(Circulation. 2000;102:1623.)
© 2000 American Heart Association, Inc.
Clinical Investigation and Reports |
From Department of Exercise and Sport Science (M.J.L., P.A.E., B.B.S.), University of Utah, Salt Lake City; LDS Hospital Fitness Institute (T.D.A., F.G.Y.), Salt Lake City, Utah; and Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics (B.E.A.), University of South Carolina, Columbia.
Correspondence to Michael J. LaMonte, PhD, Prevention Research Center, School of Public Health, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC 29208. E-mail mjlamont{at}sph.sc.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and ResultsComprehensive health examinations were performed on 3232 men (age 45.9±10.8 years) and 1128 women (age 43.8±12.8 years) between 1975 and 1997. Maximal treadmill exercise testing was used to categorize those with (12% of the men and 10% of the women) and those without CHD into age- and sex-specific cardiorespiratory fitness quintiles. After adjustments for age, body fat, smoking status, and family history of CHD, favorable associations were observed between fitness and most CHD risk factors among men and women, regardless of CHD status.
ConclusionsThese data indicate that enhanced levels of cardiorespiratory fitness may confer resistance to elevations in CHD risk factors even in a low-risk sample of middle-aged men and women. Furthermore, these findings reinforce current public health recommendations that advocate increased national levels of physical activity and cardiorespiratory fitness for primary and secondary CHD prevention.
Key Words: cardiovascular disease risk factors exercise women
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A current understanding of the relationship between sedentary lifestyles and CHD has emerged from pioneering works that used self-reported physical activity to represent the degree of exposure.1 Cardiorespiratory fitness assessed with maximal exercise testing is a more precise and reliable measure than self-reported physical activity. This may in part explain the larger risk estimates for death due to CHD associated with low levels of measured fitness compared with self-reported physical inactivity.1 Correlations between carefully aggregated habitual activity levels and cardiorespiratory fitness measured with maximal exercise testing have been large (r=0.50 to 0.83).5 The objective measure of cardiorespiratory fitness might therefore more accurately reflect the consequences of a sedentary or irregularly active lifestyle.
Compared with physical activity,1 3 fewer reports are available on the association between cardiorespiratory fitness and CHD.6 7 8 9 10 Existing studies have often had modest sample sizes with relatively small percentages of women. Cardiorespiratory fitness has frequently been extrapolated from submaximal exercise, few reports have included participants with existing CHD, and there is a paucity of data from low-risk populations. In the present investigation, we described the association between measured cardiorespiratory fitness and coronary risk factors in a large low-risk sample of middle-aged men and women with and without CHD.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A detailed health-fitness evaluation was performed by a licensed physician and qualified technician. Personal and familial health histories were obtained through interview procedures. Clinical measurements included resting and exercise ECG and blood pressure, fasting blood glucose and lipids, pulmonary function, body composition, and cardiorespiratory fitness. Body mass index (in kg/m2) was calculated on the basis of standing weight and height, and percent body fat11 was determined hydrodensitometrically.12
Cardiorespiratory Fitness Test
Most participants (>97%) completed a maximal treadmill
exercise test. Treadmill test time was used to predict maximal oxygen
consumption (
O2 max) according
to Bruce et al.13 The age-adjusted correlation between
predicted and measured
O2max
was 0.92 (SEE ±1.9 mL · kg-1 ·
min-1) for men13 14 and 0.92 (SEE
±2.2 mL · kg-1 ·
min-1) for women.13 15
Participants (<3.0%) with ambulatory or other contraindications to
maximal treadmill testing completed an Astrand-Ryhming submaximal cycle
ergometry test,16 from which age-corrected17
O2 max was estimated. The
correlation between the predicted age- and sex-corrected
O2 max and that measured
during maximal cycle ergometry was 0.94 (SEE 0.248
L/min).17
For the treadmill tests, a 12-lead ECG and blood pressure were
recorded at rest, during exercise, and during recovery. After an
appropriate warm-up, participants exercised to a volitional end point
or until specific criteria16 to terminate the test were
observed. Maximal effort was seen as achievement of
85%
age-predicted maximal heart rate and perceived exertion of >16 on a
20-point Borg scale.16 During the Astrand-Ryhming tests,
heart rate was obtained from a bipolar CM-5 ECG. Age- and sex-specific
cardiorespiratory fitness quintiles were developed according to
published standards.18
Participants were classified as those with and those without known or
suspected heart disease based on the following criteria: (1)
indication of existing CHD on the medical history questionnaire, (2) a
positive resting or exercise ECG, or (3) demonstrated exercise
intolerance. Exercise intolerance was defined as (1) failure to achieve
85% of age-predicted maximal heart rate or (2) premature termination
of the exercise stress test for reasons other than exhaustion.
Statistical Analyses
Glucose and triglyceride values were log (base 10)
transformed to better approach normality. Other variables
demonstrated small amounts of skewness due to outlying values, but
these outliers were retained in the analyses because of their
possible association with fitness. Linear regression was used to adjust
mean risk factor values for age, percent body fat, smoking status, and
family history of CHD to better assess the independent effect of
fitness. Polynomial trend modeling was used to describe the shape of
the association between risk factors and cardiorespiratory fitness. The
highest-order polynomial term that was significant and the percent
linear variation19 are reported. Logistic regression
models were constructed to evaluate the clinical relevance of the
association between fitness and CHD risk factors. Sample size limited
logistic analyses to men and women without CHD. Fitness
tertiles were formed according to MET levels of maximal exercise
performance20 to enable a comparison with existing
data. CHD risk factors associated with the insulin-resistance
metabolic syndrome were dichotomized as10
Systolic blood pressure (SBP;
140 mm Hg or not),
glucose (
6.1 mmol/L or not), triglycerides
(
1.7 mmol/L or not), and LDL (
3.4 mmol/L or not).
Statistical significance was evaluated with point estimates and the
reported 2-tailed probability or the 95% CI. All analyses were
performed with SPSS-PC+ (Version 6.1).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Risk Factors Across Fitness Levels
Men
Cardiorespiratory fitness was indirectly associated with all CHD
risk factors among men without CHD (Table 3
). Significant linear trends were seen
for SBP, glucose, total cholesterol (TC), LDL, and TC/HDL,
with >90% linear variation in these risk factors across fitness
levels. Triglycerides and HDL demonstrated significant
higher-order associations with fitness, although the largest proportion
of variation in these trends was linear (97.9% and 96%,
respectively). Among men with CHD (data not shown), significant linear
inverse associations were observed between fitness and all CHD risk
factors except HDL.
|
Women
Cardiorespiratory fitness was inversely associated with all CHD
risk factors in women without CHD (Table 4
). However, only HDL demonstrated a
significant linear association with fitness. Among the risk factors
that demonstrated higher-order associations with fitness,
triglycerides and TC/HDL showed large proportions of linear
variation (90% and 67%, respectively) across levels of fitness. Risk
factor values generally improved with higher levels of fitness among
women with CHD (data not shown), among whom significant linear trends
were observed for triglycerides, HDL, and TC/HDL.
|
Logistic Regression Models
The prevalence of clinically relevant risk factor values was
higher among men than women: SBP (15.4% versus 10.9%), glucose (8.6%
versus 3.1%), triglycerides (35.2% versus 20.3%), and
LDL (50.4% versus 33.9%). After adjustment for potential confounders,
significant inverse associations persisted between fitness and all risk
factors except glucose among men (Figure 1
) and between fitness and SBP and
triglycerides among women (Figure 2
).
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cardiorespiratory fitness was favorably associated with CHD risk factors despite a relatively homogeneous cohort and after statistical adjustment for age, percent body fat, smoking status, and family history of heart disease. Our findings are consistent with cross-sectional reports on Aerobics Center Longitudinal Study (ACLS) men6 and women,7 as well as other observational data.8 9 10 Furthermore, associations between fitness and CHD risk factors similar to those seen in the current data have been reported at baseline in prospective studies that have subsequently demonstrated reduced coronary mortality rates in fit versus unfit men and women.23
Extensive reviews have summarized observational and experimental data that show desirable effects of exercise on glycemia24 and resting blood pressure.25 We observed fitness to be strongly and inversely associated with fasting glucose and resting SBP levels even after adjustment for influential variables. This observation has clinical significance because elevated fasting glucose and resting SBP have been suggested as markers for insulin resistance,26 which is known to increase CHD risk by clustering adverse conditions of hyperglycemia, hypertension, and dyslipidemia.27 28 Because skeletal muscle is a large and robust substrate depot for active and fit persons,24 it is not surprising that enhanced fitness appears to protect against elevated blood pressure, glucose, and lipid values.
The extent to which blood lipids were associated with cardiorespiratory fitness among the current cohort is contrary to some studies29 30 but similar to others.6 7 8 9 10 We observed significant inverse linear trends for TC and LDL across fitness levels among men regardless of CHD status. Fitness was favorably and significantly associated with HDL and TC/HDL among women even after adjustment for age and body fat and despite no association between fitness and TC. Among men and women with CHD (data not shown), percent differences in lipid levels between the lowest and highest fitness groups (eg, triglycerides 25% decrease, LDL 12% decrease) were similar to the expected effect of low-dose fibric acid derivatives and HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors.31 Exercise, which is essentially an anabolic agent, is one of few dose-response agents with proven therapeutic effects for many chronic diseases that is not regulated by the Food and Drug Administration.32 Because risk factors synergistically multiply the individual risk of CHD,28 even small risk factor reductions associated with increased fitness could substantially lower the probability of incident CHD.
The homogeneity of the cohort may have resulted in
underrepresentation of the influence of fitness on the
coronary risk profile; therefore, we looked at the relationship
from a clinical perspective. Recent ACLS reports have shown fitness to
be inversely associated with the prevalence10 and
associated mortality risk33 of CHD risk factor clustering.
By applying the criteria used by ACLS investigators, we observed that
low-fit men (Figure 1
) and women (Figure 2
) were 3 to 6
times more likely to have clinically relevant risk factor levels than
their high-fit counterparts. The associations remained significant even
after adjustment for body fat. Our hydrostatic estimate of total body
fat does not precisely quantify the more atherogenic central fat
depot.34 Nonetheless, the current observations support
previous data6 7 8 9 10 24 34 that show enhanced
cardiorespiratory fitness levels confer protection against elevated CHD
risk independent of the influence of body fat.
Recommendations that promote the cardiovascular benefits of physical activity and cardiorespiratory fitness1 2 are potentially limited by little data from low-risk populations.35 Significant inverse associations were reported between baseline self-reported physical activity and fatal coronary events among 27 658 adults after a 6-year follow-up in the Adventist Health Study.35 Potential misclassification on exposure and selection bias reduces the generalizability of these data until other studies confirm the health benefits of physical activity in low-risk populations. Low coronary mortality rates have been reported among Mormons,36 37 including men with lethal genetic predisposition.38 Between 1993 and 1995, Utah ranked first and third nationally for the lowest cardiovascular and CHD death rates, respectively.21 Our cross-sectional findings showed that a large cohort of middle-aged men and women, the majority of whom are Mormon, demonstrated (1) average levels of cardiorespiratory fitness, (2) clinically acceptable values for most CHD risk factors, and (3) inverse associations between fitness and CHD risk factors, regardless of CHD status. These observations are consistent with cross-sectional data from other cohorts,6 7 among whom prospective studies subsequently showed that fitness independently protected against coronary mortality.23 It is therefore plausible that fitness contributes to the low CHD incidence and mortality rates previously described for Utah Mormons.36 37 38 Our findings and those from the Adventist Health Study suggest that physical activity and cardiorespiratory fitness confer substantial cardiovascular benefits, even in low-risk populations of men and women.
The present study has potential limitations that deserve
consideration. Although cardiorespiratory fitness
(
O2 max) was predicted from
time during a maximal treadmill test as opposed to measured aerobic
power, correlations between predicted and measured
O2 max are
large.14 15 Recent evidence of only modest genetic
contributions to cardiorespiratory fitness,39 reported
training gains of up to 30%,16 and rapid
detraining-related losses40 illustrate the plasticity of
cardiorespiratory fitness and should temper genetic arguments against
targeting fitness enhancement for CHD prevention. A recent randomized
trial showed that sedentary or irregularly active individuals can
achieve health-related levels of cardiorespiratory fitness through
regular moderate-intensity lifestyle activities such as brisk
walking.41 Our data lack more precise indices of
coronary risk (eg, regional adiposity, insulin, lipoprotein
subfractions)34 that may have resulted in stronger
associations with fitness. Attempts to control for medications and diet
were not made. Our analyses lacked an index of habitual
physical activity. With some of the variation in cardiorespiratory
fitness not accounted for by genetic or environmental
transmission,39 the level of habitual physical activity
may indeed account for the remainder. Furthermore, differences in risk
estimates for CHD mortality between fitness and physical
activity1 may reflect different mechanisms through which
fitness and activity confer cardiovascular health
benefits.8 32 Last, we see a large need for data on ethnic
minorities and persons with lower socioeconomic status for whom
different levels of physical activity and CHD rates have been
described.1 42
We conclude that cardiorespiratory fitness was significantly and favorably associated with CHD risk factors independent of age, percent body fat, and family history of CHD, and regardless of CHD status, in a low-risk population of middle-aged men and women. These findings support public health recommendations for increased physical activity and cardiorespiratory fitness to prevent the morbidity and mortality associated with CHD.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received November 16, 1999; revision received May 8, 2000; accepted May 11, 2000.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
O2 max, physical activity, and
body fat with chronic exercise: effects on plasma lipids. Med Sci
Sports Exerc. 1997;29:11521159.[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
N-E Thomas, J S Baker, M R Graham, S-M Cooper, and B Davies C-reactive protein in schoolchildren and its relation to adiposity, physical activity, aerobic fitness and habitual diet Br. J. Sports Med., May 1, 2008; 42(5): 357 - 360. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. H. Eckel Preventive Cardiology by Lifestyle Intervention: Opportunity and/or Challenge?: Presidential Address at the 2005 American Heart Association Scientific Sessions Circulation, June 6, 2006; 113(22): 2657 - 2661. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. J. LaMonte, S. N. Blair, and T. S. Church Physical activity and diabetes prevention J Appl Physiol, September 1, 2005; 99(3): 1205 - 1213. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. J. Stewart, D. Badenhop, P. H. Brubaker, S. J. Keteyian, and M. King Cardiac Rehabilitation Following Percutaneous Revascularization, Heart Transplant, Heart Valve Surgery, and for Chronic Heart Failure Chest, June 1, 2003; 123(6): 2104 - 2111. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. J. LaMonte, J. L. Durstine, F. G. Yanowitz, T. Lim, K. D. DuBose, P. Davis, and B. E. Ainsworth Cardiorespiratory Fitness and C-Reactive Protein Among a Tri-Ethnic Sample of Women Circulation, July 23, 2002; 106(4): 403 - 406. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Circulation Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2000 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |