| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
(Circulation. 2002;105:1329.)
© 2002 American Heart Association, Inc.
Clinical Investigation and Reports |
From the Departments of Internal Medicine (A.A.A.J.S., W.W., G.A.v.M.) and Physiology (J.M.K.), Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam; and Departments of Internal Medicine (H.J.L.M., J.W.M.L.) and Otorhinolaryngology (M.W., H.A.M.M.), University Medical Center, St Radboud, Nijmegen, the Netherlands.
Correspondence to H.J.L.M. Timmers, Department of Internal Medicine, University Medical Center St Radboud, Geert Grooteplein Zuid 9, PO Box 9101, 6500 HB Nijmegen, The Netherlands. E-mail H.Timmers{at}aig.azn.nl
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results We studied 4 women (age 41 to 63 years) who were referred for evaluation of arterial baroreflex function because of clinical suspicion of carotid sinus denervation attributable to bilateral carotid body tumor resection. The course of BP level and variability was assessed from repeated office and 24-hour ambulatory measurements (Spacelabs/Portapres) during 1 to 10 years of (retrospective) follow-up. Rapid cardiovascular reflex adjustments to active standing and Valsalvas maneuver were assessed. Office BP level increased from 132/86 mm Hg (range, 118 to 148/80 to 92 mm Hg) before bilateral surgery to 160/105 mm Hg (range, 143 to 194/90 to 116 mm Hg) 1 to 10 years after surgery. During continuous 24-hour noninvasive BP recording (Portapres), a marked BP variability was apparent in all 4 patients. Initial symptomatic hypotension on change to the upright posture and abnormal responses to Valsalvas maneuver were observed.
Conclusions Acute carotid sinus denervation, as a result of bilateral carotid body tumor resection, has a long-term effect on the level, variability, and rapid reflex control of arterial BP. Therefore, in contrast to earlier experimental observations, the compensatory ability of the baroreceptor areas outside the carotid sinus seems to be of limited importance in the regulation of BP in humans.
Key Words: baroreceptors carotid sinus denervation blood pressure hypertension
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In humans, bilateral carotid sinus denervation may result in acute baroreflex failure, producing severe, labile hypertension, headache, diaphoresis, and emotional instability.6 Baroreflex failure may result from bilateral carotid body tumor resection (bCBTR) attributable to damage of the adjacent carotid sinus or glossopharyngeal nerves.7 Data on the long-term effect of bilateral carotid sinus denervation on arterial BP are limited and controversial. Reports vary from normalization of BP8,9 to increased BP variability6,7 and sustained hypertension in individual patients.10
The aim of this study was to assess the long-term effects of carotid sinus baroreceptor denervation in humans on the level and variability of BP. Repeated office BP readings during follow-up were documented and ambulatory (beat-to-beat) BP measurements were carried out in 4 patients with acute baroreflex failure after bilateral carotid body tumor resection. Functional baroreflex integrity was assessed by means of standard cardiovascular reflex testing.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Patient A, a 45-year-old, normotensive woman with a positive history for familial paragangliomas, underwent bCBTR at age 35 years with an interval of 2 months between the first (left-sided) and second (right-sided) operation. Pathological examination revealed complete excision and no signs of malignancy. Immediately after the second operation, the patient had an unbearable headache with a diastolic BP up to 140 mm Hg. Despite antihypertensive treatment during the following 2 years, she was referred to our institution for labile hypertension and orthostatic lightheadedness. Physical examination and routine laboratory examination were unremarkable except for BP values as described below.
Patient B, a 63-year-old woman, had undergone radical excision of a right-sided carotid body tumor at the age of 23 years. Forty years later, a contralateral left-sided carotid body tumor was resected. Surgery was radical, and no malignancy was found. The second (left-sided) operation was followed by attacks of severe headache evoked by mental stress and physical exercise and of postural lightheadedness. In addition, she had developed dysphagia and voice changes attributable to surgical damage to the superior laryngeal nerve.11
Patient C, a 63-year-old normotensive woman, underwent left- and right-sided bCBTR, respectively, within 3 months. Pathological examination revealed nonradical excision of the right-sided tumor. During the first postoperative day after bCBTR, a BP up to 140/100 mm Hg was measured. During a 5-year follow-up period without medication, episodic lightheadedness on standing in the morning persisted. Chronic attacks of headache with a red face and perspiration in the neck during mental or physical exercise were present.
Patient D, a 41-year-old normotensive woman, underwent right- and left-sided bCBTR within 1 year because of a globus feeling in the neck and difficulty swallowing. Immediately after the second operation, she developed a severe headache accompanied by flushes of the head and upper trunk, nervousness, and tremulousness. During these episodes, BP reached 210/120 mm Hg. These attacks occurred during emotional events, and a marked emotional lability was present. Occasionally the patient experienced lightheadedness on standing. She was treated with moxonidine, atenolol, and chlorthalidone.
Effect of Carotid Sinus Denervation on BP Level
The course of arterial BP level was evaluated by means of retrospective analysis of office BP readings obtained from the medical records on presurgery and postsurgery follow-up. Sphygmomanometric measurements were performed in sitting position. BP level was also assessed by means of a 24-hour intermittent ambulatory BP recording (SpaceLabs) after the second resection. Values were obtained every 15 and 30 minutes during the daytime (7 AM to 11 PM) and nighttime (11 PM to 7 AM), respectively. The first 3 automatic BP readings in the doctors office were taken as a second measure of casual BP. Normotension was defined as a mean BP
135/85 mm Hg during daytime and
120/70 mm Hg during nighttime, and a day-night difference
10% was considered normal.12,13 SpaceLabs recordings were performed 2 years (patients A and C) and 3 months (patient D) after the second operation, respectively. In patient B, it was performed shortly before as well as 1 year after removal of the second tumor.
Effect of Carotid Sinus Denervation on 24-Hour BP Variability
Arterial BP variability was assessed by means of a 24-hour beat-to-beat registration of finger arterial pressure using the Portapres device (model 1, TNO-BioMedical Instrumentation). This device is suitable for analysis of BP variability during daily activities.1416 Readings were taken from the third and second finger alternating every half hour. The continuous ambulatory recording was stored on a built-in cassette recorder along with a marker signal superimposed on a hydrostatic height-correcting signal for offline AD conversion. A 24-hour Portapres recording started at 12 AM and comprised strictly scheduled standardized activities, as follows: supine rest without sleep for 1.5 hours (siesta, starting at 2 PM), cycling at 50 W/50 to 60 rpm on a bicycle ergometer for 20 minutes (starting at 4:30 PM), and 2 periods of walking for 30 minutes (patient A, starting at 10 AM and 11 AM; patients B, C, and D, starting at 4 PM and 10 AM). When no standardized activities were performed, patients were left free to perform nonfatiguing daily activities. They stayed in bed between 11 PM and 6:30 AM and kept a diary to report the time of nonstandardized activities. Five-minute averages were calculated and used for presentation of 24-hour BP profiles and BP frequency distributions. Portapres recordings were performed 2 years (patients A and C) and 3 months (patient D) after the second operation, respectively. In patient B, it was performed shortly before as well as 1 year after removal of the second tumor.
Effect of Carotid Sinus Denervation on Rapid Cardiovascular Reflex Adjustments
Functional baroreflex integrity was assessed by measuring the beat-to-beat BP and heart rate responses to active standing, Valsalvas maneuver, and forced breathing. Patients were nonsmokers and abstained from caffeine and food 2 to 4 hours before reflex testing. Investigations were performed in a room with an ambient temperature of 22°C to 24°C. Continuous finger arterial BP was measured by the Finapres device (model 5, TNO-BioMedical Instrumentation).17 BP was obtained from the mid-phalanx of the third finger of the left hand, which was held at heart level.
The BP and heart rate responses to active standing and Valsalvas maneuver were used to assess overall baroreflex-mediated heart rate and vasomotor control.18,19 Normal baroreflex-mediated vasomotor control was defined as an initial BP decrease >40/25 mm Hg with return of BP to prestanding levels and by the presence of a late phase II recovery and phase IV overshoot during the Valsalvas maneuver.18,19 The initial maximal heart rate increase on standing (dHRmax) and the highest heart rate in phase II divided by the lowest heart rate in phase IV of the Valsalvas maneuver (Valsalva ratio) was calculated to assess baroreflex-mediated heart rate control.19 The inspiratory-expiratory difference in heart rate during forced breathing was used as a selective test for efferent cardiovagal innervation. The dHRmax, Valsalva ratio, and inspiratory-expiratory difference were compared with age-matched normotensive data.19 Cardiovascular reflex testing was carried out after removal of the second tumor at intervals of 2 years (patient A), 3 days and 2 years (patient C), and 3 months (patient D), respectively. In patient B, it was performed shortly before as well as 1 month and 1 year after the second operation.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
The first 3 office BP readings by the ambulatory monitor were in agreement with those obtained by sphygmomanometry (Table 1). Compared with office BP readings, averaged ambulatory daytime values were lower in all patients but still above the proposed values for normotension in patients A, B, and D. In patient B, mean daytime ambulatory values had increased from 131/87 mm Hg before bCBTR to 156/100 mm Hg after bCBTR.
Effect of Carotid Sinus Denervation on 24-Hour BP Variability
Prospective evaluation of BP variability by means of repeated Portapres recordings was assessed in patient B only. One month after the operation, the variability of BP had increased compared with before the operation (Figure 1). As can be observed in the BP distribution curves, the increase in BP variability was attributable to the occurrence of more high BP values. For example, after the operation, 75% of mean arterial BP values were found between 66 to 110 mm Hg, whereas 75% of BP values occurred between 69 to 97 mm Hg before the operation. The marked BP increments were observed during scheduled activities like walking (from 111/66 to 160/79 mm Hg) and cycling (from 139/68 to 160/80 mm Hg). However, nonscheduled activities like undressing before going to bed and dressing the next morning were also associated with marked increases in BP (212/99 and 180/100 mm Hg, respectively). During mental activity, such as watching television or having a telephone conversation, BP rose to values between 192/96 and 232/123 mm Hg. During supine rest, mean arterial BP was significantly lower than the remaining daytime (siesta 115/56 mm Hg versus ambulation 134/72 mm Hg, P<0.001, Students t test). In Figure 2, the 24-hour BP recordings of all patients after bCBTR are shown. It is apparent that BP during the day and night is markedly variable in these patients, especially when compared with healthy normotensive subjects (Figure 1, left).
|
|
Effect of Carotid Sinus Denervation on Rapid Cardiovascular Reflex Adjustment
In response to standing up, patient A showed a large initial decrease in BP from 142/92 to 77/55 mm Hg with a slow and incomplete recovery to 108/79 mm Hg after 1 minute at 2 years after bCBTR. The maximal initial increase in heart rate (dHRmax) was abnormally low (10 beats/min; normal, >15).19 Valsalvas maneuver provoked a progressive decrease in BP during strain without overshoot after release of strain. The heart rate response during Valsalvas maneuver was abnormal. These findings were indicative of impaired baroreflex-mediated vasomotor and heart rate control.1820 During forced breathing, a normal inspiratory-expiratory difference in heart rate was observed, indicative of normal efferent vagal heart rate control (Table 2). Presently (10 years after operation), no improvement in the BP response on standing or Valsalvas maneuver is present.
|
Patient B was evaluated shortly before the second operation. On standing, BP decreased from 150/80 mm Hg to 100/43 mm Hg within 12 seconds. At 1 minute of standing, BP had returned to 135/65 mm Hg. The maximal initial heart rate increase was abnormally low (5 beats/min; normal, >13). The inspiratory-expiratory difference in heart rate at forced breathing was just above the lower limit of normal (10 beats/min; normal, >9) at a basal heart rate of 70 beats/min. One month after the second operation, the initial decrease in BP was more pronounced (170/110 to 90/75 mm Hg) with a sluggish recovery (Figure 3, top left). At 1-year follow-up, the BP response to standing had improved, but the initial BP decrease was still marked (55/35 mm Hg; normal, <40/25) (Figure 3, top right, and Table 2). At that time, Valsalvas maneuver showed a progressive decrease in BP during straining without a BP overshoot after release of the strain. Heart rate did not change during this procedure (Table 2). The heart rate response to forced breathing was abnormally low (5 beats/min; normal, >9). These findings indicated the persistence of impaired baroreflex-mediated vasomotor and heart rate control.
|
Patient C was evaluated within 3 days after the second operation. On standing, BP showed a marked initial decrease from 122/61 to 78/48 mm Hg with a low increment in heart rate (dHRmax 16 beats/min) with respect to the fall in BP (Figure 3, bottom left). After 2 years of follow-up, normal cardiovascular responses to standing (Figure 3, bottom right), Valsalvas maneuver, and forced breathing (Table 2) were found, indicating a normal baroreflex functioning.
Three months after bCBTR, patient D showed a large asymptomatic initial decrease in BP from 153/90 to 94/64 mm Hg (59/26 mm Hg; normal, <40/25), with a normal heart rate response. The cardiovascular responses to Valsalvas maneuver and forced breathing were normal.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Effect of Carotid Sinus Denervation on the Level of Arterial BP
Shortly after the second operation, an increase in BP was observed (Table 1) in all patients. This is consistent with the short-term effect of carotid sinus denervation both in experimental animals13 and in humans.6,8,9,21 In animal studies, arterial BP has been shown to return to preoperative levels within 14 days postoperatively.3 In humans, knowledge relies on office BP measurements, where both normalization of BP6,8 and sustained hypertension6,10,22 have been observed.
Our study suggests that these different observations on the long-term effects of bCBTR on BP in humans can be explained by differences in completeness of denervation. In patient C, histological evaluation revealed incomplete resection of the glomus body tumor, which may imply that baroreceptor afferents from the carotid sinus on one side were left intact as well. Normal BP and heart rate responses during cardiovascular reflex testing support this view. In this patient, almost normal averaged daytime and nighttime BP were observed after 1 year. In patient B, dysphagia, impaired rima glottis closure, and decrease in inspiratory-expiratory heart rate difference during forced breathing were indicative of iatrogenic vagus nerve impairment.11,19,23 In addition to efferent cardiac vagal fibers, afferent baroreceptor fibers from the aorta, afferent low pressure baroreceptor fibers, and afferent lung fibers could have been affected by the operative procedure as well, giving rise to a more extensive baroreceptor denervation than a selective carotid sinus denervation. Baroreflex-mediated vasomotor control was still abnormal after 1-year follow-up. The highest outpatient BP values were measured in this case.
Effect of Carotid Sinus Denervation on the Variability of Arterial BP
Arterial baroreceptors provide the central nervous system with a continuous stream of information on changes in BP, on the basis of which efferent autonomic neural activity is dynamically modulated. Arterial baroreceptors are especially sensitive to abrupt transients in BP, whereas they adapt within 10 to 15 minutes to a persisting change in BP.18 Their main role seems to be the limitation of excursions in heart rate and BP in response to short challenges like orthostatic challenge, mental stress, and exercise during daily life. Disruption of this dynamic reflex control of blood pressure explains our observation of an increased BP variability after bCBTR during these challenges. The BP level in patients after bCBTR seems to depend largely on the use of either office or ambulatory measurements. Casual BP measurements in the doctors office on long-term follow-up after bCBTR suggest overt hypertension in the patients presented here (Table 1). This finding is in line with the observations of Holton and Wood6 (in 2 patients), Palatini and Pessina10 (in 1 patient), and Sleight22 (in 1 patient). In these reports, it was concluded from office BP measurements that carotid sinus denervation produces chronic hypertension. However, the effect on averaged ambulatory BP readings seems to be less pronounced. Averaged ambulatory BP values during daytime and nighttime in the patients presented here were only slightly elevated, with a normal daytime-nighttime difference. The marked discrepancy between office and ambulatory values indicates that these patients are particularly sensitive to the pressor effect of mental stress caused by the measurement of BP in the doctors office. The magnitude of this pressor effect is similar to that observed in patients with white coat hypertension.24 Indeed, more pronounced elevations of BP provoked by mental and physical stress were observed in the Portapres recording in patient B after bCBTR compared with before the second operation (Figure 1). A marked variability in continuous 24-hour BP was obvious in all patients (Figure 2).
Lability of BP observed after bCBTR is not solely determined by episodic BP elevations but also by episodic hypotension. After the second glomus resection, patients complained of postural lightheadedness. The large BP decrease on change of posture explains the periodic orthostatic lightheadedness in these patients. The disturbed initial adjustment of arterial pressure to the orthostatic posture becomes apparent by beat-to-beat analysis of circulatory transients and cannot be assessed sufficiently by sphygmomanometry.19 This might explain why initial orthostatic disturbances are not consistently reported in patients with baroreflex failure.7 Our study indicates that the carotid sinus baroreceptors are of great importance to provide rapid adjustment of BP and heart rate to standing. In the 3 patients with intact cardiac vagal control (patients A, C, and D), the reciprocal relationship between heart rate and BP on standing provides circumstantial evidence for mediation of the heart rate by the (unaffected) aortic baroreceptors.18 But the abnormally small heart rate peak in relation to the pronounced decrease in BP, despite a normal cardiovagal innervation,19 suggests a low sensitivity of these receptors compared with the carotid baroreceptors.
Limitations of the Study
Because bilateral carotid body paraganglioma is a rare disorder, we studied the effects of carotid sinus baroreceptor denervation in only 4 patients. Except for 1 prospectively studied patient, BP data were obtained retrospectively from the individual clinical follow-up, which ranged from 1 to 10 years. In addition, there were considerable differences in the intervals between bCBTR and additional investigations of the baroreflex. Systematic prospective evaluation of baroreflex function in these patients is needed.
Conclusion
Our data provide support for the view that after carotid sinus denervation in humans, BP remains slightly elevated over normotensive values. In addition, BP variability remains markedly increased. Apparently, in contrast to some experimental observations in animals, the lack of carotid baroreceptors cannot be compensated for by other reflex mechanisms on the long term. This leads to elevated BP during mental stress and might explain the isolated office hypertension that can be observed in these patients. Initial orthostatic lightheadedness can be observed and results from a large initial orthostatic fall in BP, insufficiently buffered by the aortic baroreceptors. The hydrostatic position of the carotid sinuses in the upright posture in humans gives these baroreflex afferent areas a major role in defense of upright BP and, thereby, brain perfusion. In addition, it seems that the sensitivity of this part of the baroreflex cannot be compensated for by other (aortic) baroreceptor areas. This is different from observations in experimental animals.
Received October 10, 2001; revision received January 10, 2002; accepted January 14, 2002.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Minguez-Castellanos, F. Escamilla-Sevilla, G. R Hotton, J. J Toledo-Aral, A. Ortega-Moreno, S. Mendez-Ferrer, J. M Martin-Linares, M. J Katati, P. Mir, J. Villadiego, et al. Carotid body autotransplantation in Parkinson disease: a clinical and positron emission tomography study J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry, August 1, 2007; 78(8): 825 - 831. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Herigstad, G. M. Balanos, and P. A. Robbins Can human cardiovascular regulation during exercise be learnt from feedback from arterial baroreceptors? Exp Physiol, July 1, 2007; 92(4): 695 - 704. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Hesse, N. Charkoudian, Z. Liu, M. J. Joyner, and J. H. Eisenach Baroreflex Sensitivity Inversely Correlates With Ambulatory Blood Pressure in Healthy Normotensive Humans Hypertension, July 1, 2007; 50(1): 41 - 46. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. E. Westerhof, J. Gisolf, J. M. Karemaker, K. H. Wesseling, N. H. Secher, and J. J. van Lieshout Time course analysis of baroreflex sensitivity during postural stress Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, December 1, 2006; 291(6): H2864 - H2874. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. J Joyner Baroreceptor function during exercise: resetting the record Exp Physiol, January 1, 2006; 91(1): 27 - 36. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. N. Thrasher Baroreceptors, baroreceptor unloading, and the long-term control of blood pressure Am J Physiol Regulatory Integrative Comp Physiol, April 1, 2005; 288(4): R819 - R827. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J.-K. Kim, J. A. Sala-Mercado, J. Rodriguez, T. J. Scislo, and D. S. O'Leary Arterial baroreflex alters strength and mechanisms of muscle metaboreflex during dynamic exercise Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, March 1, 2005; 288(3): H1374 - H1380. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. Stemper, L. Bernardi, F. B. Axelrod, G. Welsch, C. Passino, and M. J. Hilz Sympathetic and parasympathetic baroreflex dysfunction in familial dysautonomia Neurology, October 26, 2004; 63(8): 1427 - 1431. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. J.L.M. Timmers, J. M. Karemaker, W. Wieling, H. A.M. Marres, and J. W.M. Lenders Baroreflex Control of Muscle Sympathetic Nerve Activity After Carotid Body Tumor Resection Hypertension, August 1, 2003; 42(2): 143 - 149. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. J. Fadel, M. Stromstad, D. W. Wray, S. A. Smith, P. B. Raven, and N. H. Secher New insights into differential baroreflex control of heart rate in humans Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, February 1, 2003; 284(2): H735 - H743. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Damgaard, A. Gabrielsen, M. Heer, J. Warberg, P. Bie, N. J. Christensen, and P. Norsk Effects of sodium intake on cardiovascular variables in humans during posture changes and ambulatory conditions Am J Physiol Regulatory Integrative Comp Physiol, December 1, 2002; 283(6): R1404 - R1411. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. A. Lanfranchi and V. K Somers Arterial baroreflex function and cardiovascular variability: interactions and implications Am J Physiol Regulatory Integrative Comp Physiol, October 1, 2002; 283(4): R815 - R826. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Circulation Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2002 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |