best fit between measured and simulated levels of TPA and PAI-1 occurred when active TPA was cleared faster than complexed TPA. Brommer et al56 reported faster clearance for TPA activity compared with total TPA antigen, while Huisman et al25 reported similar clearance rates for TPA/C1-inhibitor complex and total TPA antigen during TPA infusion.
Increased TPA and scu-PA With Exercise
It is well known that
exercise increases both TPA and scu-PA
levels in plasma, but the mechanisms behind these increases are still
controversial.19 26 Plasminogen
activators may be increased in plasma during exercise in
three ways: (1) hemoconcentration, which increases the concentration of
most proteins in blood (corrected for in our data), (2) reduced hepatic
blood flow, which decreases clearance of TPA and presumably
scu-PA,29 and (3) release of epinephrine and other
factors during strenuous exercise, which stimulate increased
secretion.27 28
Depending on the exercise protocol used, either reduced clearance or increased secretion may be the most important cause of elevated plasminogen activators in plasma. Sustained submaximal exercise reduces hepatic blood flow and TPA clearance but has only minor effects on plasma epinephrine levels.25 26 29 75 TPA levels tend to rise gradually during submaximal exercise in parallel with reductions in clearance. When exercise ceases, clearance rapidly returns to normal, with similar half-lives for scu-PA and active TPA but a longer half-life for total TPA, consistent with slower clearance of TPA/PAI-1 and TPA/C1-inhibitor complexes.19 Changes in clearance are likely to be the most important cause of increased TPA and scu-PA during sustained submaximal exercise. Results from the study by de Boer et al29 were used to develop and validate the exercise clearance model in our kinetic simulation.
In contrast to
submaximal exercise, graded exercise to exhaustion
initially produced little change in plasma TPA or scu-PA levels,
followed by an exponential increase in TPA and scu-PA that peaked at
the point of
exhaustion.19 26 27 28
Kinetic modeling of the
exercise to exhaustion protocol in our study indicated that while
reduced hepatic clearance did occur (Fig 2
), it was
insufficient to
explain the rapid exponential rise in plasminogen
activators. Instead, increased secretion of both TPA and
scu-PA was predicted to be the most important cause of increased levels
of these proteins during graded exercise to exhaustion. This is
supported by our previous finding that TPA secretion was predicted to
be directly proportional to the epinephrine concentration in
blood during exercise and epinephrine
infusion.27 28 Exercise to exhaustion produces an
exponential increase in plasma epinephrine levels which, based
on increases in TPA secretion, accurately predicts the changes seen in
plasma TPA levels.
The highest levels of active TPA and greatest percentage of TPA in the active form occurred at the point of maximum exercise. The average specific molar activity of uncomplexed TPA at maximum exercise, defined as TPA activity (IU/mL) divided by total TPA antigen minus TPA/PAI-1 complex minus TPA/C1-inhibitor complex, was 4.5x1013 IU/mol. This was the same as the value of 4.48x1013 IU/mol from prior work used to calculate the molar concentration of active TPA and active PAI-1.35 It is somewhat surprising that the specific activities of the two studies were this similar. The prior study used a less specific assay for TPA activity and based the calculation of free TPA on total TPA minus TPA/PAI-1 complex only. It is likely that compensating errors in the older study contributed to the similarity of the results. More work is still needed on the specificity and standardization of assays for all forms of TPA and PAI-1.
Study Limitations
It is important to point out the
limitations of this model.
First, the site of PAI-1 synthesis is still controversial. While we
chose to model liver PAI-1 secretion, endothelial PAI-1
secretion produced similar results for TPA and only slightly different
forearm vein results for PAI-1. The major conclusions in the study on
release and clearance of TPA were not affected by the site of PAI-1
secretion. Second, it is likely that different
endothelial beds secrete TPA (and possibly PAI-1) at
different rates.34 59 Third, we used estimated total
and
regional blood volumes and regional blood flows. Errors in total blood
volume may affect the absolute level of predicted TPA and PAI-1
secretion (see Table 4
) but did not have an effect on the
relative
changes in secretion found during exercise and the adrenergic
infusions. To better understand regional differences in TPA and PAI-1
secretion, more data are needed on regional TPA and PAI-1 release,
blood volumes, and blood flows. Finally, better measurements of hepatic
clearance rates as a function of hepatic blood flow for active TPA,
TPA/PAI-1 complex, TPA/C1-inhibitor complex, active PAI-1,
and latent PAI-1 are needed to improve the clearance model.
In summary,
the most important findings in this study were (1) the
ß-adrenergic agonist isoproterenol increased plasma TPA and
scu-PA levels by stimulating increased secretion, (2) the
-adrenergic agonist phenylephrine increased TPA and
scu-PA levels in plasma by reducing hepatic blood flow and thus
clearance, (3) graded exercise to exhaustion increased plasma TPA and
scu-PA levels through a combination of increased secretion and reduced
clearance, (4) the time course of scu-PA release was similar to that of
TPA release, but the magnitude of the responses differed, (5) in vivo,
the model predicted that C1-inhibitor bound to TPA at a
rate of 553 mol-1 · s-1, 200-fold
higher than measured in vitro,25 71 and (6)
C1-inhibitor contributed equally with PAI-1 to TPA
inhibition when active PAI-1 levels were low (20 to 50 pmol/L) but was
less important when active PAI-1 levels were high. We conclude that
secretion, inhibition, clearance, and regional blood flow effects must
all be taken into account when evaluating changes in
plasminogen activator levels.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received March 16, 1995; revision received July 5, 1995; accepted July 7, 1995.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-macroglobulin, and
C1-inhibitor: studies in patients with defibrination and a
fibrinolytic state after electroshock or complicated labor.
Blood. 1990;75:671-676.
- and
ß-Receptor blockade of isoproterenol- and
norepinephrine-induced effects on regional blood flow
and blood flow acceleration. Eur J Pharmacol. 1978;50:159-173. [Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]