| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
(Circulation. 2003;107:1620.)
© 2003 American Heart Association, Inc.
Clinical Investigation and Reports |
From the Cardiovascular Center, Cardiology, University Hospital, Zürich, Switzerland.
Correspondence to Georg Noll, MD, FESC, Cardiology, University Hospital, Rämistrasse 100, 8091 Zürich, Switzerland. E-mail karnog{at}usz.unizh.ch
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results MSA was measured using microneurography at rest and during lower body negative pressure (LBNP) to mimic orthostatic stress in patients with a history of vasovagal syncope (n=10) and in age-matched healthy controls (n=8). Heart rate and blood pressure were simultaneously recorded. Cardiac baroreceptor sensitivity was calculated with the spectral technique (
coefficient). Resting MSA in the patients with syncope was significantly increased as compared with controls (42.4±2.3 versus 26.5±3.6 bursts/min, P=0.001), whereas activation of MSA during orthostatic stress in the patient group was significantly blunted (5.1±1.6 versus 15.2±2.1 bursts/min at LBNP -50 mm Hg, P=0.002). In the patients with syncope, cardiac baroreceptor sensitivity was significantly reduced under supine resting conditions (8.5±0.7 versus 13.0±1.1 ms/mm Hg, P=0.001), as well as under orthostatic stress (7.3±0.7 versus 13.4±1.5 ms/mm Hg, P=0.003).
Conclusions This study shows that in patients with vasovagal syncope, resting MSA is increased and baroreflex regulation during orthostatic stress is blunted, thus leading to impaired MSA adaptation. These results provide new insights into mechanisms of vasovagal syncope and suggest that pharmacological modulation of baroreceptor sensitivity may represent a promising treatment of neuromediated syncope.
Key Words: syncope baroreceptors nervous system, sympathetic
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sympathetic nerve activity represents a fast-acting regulatory system that allows adaptation of the cardiovascular system to different physiological conditions, such as orthostasis and exercise. The activity of the sympathetic nervous system is primarily regulated by mechanoreceptors and, to a smaller degree, by chemoreceptors.6 The arterial baroreceptors (high pressure receptors) are located in the carotid sinus and the aortic arch, and cardiopulmonary baroreceptors (low pressure receptors) are located in the great veins, atria (A- and B-receptors, Bainbridge reflex), and ventricles (Bezold-Jarisch reflex). These mechanoreceptors are stretch-activated ion channels, which influence sympathetic outflow via an afferent loop to the brain stem and in turn via the efferent loop determine vascular tone.7 There are other regulatory mechanisms of sympathetic outflow, however, as MSA levels differ in the forearm and calf during mental stress8 but not during lower body negative pressure (LBNP).9
LBNP to simulate orthostatic stress is associated with activation of cardiac and arterial baroreceptor mechanisms.10 Levels of negative pressure up to -20 mm Hg lead to a decrease of central venous pressure and activation of cardiac low pressure receptors,11 whereas at higher negative pressure values, a decrease of arterial pressure also activates arterial baroreceptors. A dysfunctional arterial baroreflex has been implicated in the pathophysiology of vasovagal syncope.12 In principle, alterations of baroreceptor reflex function may occur 2 ways: (1) Baroreceptor reflex control of sympathetic nerve activity and heart rate is shifted to higher or lower blood pressure levels (resetting of baroreflex) and (2) baroreceptor sensitivity is reduced leading to an reduced cardiovagal control (alteration of baroslope).
The fact that drugs, which dilate veins, can induce vasovagal syncope suggests a participation of the venous tone in fainting as well.13 Some authors described a failure of reflex venoconstriction as part of the origin of vasovagal syncope.14 Furthermore, the occurrence of vasovagal reaction in subjects after orthotopic heart transplantation provides strong evidence that mechanisms other than the Bezold-Jarisch reflex are involved in the pathogenesis of vasovagal syncope.15,16 Different humoral factors also seem to play a role, including epinephrine and a possible relative lack of norepinephrine,17 a decrease of vasopressin and endothelin in plasma,18,19 increased endorphin levels,20,21 and possibly nitric oxide and serotonin.22 However, the contributions of these neurohumoral factors are still controversial.23,24 Thus, the underlying pathophysiology of vasovagal syncope remains complex and still incompletely understood.
It was therefore the aim of this study to investigate the role of the sympathetic nervous system activity and baroreceptor function in patients suffering from vasovagal syncope.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Experimental Protocol
Subjects were positioned in a plexiglas chamber sealed at the iliac crest and tightly fixed by a belt to avoid displacement of the electrodes during the vacuum episodes. Heart rate, blood pressure (conventional [Riva Rocchi] by Dynamap and continuously by Finapress, an oscillometric device) and MSA by means of intraneural electrodes were continuously recorded during a resting period of 20 minutes. Then LBNP of -15 mm Hg and -30 mm Hg were applied for 2 minutes each, then -50 mm Hg was applied and signals were registered for another 20 minutes.
Microneurographic Measurements
Subjects were studied in standardized fashion, ie, at 2 PM in a quiet, temperature-controlled room, after micturition to avoid any increase of MSA through bladder distension. The last food intake was in the morning; for lunch, only water was allowed. Multifiber recordings of MSA were obtained from the peroneal nerve as described previously.25 Signals were amplified, filtered (700 to 2000 Hz), integrated (time constant, 0.1s), and digitized using an analog-digital board (MIO-16L, National Instruments) and a modified with commercial software (LabView, National Instruments). Data recorded with a computer (Apple Macintosh Power PC 7100) were analyzed offline (MatLab, MathWorks). The results were expressed as bursts per minute and bursts per 100 heartbeats. Baseline values of sympathetic activity were measured over a period of 3 minutes shortly before the beginning of the LBNP maneuvers. The measurements during each step of LBNP were for 1 minute at the beginning of the maneuver.
Lower Body Negative Pressure
LBNP was used to simulate orthostatic stress as described previously.9,10 We used an airtight plexiglas chamber in which the subjects were enclosed up to the waist. Negative pressure was applied with a commercial vacuum cleaner (-15, -30, and -50 mm Hg) and was monitored with a manometer connected to the interior of the chamber.
Baroreceptor Sensitivity
Calculation of cardiac baroreceptor sensitivity was based on the spectral analysis technique (
-coefficient); in brief, subdivisions of the continuous recorded heart rate and blood pressure ranging from 128 to 1024 heartbeats can be used. These segments were then analyzed by fast Fourier transformation (FFT), which provided R-R interval and systolic blood pressure spectral powers. The square root of the ratio of these parameters then was calculated. This method is well established and validated to other methods, ie, sequence method to gain baroreceptor sensitivity.26,27 In our study, we used periods of 300 heartbeats. The baseline calculation was done at the end of the baseline measurement and the calculation during LBNP at the beginning of the -50 mm Hg level; therefore, this level of LBNP was longer than the other levels.
Statistical Analysis
Results are presented as mean±SEM unless stated otherwise. Single comparisons were made with paired and unpaired Students t test (StatView 4.5, Abacus Concepts). Two-way ANOVA for repeated measures (Bonferonni/Dunn post-hoc test) was used to compare responses to LBNP. Statistical significance was accepted at P<0.05.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Muscle Sympathetic Activity and Hemodynamics
Resting MSA in patients with a history of syncope was significantly increased as compared with controls (42.4±2.3 versus 26.5±3.6 bursts/min, P=0.001 [Figure 1], and 60.6±3.7 versus 41.9±6.5 bursts/100 heart beats, P=0.018 [Table 1]). For ranges, see Table 1 and Table 2. At the lower level of LBNP (-15 mm Hg), there was no significant difference in MSA activation between the groups; however, at the higher levels, the activation of MSA in the syncopal group was significantly blunted (3.2±1.4 versus 8.1±1.2 bursts/min at LBNP -30 mm Hg, P=0.022, and 5.1±1.6 versus 15.2±2.1 bursts/min at LBNP -50 mm Hg, P=0.002) (Figure 2). The patients presented no significant increases versus baseline in these 2 LBNP levels (Table 2). Blood pressure remained stable in both groups. There was no significant difference in heart rate between the groups, except that in the syncopal group at LBNP -50 mm Hg, there was a significant difference within the group compared with the baseline (Table 2).
|
|
|
Baroreceptor Sensitivity
Cardiac baroreceptor sensitivity was significantly reduced under supine resting conditions (8.5±0.7 versus 13.0±1.1 ms/mm Hg, P=0.001) and also under orthostatic stress in the group of the patients (7.3±0.7 versus 13.4±1.5 ms/mm Hg, P=0.003). Baroreceptor sensitivity remained stable versus baseline within the groups under LBNP (Figure 3).
|
Induction of Syncope by Lower Body Negative Pressure
Syncope without presyncope occurred in 1 patient after 18 minutes of LBNP -50 mm Hg, but it did not occur in the control group.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Contrary to previous concepts, our study shows that in patients with a history of vasovagal syncope, resting MSA as assessed directly using microneurography is increased at baseline and not only during events of syncope or presyncope. This suggests that there is a permanent alteration in the regulation of sympathetic outflow in these patients. In line with our findings, healthy subjects who experienced presyncope in response to LBNP (-15 mm Hg) also exhibited a higher baseline MSA at rest.28 Thus, patients with syncope seem to be more dependent on MSA to maintain preload and less able to increase sympathetic vasoconstrictor outflow in response to orthostatic stimuli.
Blood pressure is determined by heart rate, stroke volume, and peripheral vascular resistance, and its regulation is highly dependent on cardiac and sympathetic baroreceptor reflex. Afferent activity from the high- and low-pressure baroreceptors in turn determines sympathetic outflow and peripheral vascular resistance. The finding of impaired sympathetic baroreflex control in patients with vasovagal syncope must therefore be related to an abnormality in this physiologically important reflex arc. This abnormality may be due to a lack of afferent stimuli from the mechanoreceptors and/or baroreceptors, ie, an afferent dysfunction or to a dysfunction of the efferent limb to the effector organ, ie, the vascular bed. The latter could explain the increased resting MSA in patients with syncope. Indeed, a reduced vascular response to sympathetic nerve activity would generate an increased sympathetic outflow even during resting conditions via negative feed-back regulation, thus resulting in a chronic resetting of baroreceptor function. The origin of such a blunted peripheral response might be located in vascular smooth muscle cells29 or may be related to synaptic dysfunction of neurotransmitter production, release, or reuptake. In line with such an interpretation, a gene mutation leading to a selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibition is associated with increased MSA.30 Furthermore, an impaired venoconstriction has been suggested as an underlying cause of vasovagal syncope.14,31
The concept of an afferent dysfunction of the arterial baroreceptor reflex is compatible with our finding of reduced cardiac baroreceptor sensitivity at baseline in patients with vasovagal syncope. Impaired arterial baroreceptor sensitivity is associated with an inappropriate detection of blood pressure changes and in turn decreased baroreceptor afferent discharge. This would increase MSA in an attempt to support vascular resistance and maintain blood pressure. In contrast to our study, other investigators tested baroreflex sensitivity in patients with vasovagal syncope with stimulus-dependent methods. Commonly, intravenous phenylephrine infusion was used to quantify baroreceptor function. Those studies showed controversial results; some reported reduced baroreceptor sensitivity in patients suffering from neurally mediated syncope,17,32 whereas another one could not confirm these findings.33 The latter study found an impaired cardiopulmonary baroreceptor sensitivity, which was explained by a possible abnormality in the afferent loop of the reflex arch. This particular finding occurred only during LBNP and not under resting conditions. Whether this abnormality is confined to the venous system or includes the arterial part of the circulation as well remains unclear. In any case, assessment of baroreceptor sensitivity by stimulus-dependent methods (ie, intravenous phenylephrine) has poorer reproducibility than spontaneous analyzing methods like spectral analysis. Indeed, interactions between the drug used and baroreceptor function might occur.26 The present study, which used a more reliable methodology, reveals permanently impaired baroreceptor function, ie, a chronic resetting of the sympathetic baroreceptor function and an impaired cardiac baroreceptor sensitivity. The fact of blunted MSA in particular at the higher levels of LBNP (-30 and -50 mm Hg) suggests the arterial baroreceptors to be responsible for our finding of baroreflex alteration in patients with vasovagal syncope.
Importantly, we also found a blunted activation of MSA during orthostatic stress in patients with a history of vasovagal syncope. Hence, neuronal-mediated sympathetic vasoconstriction is reduced during conditions of increased demand. Impaired sympathetic baroreceptor sensitivity under orthostatic stress also would contribute to a blunted MSA activation. Consequently, in these patients with vasovagal syncope alternative mechanisms of vasoconstriction must be activated to maintain blood pressure, eg, catecholamines from the adrenal glands. Indeed, increased plasma levels of epinephrine under orthostatic stress conditions, ie, tilt table, were reported in these patients.17
A possible pharmacological approach to prevent patients from vasovagal fainting is ß-adrenoceptor blockade. It is believed that ß-blockers inhibit the ventricular mechanoreceptors and in turn lower sympathetic outflow to the muscles. However, systemic ß-blockade has little effect on sympathetic outflow.34,35 The exact site of action therefore remains unclear; some authors reported a direct interaction with baroreceptor nerve endings, which could explain the clinical efficacy of such a therapy.36,37 However, the effectiveness of ß-blockade to prevent vasovagal syncope remains controversial, as vasovagal fainting also may occur during ß-blocker therapy38,39 and randomized, placebo-controlled studies were negative.40,41 The participation of the baroreflex in pathogenesis of vasovagal syncope gives rationale for novel pharmacological approaches, which would interfere with the arterial baroreceptor system.
In conclusion, this study reports that patients suffering from vasovagal syncope have a permanent sympathetic dysregulation of vascular tone due to a dysfunctional baroreceptor reflex arc and in turn an increased MSA. These alterations of cardiovascular control essentially contribute to the pathogenesis of vasovagal syncope.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received October 25, 2002; revision received December 17, 2002; accepted December 19, 2002.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
B. Verheyden, H. Ector, A. E. Aubert, and T. Reybrouck Tilt training increases the vasoconstrictor reserve in patients with neurally mediated syncope evoked by head-up tilt testing Eur. Heart J., June 2, 2008; 29(12): 1523 - 1530. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. Gratze, H. Mayer, and F. Skrabal Sympathetic reserve, serum potassium, and orthostatic intolerance after endurance exercise and implications for neurocardiogenic syncope Eur. Heart J., June 2, 2008; 29(12): 1531 - 1541. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. Gardenghi, M. U. P.B. Rondon, A. M. F.W. Braga, M. I. Scanavacca, C. E. Negrao, E. Sosa, and D. T. Hachul The effects of exercise training on arterial baroreflex sensitivity in neurally mediated syncope patients Eur. Heart J., November 2, 2007; 28(22): 2749 - 2755. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Furlan, F. Perego, S. Colombo, M. Bechir, C. Binggeli, R. Corti, R. Chenevard, L. Spieker, F. Ruschitzka, T. F. Luscher, et al. Baroreflex Regulation of Sympathetic Nerve Activity in Patients With Vasovagal Syncope * Response Circulation, March 30, 2004; 109(12): e171 - e171. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Circulation Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2003 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |