(Circulation. 2006;114:I-79 I-86.)
© 2006 American Heart Association, Inc.
Cardiac Transplantation and Surgery for Congestive Heart Failure |
From the Department of Cardiothoracic Surgery (A.C., T.C.N., M.M., F.L., G.T.D., N.B.I., D.C.M.), Division of Cardiovascular Medicine (D.L.), Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, Calif.; Laboratory of Cardiovascular Physiology and Biophysics (G.T.D., N.B.I.), Research Institute of the Palo Alto Medical Foundation, Palo Alto, Calif.
Correspondence to D. Craig Miller, MD, Department of Cardiothoracic Surgery, Falk Cardiovascular Research Center, Stanford University School of Medicine, 300 Pasteur Dr, Stanford, CA 94305-5247. E-mail dcm{at}stanford.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results Thirty-three sheep had transmural radiopaque beadsets surgically inserted into the anterior basal and lateral equatorial LV walls, with additional markers silhouetting the left ventricle. Eight animals had CSD implanted (myocardial infarction [MI]+CSD). One week thereafter, the MI+CSD group and 10 animals without CSD (MI) underwent posterior LV infarction by snaring obtuse marginal coronary arteries. Fifteen animals (Sham) had no infarction or CSD. 4D marker dynamics were measured with biplane videofluoroscopy 1 and 8 weeks postoperatively. LV volumes, sphericity index, and transmural circumferential, longitudinal, and radial systolic strains were analyzed. Compared with Sham, infarction (MI) dilated the heart, reduced sphericity index (LV length/width), and increased longitudinalradial shear strains in the inner half of both the anterior and lateral LV walls. CSD prevented this shear strain perturbation, minimized LV end diastolic volume increase, and augmented the LV sphericity index.
Conclusions Prophylactic CSD prevented infarct-induced shear strain progression not only in myocardium adjacent to, but also remote from, the infarct. CSD also prevented LV dilatation and sphericalization. By attenuating shear strain abnormalities, CSD could prevent the heart from entering into a positive feedback loop of further LV dilatation and exaggeration of LV wall stress and may reduce biochemical triggers portending adverse LV remodeling.
Key Words: myocardial infarction passive ventricular constraint CSD transmural strain LV remodeling
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Progressive LV dilation and chamber shape change (more spherical) can also lead to more myocyte stretch and upregulation of stretch response proteins that can result in the induction of pathological cardiomyocyte hypertrophy.1316 Subsequently, the heart enters a positive feedback loop of dilatation and further exaggerated wall stress, which leads, ultimately, to progressive global LV dysfunction and heart failure. Reduction of wall stress and myocardial stretching are important means for mitigating this pathophysiological evolution. To interrupt this vicious cycle, various surgical therapies attempting to reduce wall stress/strain and normalize LV shape have received considerable attention. One of these concepts involves passive external ventricular support, such as the Acorn cardiac support device (CSD), which provides end-diastolic support to reduce LV wall stress and myocardial stretch. A CSD has been shown to halt progressive LV dilation and improve ejection fraction.1724 Although multiple laboratory and clinical studies have been performed to examine the possible mechanisms of CSD on LV remodeling, its effects on regional 3D myocardial transmural strain adjacent to and remote from an infarct are unknown. This study was designed to test the hypothesis that placement of passive external cardiac constraint would decrease postinfarction LV dilatation and sphericalization and prevent abnormal transmural LV wall shear strains.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Surgical Preparation and Marker Data Acquisition
The surgical preparation and marker data acquisition methods for these experiments have been described in detail previously5,25 and are only outlined briefly. Through a left thoracotomy, 33 adult Dorsett-hybrid sheep had 13 subepicardial radiopaque markers surgically implanted to silhouette the LV chamber (Figure 1). Epicardial echocardiography was used to locate and measure the wall depth of a free segment of the midlateral equatorial LV wall between the papillary muscles and a site in the anterior LV wall basal to the anterior papillary muscle (Figure 2). Three transmural columns of beads (4 beads in each column; Figure 1) were then implanted into these 2 regions using a bead insertion trochar oriented normal to the regional epicardial tangent plane. In this study, 33 animals were used, which were drawn from 3 nonconcurrent experimental groups, including a control group (Sham, n =15), an infarction group with Acorn CSD implantation (Acorn Cardiovascular [MI+CSD], n =8), and an infarction group without CSD implantation ([MI] n =10). In the MI+CSD and MI animals, 2-0 polypropylene sutures were passed around 1 or 2 obtuse marginal branches of the left circumflex coronary artery located between the posterior vein of the left ventricle and the middle cardiac vein and loosely snared using the method of Llaneras et al.26 In MI+CSD, the CSD device was anchored to the base of the heart near the atrioventricular groove using 4-0 polypropylene sutures. Excess mesh was excised and the device tightened only sufficiently to provide a snug, wrinkle-free fit (Figure 3). Epicardial echocardiography confirmed the absence of significant changes in LV dimensions after CSD implantation. The chest was then closed, and the sheep recovered.
|
|
|
One week postoperatively, each animal was taken to the cardiac catheterization laboratory, sedated with ketamine (25 mg/kg, IM), intubated, mechanically ventilated, and anesthesia maintained with inhalational isoflurane (1% to 2.5%). With the heart in normal sinus rhythm and ventilation arrested at end expiration, simultaneous biplane videofluoroscopy (60 Hz), ECG, and LV and aortic pressures were recorded during steady-state baseline conditions. All of the animals used in this study had similar baseline loading condition with no significant difference in LVEDP between groups (Sham 11±6 mm Hg; MI, 13±5 mm Hg; and MI+CSD,13±7 mm Hg). Data from the 2 radiographic views were subsequently digitized and merged to yield 3D coordinates for each radiopaque marker every 16.7 ms. Immediately thereafter, the animals in the MI and MI+CSD group were premedicated with lidocaine (100 mg IV), bretylium (75 mg IV), and magnesium (3 g IV), and the coronary artery snares were tightened, producing complete occlusion of the selected vessels as verified angiographically. Ventricular tachyarrhythmias were treated with lidocaine (50 to 100 mg IV) and bretylium (75 to 150 mg IV), as needed. The animals ware then stabilized and recovered.
Eight weeks postoperatively, each animal returned to the cardiac catheterization laboratory for recording of hemodynamic data and marker video images. At the conclusion of this study, 3.0-mm perfusion coronary angioplasty balloon catheters (GUIDANT AguilTrac Peripheral Catheter) were placed into the proximal circumflex and left anterior descending coronary arteries. The animals were then euthanized using sodium pentothal (1 gm IV) followed by an intravenous bolus of potassium chloride (80 meq) to arrest the hearts at end diastole (ED). After adjusting LV pressure by blood withdrawal to match the in vivo LV end-diastolic pressure, simultaneous infusions of buffered glutaraldehyde (5%, 300 mL) were infused through both coronary catheters simultaneously with the balloon inflated to fix the hearts in situ. The hearts were then explanted and stored in 10% formalin for histological examination.
Hemodynamics and Cardiac Cycle Timing
See detailed methods reported in Cheng et al.25 Three consecutive steady-state beats in sinus rhythm were selected for analysis from each study. For each cardiac cycle, ED was defined as the videofluoroscopic frame immediately before the upstroke of the LVP curve, defined by LV derivative of pressure with respect to time (dP/dt) >120 mm Hg per second. End systole (ES) was defined as the videofluoroscopic frame when LV second derivative of pressure with respect to time (d2P/dt2) changed sign from minus to plus, a definition that captures the onset of isovolumic relaxation and is consistent with the concept of end systolic elastance.
Finite Cardiac Strains
Placement of the transmural beadset allowed assessment of transmural 3D myocardial deformations (3 normal strains and 3 shear strains) in the lateral equatorial and anterior basal regions of the LV wall. Detailed strain analysis methodology has been described in detail in our previous publication.25 Strains are reported at 20%, 50%, and 80% depths from the epicardium, with ED as the reference configuration and ES as the deformed configuration.
LV Dimensions and Shape
Instantaneous LV volumes were calculated every 16.7 ms from the 3D coordinates of the epicardial LV markers (Figure 1) by summing the volumes of multiple space-filling tetrahedra. Global LV shape was quantified by a sphericity index defined by LV length divided by LV diameter, where LV length was defined as the distance from the apical marker to the midpoint of the anterior and posterior basal LV markers, and LV diameter was defined as twice the distance from lateral equatorial marker to the midpoint of the anterior and posterior equatorial markers.
Statistical Analysis
Data are reported as mean±1SD. All of the data were compared using 2-way repeated-measures ANOVA with HolmSidak pairwise multiple comparisons (Sigmastat 3.11, SPSS, Inc) unless otherwise specified. P<0.05 was considered statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
LVEDV and reduced sphericity index (Figure 4a and 4b). The MI+CSD hearts maintained LVEDV values, but the LV sphericity index increased relative to Sham and MI (Figure 4a and 4b). Normalized
LVESVs for CSD and MI+CSD were not significantly different from Sham. Changes in LVEDV for Sham, MI, and MI+CSD, respectively, were 7.2±9.6, 26.6±16.0, and 6.7±8.0 mL.
|
|
Group mean transmural systolic cardiac strains at 8 weeks in the lateral equatorial LV wall are shown in Table 2 (ED reference configuration and ES deformed configuration). Compared with Sham, the MI group exhibited greater longitudinal-radial shear strain (E23) in the midwall and subendocardial layer and a larger circumferential-radial shear (E13) in the subepicardial layer of the LV wall in the lateral equatorial region immediately adjacent to the infarct. The MI+CSD group had no abnormal E23 shear strain in this region; there were no significant differences in normal strains (E11, E22, and E33) and shear strains (E23, E13, and E12) when the MI+CSD group was compared with the Sham group.
|
Group mean transmural systolic cardiac strains in the anterobasal LV wall, remote from the infarct, are shown in Table 3. Relative to Sham, the MI group had greater longitudinal-radial shear strain (E23) in the midwall and subendocardial layer of the anterobasal region, whereas the MI+CSD group exhibited no abnormal E23 shear strain. There were no significant differences in normal strains (E11, E22, and E33) and shear strains (E23, E13, and E12) comparing the MI+CSD group with the Sham group in the anterobasal region.
|
Figure 5a and 5b illustrate the group mean longitudinal-radial shear strains (E23) throughout the cardiac cycle in the midwall and subendocardial LV layer in the anterobasal and lateral equatorial LV regions, respectively, for the 3 groups. The MI animals exhibited greater E23 shear strains relative to Sham throughout systole in the anterobasal wall. In the lateral wall, the MI animals exhibited greater E23 shear strain in late systole. These shear strain abnormalities were prevented in the MI+CSD group in both LV regions.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Multiple surgical therapies intended to reduce LV wall stress/strain and unload the heart have received considerable attention recently. One such therapy is the Acorn CSD. The rationale for this approach is that limiting the stress and stretching of the myocardium will halt this component of the remodeling process.1821,2931
In this experiment, we examined the effects of a prophylactic Acorn CSD on transmural strain patterns in different LV regions to evaluate its potential influence on the prevention of LV wall remodeling. Placement of the transmural beadsets, along with high-speed biplane videofluoroscopy, allowed us to measure regional 3D transmural normal and shear strains throughout the cardiac cycle. The data from the Sham and MI groups revealed that posterolateral MI causes substantial alteration in transmural cardiac shear strains both in myocardium adjacent to and remote from the infarction. In the lateral equatorial wall adjacent to the infarcted myocardium, the MI group exhibited increased circumferential-radial shear strain in the subepicardium and longitudinal-radial shear strain in the midwall and subendocardium. In the anterobasal wall (remote from the infarct), longitudinal-radial shear was increased in the midwall and subendocardium. These altered strain patterns might participate in the pathological cascade, which results in myocyte apoptosis and matrix metalloproteinase activation, although this remains speculative. Passive ventricular constraint placed before the infarction prevented longitudinal-radial shear strain perturbations in both myocardial regions adjacent and remote from the infarction. Minimizing changes in shear strains might attenuate the neurohumoral cascade involved in the LV remodeling process.
In the lateral wall adjacent to the MI, however, CSD did not prevent change in subepicardial circumferential-radial shear strain. Nonetheless, the circumferential-radial shear strains in the MI+CSD group were not statistically different from those in the Sham and MI groups. Interestingly, increased longitudinal-radial shear strain was found only in the inner half of the LV wall in the MI group and not in the subepicardial layer. Future studies are needed to explore these effects more completely, that is, inability of CSD to prevent subepicardial circumferential-radial shear strains in myocardium adjacent to the infarction. Future surgical strategies to reshape the ventricle in patients with heart failure should be designed to reverse or minimize these shear strain abnormalities at all wall depths to prevent the pathological progression from a localized MI to global LV systolic and diastolic dysfunction.
To date, no other study has looked at the CSD effects on regional 3D myocardial strains at different LV wall depths throughout the cardiac cycle. Currently, the spatial and temporal resolution of MRI and ultrasound is not sufficient to make the required measurement directly as reported from this experiment. Several studies, however, have investigated the effects of ventricular constraint on 2D strains and infarct extension in LV remodeling. Pilla et al,32 examined 2D strain with MRI and found that ventricular restraint early after MI improved contractile function of the borderzone myocardium and wall thickening dynamics. Blom et al33 showed that CSD decreased the borderzone akinetic area and enhanced myocardial energetics after MI. Moainie et al34 found significantly smaller short-axis strain in infarcted myocardium when Marlex mesh was placed to stiffen the infarcted LV wall in sheep. Guy et al35 reported a decrease in end-systolic muscle:cavity area ratio in sheep with Merseline mesh placed over the entire LV wall.
Previous studies of cardiomyoplasty gave rise to the concept of passive ventricular constraint as a potential therapeutic modality for preventing LV dilatation and preserving LV elliptical shape. Kass et al36 suggested that the benefit of cardiomyoplasty in reversing LV remodeling might have resulted mostly from passive girdling of the heart rather than active augmentation of myocardial contraction. Both human and animal studies have shown that cardiomyoplasty, by preventing further LV dilatation and restoring LV elliptical shape, improves LV function.37,38 In addition to confirming these findings, results from the present study using direct measurement of transmural strains suggests a further importance of passive ventricular containment in potentially preventing infarct extension by attenuating the increase in shear strains both in myocardium adjacent to and remote from the infarct.
Compared with the MI group, CSD prevented LV dilatation and sphericalization. These salutary effects might prevent the heart from progressing into the pathological cascade, which culminates in global LV dilatation and congestive heart failure. CSD increased LV sphericity (LV length/diameter) and is consistent with the Acorn CSD compliance properties in both the circumferential and longitudinal axes. For a given load, the CSD allows greater compliance in the longitudinal direction (apex to base) than in the circumferential direction, which allows restoration of the LV elliptical shape.
These findings of LV size and shapes are consisted with multiple previous ventricular constraint studies. Pilla et al32 and Blom et al33 reported a 39% and 42% reduction in LVEDV, respectively, in sheep with CSD placed after anterior wall infarction. Chaudhry et al17 reported smaller LV volumes and greater sphericity index in CSD-treated dogs. Enomoto et al39 demonstrated the LVEDV and LV sphericity were better preserved in animals with ventricular constraints.
Furthermore, recent clinical findings from the Acorn CorCap CSD randomized trial29,40 demonstrated that CSD can normalize LV size and shape over time, improve quality of life, and enhance freedom from major cardiac procedures. Moreover, the recent Acorn CorCap surgical report by Mann et al40 demonstrated that CSD enhances reverse LV remodeling when CSD was added to mitral ring annuloplasty or mitral valve replacement in patients with nonischemic CHF and functional mitral regurgitation. This emphasizes the importance of a ventricular approach to a ventricular disease, which directly reduces myocardial stress and strain.
In summary, this study allowed direct examination of the effects of prophylactic Acorn CSD on regional transmural shear strains in myocardium in 2 separate LV regions. Prophylactic CSD prevented infarct-induced abnormal longitudinal-radial shear strains not only in myocardium adjacent to, but also remote from, the infarction site and prevented infarct-induced LV dilatation and sphericalization. By attenuating these shear strain abnormalities, CSD may reduce biochemical triggers portending progressive LV remodeling. A better understanding of regional strain perturbations will be important for the future development of surgical and catheter interventional treatments (passive ventricular constraint, Coapsys, Surgical Anterior Ventricular Restoration (SAVR), Dor, Fontan stitch, papillary muscle sling, Menicanti tri-level LV repair, coronary sinus cerclage, etc) aimed at reversing deleterious LV remodeling. Surgical strategies designed to reverse shear strain abnormalities (both direction and magnitude) may be a new paradigm for preventing the progression of localized MI to global LV systolic and diastolic dysfunction, but a better understanding of LV transmural wall deformations (normal strains and shear strains) is needed.
Limitations
Considerable caution must be exercised in extrapolating the result of this experiment in sheep hearts to the human heart. Because a second operation is not allowed per Stanford Medical Center Animal Research Protocol, a prophylactic model was used in this study. Such a prophylactic surgical intervention is not a clinical reality and would be associated with adverse effects, for example, obliteration of all epicardial anatomy precluding future consideration of coronary bypass grafting. Furthermore, although results from this study could be interpreted to suggest that early application of CSD could be beneficial, the appropriate timing for CSD implantation remains controversial and needs considerable future investigation.
Passive ventricular constraint prevented the increase in regional transmural (midwall and subendocardium) longitudinal-radial shear strains after posterior wall MI but not subepicardial circumferential-radial shear strains in myocardium adjacent to the infarct. These results have spawned our current investigation, using quantitative histological techniques and transmural fiber-sheet strain analytical methods41 to better understand the underlying basis of these findings at a more fundamental level and to examine the CSD effects on the LV microstructure (ie, myocardial fiber and sheet) architecture and dynamics. The need for immediate glutaraldehyde fixation for quantitative histological microstructural measurement precluded assessment of tissue perfusion using dye or microsphere injection and infarct size measurements. The present study is highly invasive and, clearly, MRI will ultimately be the best method for this type of study, because MRI studies are noninvasive and allow assessment of the entire LV, rather than just a few specific regions. However, the current spatial resolution of MRI is not sufficient to make the required measurements directly for this study. Most MRI studies have reported average strain contributions over the entire transmural thickness at each LV site or used model assumptions for each LV wall depth. If the transmural thickness of the LV wall is &10 mm, and one wants to resolve the strains of one third of the wall (&3 mm) within 0.05, this requires a spatial resolution of 0.15 mm (0.05 x 3), a resolution available in the present bead column studies but not currently with MRI.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Sources of Funding
This work was supported by grants HL-29589 and HL-67025 from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. Drs Cheng and Nguyen were Carl and Leah McConnell Cardiovascular Surgical Research Fellows. Dr Cheng was a recipient of the Thoracic Society Foundation Research Fellowship Award. Dr Langer was also supported by the Deutsche Akademie der Naturforscher Leopoldina, Halle, Germany.
Disclosures
None.
| Footnotes |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Circulation Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2006 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |