(Circulation. 2000;102:2094.)
© 2000 American Heart Association, Inc.
Clinical Investigation and Reports |
From the Departments of Cardiology (D.A.G., E.D.B., K.G., J.E.L., K.J.J.) and Cardiac Surgery (J.E.M.), Childrens Hospital, and the Departments of Pediatrics (D.A.G., E.D.B., K.G., J.E.L., K.J.J.) and Surgery (J.E.M.), Harvard Medical School, Boston, Mass.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and ResultsAll patients who underwent catheter closure of a Fontan fenestration were enrolled in either the Clamshell (1989 to 1994) or CardioSEAL (1996 to 1999) regulatory trials. Physiological values obtained at catheterization helped assess the hemodynamic effects of fenestration occlusion. In addition to survival, outcomes assessed included O2 saturations, medication use, significant clinical findings (eg, heart failure, protein-losing enteropathy, or new arrhythmias), and somatic growth. Of 181 patients who underwent closure, 27 had additional significant leaks. The remaining 154 patients constituted the study group. Median time from closure to latest follow-up was 3.4 years (range 0.4 to 10.3 years). Fenestration closure increased O2 saturation 9.4% on average (P<0.001). The numbers of patients receiving digoxin or diuretics decreased at the most recent follow-up compared with baseline (P<0.001), but use of antiarrhythmic agents increased marginally (P=0.05). Height and weight percentiles rose (medians of 2 and 4, respectively; P<0.001). Clinical decompensation during follow-up of 154 patients was rare (4.5%), with 2 deaths, 3 Fontan revisions, and 1 patient each with protein-losing enteropathy and ascites. No other patient developed chronic congestive symptoms; 21 patients developed new arrhythmias, and 2 had a stroke or transient ischemic attack.
ConclusionsFenestration closure in Fontan patients was followed by improved oxygenation, reduced need for anticongestive medication, and improved somatic growth at latest follow-up. Death (1.3%) or chronic decompensation (3.2%) was rare.
Key Words: Fontan procedure outcome fenestration
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Although spontaneous closure of the fenestration can occur,17 in many patients the fenestration remains patent. Despite the resultant cyanosis, patients with a patent fenestration after the Fontan procedure are frequently clinically "well," with O2 saturations in the 80% to 90% range. Because the fenestration preserves cardiac output at the expense of oxygenation and limits the extent of increases in central venous pressure early and late after surgery, some have argued that fenestration closure is unnecessary and potentially dangerous. Clinical signs of high central venous pressure and/or low cardiac output, such as heart failure, ascites, protein-losing enteropathy, the need for Fontan takedown or transplantation, or death, might result from ill-advised closure.
The lack of availability of approved devices to close post-Fontan fenestrations has limited widespread use of late transcatheter closure of fenestrations. The recent FDA approval of the CardioSEAL device for humanitarian use18 has made device closure easily available in the United States for the first time. However, there is little information regarding indications for and late outcomes after fenestration closure. To provide insight into these issues, we describe clinical outcomes after transcatheter closure of a Fontan fenestration for a large cohort of patients during their first 10 years of follow-up. In this analysis, particular attention was paid to the prevalence of complications that might well be due to chronic low cardiac output or elevated central venous pressures.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Device Description
The Clamshell is a low-profile double-umbrella device, with
hinged arms attached to Dacron fabric.11 The
CardioSEAL is a second-generation device, modified to
improve long-term device performance.19
Implantation Procedure
Implantation was performed as described
previously.13 Briefly, patients underwent elective or,
rarely, emergent cardiac catheterization with full
heparinization to assess feasibility for fenestration closure on the
basis of test occlusion hemodynamics. After baseline
hemodynamics were assessed, the location and size of
the defect were determined. Small (1- to 2-mm) defects that produced
minimal cyanosis (aortic O2 saturation >92%)
were not closed. Fenestrations suitable for closure were then occluded
with a balloon to determine the effects on
hemodynamics. If aortic saturation did not exceed 90%
after 2 minutes of test occlusion, we searched carefully for other
sources of right to left shunting. In general, closure was undertaken
whenever aortic pressure remained stable, mixed venous saturation rose,
and right atrial pressure was acceptable (<20 mm Hg) with test
occlusion. After device release, repeat angiography determined the
adequacy of position and residual shunting.
Data Collection
The Childrens Hospital Department of
Cardiology actively maintains databases for the
Clamshell Septal Occluder and high-risk
CardioSEAL regulatory trials. A retrospective review of
these databases, regulatory charts, and medical records yielded
surgical, clinical, catheterization, and
device-specific information for each patient. The type of Fontan
procedure and fenestration size were acquired through review of
surgical reports. Patients were grouped into 5 anatomic categories
based on echocardiogram reports: hypoplastic left heart syndrome,
heterotaxy syndrome, other predominant left ventricle, other
predominant right ventricle, and others. Any
catheterizations after the implantation procedure were
recorded and noted.
Cardiac index, right atrial pressure, and aortic O2 saturation were collected from catheterization reports at baseline, after test occlusion, and after closure. If several pressures or O2 saturations were available for each time point, the highest value was used. Follow-up information, including important clinical events (eg, new arrhythmias, pacemakers, and reoperations), medications (digoxin, diuretics, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, and antiarrhythmics), and O2 saturations by finger oximetry, were recorded from physician letters and chart review. Device fractures were determined by evaluation of a chest x-ray or by fluoroscopy. Age-specific height and weight percentiles were calculated for each patient. Decompensation of cardiac status was defined as death, Fontan takedown, transplantation, or new chronic symptoms of heart failure (eg, peripheral edema, ascites, and protein-losing enteropathy).
Statistical Analyses
Because fenestration closure in patients with multiple right to
left defects will have less predictable hemodynamic and
clinical effects, only patients with a fenestration occurring in
isolation, without additional significant right to left shunts,
undergoing closure before February 17, 1999, were analyzed.
Descriptive information was compared for the Clamshell and CardioSEAL
groups by use of the Fisher exact test for categorical variables
and the Wilcoxon rank sum test for continuous variables.
Data from the 2 cohorts were then combined for analysis.
Pretest and posttest occlusion measurements of
hemodynamic cardiac catheterization
variables were compared by paired t test. Similar
comparisons were made between precatheterization
O2 saturations and those at the most recent
follow-up. Changes in height and weight percentiles were evaluated by
the Wilcoxon signed rank test, and changes in medication use
were evaluated by the McNemar test. Linear regression analysis
was used to explore the relationships between change in
O2 saturation and patient characteristics;
similarly, logistic regression analysis was used for the
outcome variable decompensation in cardiac status. Freedom from
death and decompensation were estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Implantation Procedure
A single device was implanted in 153 of 154 patients; 1 patient
had 2 devices. Most devices were 17 mm (n=143, 92.9%), although 9
were 23 mm, 1 was 28 mm, and 1 was a custom device.
Hemodynamic information for this cohort is
presented in Table 2
. Baffle
pressure and arterial O2 saturation
rose with test occlusion (mean increases of 1.5±2.3 mm Hg
[P<0.001] and 5.3±4.8% [P<0.001],
respectively), whereas cardiac index was lower (mean decrease 0.5±0.9
L · min-1 ·
m-2, P<0.001). Complications at
implantation were uncommon, occurring in 9 of 154 patients (5.8%).
They included 2 patients with device embolizations subsequently
retrieved, 4 additional patients with acute transient ECG changes
requiring medical intervention, 1 patient with an arterial
pulse loss requiring heparin therapy, 1 patient with vessel dissection
(requiring surgical repair) after device embolization and retrieval
(noted above), and 2 patients with hemodynamically
silent device malpositions. No complication produced long-term
sequelae.
|
Follow-Up
Median time from catheterization to most recent
follow-up was 3.4 years (range 0.4 to 10.3 years). Differences between
patients who received a Clamshell versus a CardioSEAL device were
primarily due to a shift toward delay of closure in stable patients,
once the possibility of spontaneous closure was recognized. Median time
from Fontan procedure to first catheterization was
longer for the CardioSEAL patients compared with the Clamshell group
(33 versus 5 months, P<0.001), and median age at
catheterization was older (6.9 versus 4.4 years,
P<0.001). Median time from catheterization
to last follow-up was longer for Clamshell patients (6.1 versus 1.7
years, P<0.001), and the CardioSEAL patients were slightly
younger at the time of the Fontan procedure (2.8 versus 4.0 years,
P=0.04).
Improvement in O2 Saturations
Because information collected for the Clamshell patients focused
on safety, not efficacy, O2 saturation at latest
follow-up was missing from the database for 48 patients. However, in
106 patients with available information, there was a significant mean
increase of 9.4±5.8% in O2 saturation from
baseline to last follow-up (P<0.001). Eight patients had an
O2 saturation <90% at last follow-up. The
magnitude of the increase in oxygenation was greatest
in the patients who had the lowest preprocedure saturations
(P<0.001). After adjusting for preprocedure saturation in a
linear regression model, there were no significant associations between
the amount that the O2 saturation improved and
anatomy, device size, age at Fontan procedure, age at
catheterization, or time from
catheterization to last follow-up.
Medication Usage and Growth
Table 3
displays clinical
information on patients before the procedure and at the most recent
follow-up. Among patients whose medication use changed, use of digoxin,
diuretics, and warfarin decreased (P<0.001,
P<0.001, and P=0.03, respectively). There was a
borderline increase in the use of antiarrhythmics (P=0.05).
Age-specific height and weight percentiles both showed a small but
significant increase from preprocedure to most recent follow-up (median
increases of 2 percentiles [P<0.001] and 4 percentiles
[P<0.001], respectively).
|
Clinical Decompensation
No patients died during the placement of the device. Two deaths
occurred (2.6 and 8.3 years after closure) during the follow-up period.
A 6.5-year-old with double-outlet right ventricle/severe mitral
stenosis had an atrial septectomy followed by a fenestrated
Fontan procedure at age 3.9 years. Pleural effusions and cyanosis
complicated the early postoperative course; the fenestration was closed
on postoperative day 12. After 2.5 good years, he developed congestive
heart failure and wheezing and was treated with ß-agonists. After an
unexpected arrest associated with ventricular
fibrillation/ventricular tachycardia, his
ventricular function was poor; he died on the second
hospital day. A second patient with double-inlet left ventricle
underwent a fenestrated Fontan procedure at 10 years of age, with
elective fenestration closure 1 month after surgery. He developed
progressive aortic regurgitation and left
ventricular dysfunction resulting in congestive symptoms 8
years later. He acutely decompensated with a pericardial effusion and
died at attempted pericardiocentesis.
Three patients underwent subsequent intracardiac surgery. Two patients had right atrial reduction surgery and revision to a lateral tunnel or extracardiac baffle to treat either right pulmonary vein compression or intractable arrhythmias. The fenestration closure devices were explanted at Fontan revision. No other devices were explanted. The third patient, with an atriopulmonary connection, had a right Glenn anastomosis to treat right pulmonary artery stenosis. All 3 were doing well at latest follow-up.
The criteria for decompensation were met in 2 additional patients: 1
had chronic ascites, and 1 developed protein-losing enteropathy. No
other patient developed chronic congestive symptoms, although 7 had
transient fluid retention. The estimated survival probability was 100%
at 2 years and 98.8% at 5 years after closure
(Figure
, panel A). The estimated
probability of freedom from decompensation of cardiac status (including
death, Fontan takedown or revision, and new symptoms of chronic heart
failure) was 98.6% at 2 years and 96.0% at 5 years after closure
(Figure
, panel B). Patients who failed were more likely to have
a shorter interval between the Fontan procedure and device implantation
(median 0.7 versus 10 months, P=0.001).
|
New-Onset Arrhythmias
New-onset arrhythmias after fenestration closure were
noted in 21 patients (13.6%): 11 had sick sinus syndrome or sinus
bradycardia, 4 had atrial fibrillation or flutter, 2 patients developed
ventricular arrhythmias, and in 4 patients, other
dysrhythmias were noted. Pacemaker placement followed device closure
after varying intervals in 6 patients, and 4 patients were started on
antiarrhythmic agents after closure.
Other Complications or Observations
Two patients had cerebral vascular accidents or transient
ischemic attacks after device closure. Parenthetically, the
number of patients receiving warfarin decreased from 18 to 7 (4%)
after fenestration closure (Table 3
). In 2 patients, an
incidental arm fracture was found on routine follow-up radiograph. Both
patients are doing clinically well.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Previous Work
Prior studies from several institutions have described the changes
in early morbidity and mortality associated with using a fenestration
in Fontan patients,9 14 16 the hemodynamic
effects of test occlusion and selection of patients for
transcatheter closure,15 20 the methodology
for transcatheter closure of fenestrations with the use of
several different devices,13 17 21 22 and the short-term
follow-up of those patients. The present study, although
significantly increasing the number of patients available for
analysis, does not substantively alter the conclusions of those
prior studies: generally, test occlusion modestly increases
O2 saturations, modestly increases right-sided
pressures, and modestly reduces cardiac output. Marked increases in
right-sided pressures or falls in cardiac output at test occlusion are
taken as signs to defer late closure. Closure is performed
percutaneously, with use of a sheath, and is generally
safe, with no related mortality or chronic morbidity in 154
patients.
Focus of Study
The present study has been designed to provide insight
regarding different questions. The absence of device availability did
not stop surgeons from performing fenestrated Fontan procedures. As
these patients were, by necessity, managed medically, cardiologists
discovered that their clinical courses were generally benign, despite
persistent cyanosis in those cases who did not spontaneously close
their fenestrations. Several questions arose from that experience: Is
fenestration closure really necessary or even beneficial? Will closure
produce a significant increase in the need for anticongestive therapy?
Will it increase the prevalence of ascites, effusions, or
protein-losing enteropathy? Finally, does fenestration closure increase
mortality in Fontan patients?23 24 25 Given the frequency
with which the Fontan procedure is performed and the high morbidity and
mortality of a failed Fontan procedure, these are important
questions.
The present study is uniquely suited to address many of these issues. The very first patients to undergo fenestration with late test occlusion and closure13 are included in the data set, thus providing the longest possible follow-up. The surgical techniques, catheter techniques, device characteristics, and patient selection have been largely constant for the entire 10-year period. Finally, the fact that all patients were enrolled in FDA-supervised trials allowed for prospective information gathering in all patients and follow-up in each of 154 patients.
Mortality, Morbidity, and Failure
The first striking finding in the present study is the
infrequency of deaths (2 of 154 patients), a finding that contrasts
sharply with prior large series reporting late survival after the
Fontan procedure.23 24 25 Because our sample includes only
patients who underwent successful closure and is thus highly selective,
we would not interpret these data to mean that the lateral tunnel
fenestrated Fontan is the procedure of choice for single ventricle.
However, these data do support a conclusion that fenestration closure
in suitable patients does not increase the risk of death in the first 5
to 10 years of follow-up.
Also striking is the infrequency of morbidity or onset of failure of the Fontan circulation. There were only 3 reoperations, each apparently unrelated to fenestration closure, and each was successful. Two other patients had features of chronic decompensation: one developed protein-losing enteropathy, and one developed ascites. As above, these data support a conclusion that fenestration closure in suitable patients has a minimal impact on the prevalence of complications associated with elevated right heart pressures or low cardiac output. Our general criteria for closure include all patients who do not experience a fall in blood pressure or mixed venous saturation or a rise in right atrial pressure >20 mm with test occlusion.
Beneficial or Adverse Effects of Fenestration Closure
A persistent rise in O2 saturation is
expected after fenestration closure, and the present study confirms
that expectation. However, the small but significant growth improvement
seen in these children was not expected. Although a return toward
normal growth may have been due to the original fenestrated Fontan
procedure, the average delay between surgical performance of
the fenestrated Fontan and closure of the fenestration (9 months)
argues against that hypothesis. Similarly, the reduced need for
anticongestive therapy after fenestration closure was unanticipated.
This may reflect an improvement in O2 delivery
and/or ventricular function, or it may represent
(warranted or unwarranted) a sense of clinical well-being on the part
of patients and caregivers. Classic studies have demonstrated that
children aged >2 years with persistent cyanosis (mean saturation 86%)
will have depressed ventricular function that may persist
after restoration of an acyanotic circulation.26
Regardless of the explanations, the reduced use of digitalis and
diuretics provides strong support for the conclusion noted
above: fenestration closure does not increase the prevalence of right
heart failure and may well improve overall
cardiovascular status.
The possible adverse effects of fenestration closure include new arrhythmias or strokes. Both are known to occur in patients after a Fontan procedure, with or without fenestration.23 27 28 29 30 The present study provides little new insight into the issue of whether fenestration closure increases or decreases the prevalence of late arrhythmias. In contrast, only 2 strokes occurred after fenestration closure, despite the fact that only 7 of 154 patients are receiving warfarin.
Indications for and Timing of Closure
Although not specifically addressed by these data, the indications
for closure were, in our practice, an aortic saturation <90% and
tolerance of test occlusion, as noted above. These imprecise guidelines
reflect, accurately, the imprecise nature of patient selection for
fenestration closure. However, because the vast majority of patients
either underwent closure or had fenestrations too small to warrant
closure, further efforts to improve the precision of patient selection
criteria are unlikely to yield significant clinical insights.
In contrast, the optimal timing of fenestration closure remains an important unanswered question. The marked difference in timing of closure between the Clamshell versus CardioSEAL groups (5 months versus 33 months after surgery) did not produce any noticeable adverse clinical effects; indeed, it is likely that a significant number of fenestrations closed spontaneously. Supporting the thesis that closure should be delayed is the finding that early closure was associated with cardiac decompensation. However, the adverse effects of persistent cyanosis are too important to ignore. Careful noninvasive and/or invasive studies on the time course of spontaneous fenestration closure would help define a recommendation for planning fenestration closure.
Conclusions
In summary, we have found that test occlusion and subsequent
transcatheter closure of Fontan fenestrations constitute a
successful clinical strategy in the management of patients with
single-ventricle physiology. Late closure is followed by improved
oxygenation, reduced use of anticongestive medications,
and improved somatic growth. Failure to tolerate late test occlusion is
rare. Death, protein-losing enteropathy, and ascites are also rare
after fenestration closure, with a follow-up as long as 10 years. Early
closure may predispose to cardiac decompensation or Fontan takedown and
would be unnecessary in cases of spontaneous closure. These findings
support a recommendation that patients with fenestrated Fontan
procedures should undergo late (>6 months after surgery)
transcatheter closure if O2
saturations are <90% and test occlusion is tolerated. More precise
recommendations on the timing of late closure await further
studies.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Dr Lock is a coinventor of the Clamshell/CardioSEAL device, and his institution receives royalties on its commercial sales; he also participates in regulatory studies of this device.
Received April 17, 2000; revision received May 25, 2000; accepted June 6, 2000.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. Meadows, P. Lang, G. Marx, and J. Rhodes Fontan Fenestration Closure Has No Acute Effect on Exercise Capacity but Improves Ventilatory Response to Exercise J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., July 8, 2008; 52(2): 108 - 113. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Ono, D. Boethig, H. Goerler, M. Lange, M. Westhoff-Bleck, and T. Breymann Somatic development long after the Fontan operation: factors influencing catch-up growth. J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., November 1, 2007; 134(5): 1199 - 1206. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
I. Inglessis and M. J. Landzberg Interventional Catheterization in Adult Congenital Heart Disease Circulation, March 27, 2007; 115(12): 1622 - 1633. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Khairy, N. Poirier, and L.-A. Mercier Univentricular Heart Circulation, February 13, 2007; 115(6): 800 - 812. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Ono, D. Boethig, H. Goerler, M. Lange, M. Westhoff-Bleck, and T. Breymann Clinical outcome of patients 20 years after Fontan operation -- effect of fenestration on late morbidity Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., December 1, 2006; 30(6): 923 - 929. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G Agnoletti, Y Boudjemline, P Ou, D Bonnet, and D Sidi Right to left shunt through interatrial septal defects in patients with congenital heart disease: results of interventional closure Heart, June 1, 2006; 92(6): 827 - 831. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Khairy, M. J. Landzberg, M. A. Gatzoulis, L.-A. Mercier, S. M. Fernandes, J.-M. Cote, J.-P. Lavoie, A. Fournier, P. G. Guerra, A. Frogoudaki, et al. Transvenous Pacing Leads and Systemic Thromboemboli in Patients With Intracardiac Shunts: A Multicenter Study Circulation, May 23, 2006; 113(20): 2391 - 2397. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. M. Tak, S. Al-Jureidini, I. Balfour, M. Hohenberg, B. Kountzman, and A. C. Fiore An Alternative Method to Fenestrate the Extracardiac Fontan Conduit in a Patient with Atrial Situs Inversus and Levocardia Ann. Thorac. Surg., February 1, 2006; 81(2): 746 - 748. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Garekar, H.L. Walters, R.E. Delius, R.L. Thomas, and R.D. Ross Intermediate outcomes of fenestrated Fontan procedures J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., January 1, 2006; 131(1): 247 - 249. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. Pekkan, H. D. Kitajima, D. de Zelicourt, J. M. Forbess, W. J. Parks, M. A. Fogel, S. Sharma, K. R. Kanter, D. Frakes, and A. P. Yoganathan Total Cavopulmonary Connection Flow With Functional Left Pulmonary Artery Stenosis: Angioplasty and Fenestration In Vitro Circulation, November 22, 2005; 112(21): 3264 - 3271. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. A. Jayakumar, L. J. Addonizio, M. R. Kichuk-Chrisant, M. E. Galantowicz, J. M. Lamour, J. M. Quaegebeur, and D. T. Hsu Cardiac transplantation after the Fontan or Glenn procedure J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., November 16, 2004; 44(10): 2065 - 2072. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. M. Zahn, N. C. Dobrolet, D. G. Nykanen, J. Ojito, R. L. Hannan, and R. P. Burke Interventional catheterization performed in the early postoperative period after congenital heart surgery in children J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., April 7, 2004; 43(7): 1264 - 1269. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. J. Bradley, D. G. Human, J.A. G. Culham, W. J. Duncan, M. W. H. Patterson, J. G. LeBlanc, and S. S. Sett Clipped tube fenestration after extracardiac Fontan allows for simple transcatheter coil occlusion Ann. Thorac. Surg., December 1, 2003; 76(6): 1923 - 1928. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. P. McGuirk, D. S. Winlaw, S. M. Langley, O. F. Stumper, J. V. de Giovanni, J. G. Wright, W. J. Brawn, and D. J. Barron The impact of ventricular morphology on midterm outcome following completion total cavopulmonary connection Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., July 1, 2003; 24(1): 37 - 46. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. A Friedman Novel mapping techniques for cardiac electrophysiology Heart, June 1, 2002; 87(6): 575 - 582. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. S. Lemler, W. A. Scott, S. R. Leonard, D. Stromberg, and C. Ramaciotti Fenestration Improves Clinical Outcome of the Fontan Procedure: A Prospective, Randomized Study Circulation, January 15, 2002; 105(2): 207 - 212. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Circulation Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2000 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |